14 ms·
You Might Have an Invisible Facebook Account Even if You Never Signed Up
- tjr 13y agoWhen you install the Facebook app on your phone it requires permission to read your contacts, call log, location, accounts, and application data. Is this true?
- BlackDeath3 13y agoGood thing deleting the pre-installed Facebook application (if it's ever been used at all it was inadvertently) off of my Android phone is quick and easy, and doesn't require root access! EDIT: This is why we need sarcasm tags. No, I have not actually been able to remove my Facebook application.
- mcintyre1994 13y agoHow? Sony Ericsson Xperia Arc S, ICS, locked to my carrier, unrootable. I've been wanting to get rid of it ever since the phone started running out of space all the time, app info gives no option to remove it. Is this a case of my manufacturer/carrier are more annoying than yours, or am I really missing something?
- BlackDeath3 13y agoI was being sarcastic. I'll probably never rid myself of the damn thing.
- mcintyre1994 13y agoDammit, it's really easy on my rooted Touchpad, but this thing's horrible for it. It'd be fine if it had storage space, but nope.
- shocks 13y agoYou can "disable" it through the Applications menu under Settings.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- mcintyre1994 13y agoI had to uninstall updates (the option where disable normally is), and then I could go and disable it, weird. Thanks though, disabled and uses about 1/6 of the space of the updated one :)
- shocks 13y agoExcellent. :) It's not the best solution, the best solution would be the ability to uninstall it completely, but it's better than nothing.
- kamjam 13y agoI was able to root my Arc S (but UK model/unlocked). I seem to recall using this method, but would need look on my PC for the files i used to verify... http://theunlockr.com/2012/10/09/how-to-root-the-sony-xperia-arc-x12/ http://theunlockr.com/2012/10/09/how-to-root-the-sony-xperia...
- reginaldjcooper 13y agoI always have a chuckle when Android users say it's open source and free. iPhone is worse, of course, but still. We all really need an actual FOSS phone that is liberated from the carriers. Maybe Canonical's (modulo Amazon results when searching contacts).
- aestra 13y agoI jumped for joy when my new phone didn't come with preinstalled facebook!
- wnevets 13y agoyes, the facebook android app requires about 20 other permissions
- vaadu 13y agoFirst thing to do on an Android is to go under settings/apps/All and disable the privacy parasites such as the facebook apps(4) and google+.
- joering2 13y agoBut aren't you doing this AFTER you install the app? Which defies the purpose because by the time you turn it off, all your data is transferred.
- ambrop7 13y agoAnyone knows if the preinstalled FB application sends anything to FB even if you've never used it?
- estel 13y agoTheoretically it could, definitely. I don't know if anyone's done the packet sniffing for it.
- king_jester 13y agoIf you are disabling the app in the Applications menu in Settings, the process for that app will not be able launch while disabled, so FB won't be able to collect anything.
- mh- 13y agoon Android, yes
- myko 13y agoIt no longer asks for these things on iOS?
- mh- 13y agoiOS doesn't allow access to most of the items listed. Others are prompt-based and can be disabled/prevented by the user in the iOS privacy settings. http://0.tqn.com/d/ipod/1/0/S/O/-/-/ios-6-privacy.jpg http://0.tqn.com/d/ipod/1/0/S/O/-/-/ios-6-privacy.jpg
- RexRollman 13y agoI use iOS, and don't use Facebook, but you can't selectively disallow Facebook access to things like the address book? It's all or nothing?
- cookingwithrye 13y agoThe lack of fine-grained permissions per app is Android's fault, not Facebook's (not that they aren't benefiting). Android application manifests means that if even just one user of your app might want to use a feature that requires elevated permissions, your entire app must be given these permissions for all users at installation time. Which is obviously a huge security issue. What if I want to use the Facebook app but deny it permission to my address book? Not possible out of the box. E.g. There's a feature to see if any of your phone contacts already have Facebook accounts. To service the potential people that wants this feature to work so they can easily "friend" these people on Facebook, the app must have this permission for everyone who installs it.
- RexRollman 13y agoThanks for the reply. I appreciate the info.
- 13y ago
- dreamfactory 13y agoEven better, it updates your contact book email addresses to facebook domain ones.
- kamjam 13y agoThey had to do that for national security purposes, and you know, the children. </sarc> And yeah, that was very sad. http://news.cnet.com/8301-1023_3-57464415-93/facebook-e-mail-mess-address-books-altered-e-mail-lost/ http://news.cnet.com/8301-1023_3-57464415-93/facebook-e-mail... I never sync Facebook/my contacts, but I do wonder if they steal this info anyway... most likely is my guess, but that's just me being a cynic.
- Tichy 13y agoYes
- deltaqueue 13y agoYes, but this shouldn't come as a shocker to anyone that uses Facebook and Android. You can arrange to have contacts synced in Android so that you can see updates / photos / phone numbers merged with your Google contacts. NSA access notwithstanding, Facebook is in the business of making it easier to interact and socialize with people. Alternatively, you can use the app "Tinfoil" for Facebook, which is essentially a locked-down web browser that provides a watered down Facebook experience.
- jacobquick 13y agoI actually got a peek at Facebook's behavior maybe 5 years ago when I signed up to beta-test a video game. They had used the Facebook login API for their beta forums without marking it on their site, so signing up for the game signed me up for Facebook. Suddenly all the Facebook ads everywhere knew my name. Three weeks and about 40 emails to "update my Facebook profile" that I reported to Gmail as phishing later, I received the dubious honor of being banned from Facebook without ever using it. I threw all their domains into loopback in my hostfile at home and haven't seen their site or ads on that machine since, but if I log into LinkedIn in my work browser it starts all over again, so I've figured for a while there's probably also an account for everyone who has LinkedIn.
- kamjam 13y agoI have the same feeling about LinkedIn! I only recently signed up for LinkedIn, about a year ago, using my GMail address I use for job-hunting purposes. I've had this account since circa-2008 but I ONLY use it for work purposes (since it's a bit more professional sounding). I also have another GMail account which I have had for much longer and shared amongst friend and some old colleagues. When I signed up for LinkedIn, I put in my name and "work" email address and straight away, without me having provided any other piece of information it was suggesting people I may know. It was not possible that it could have shadow guessed this from my email since those colleagues don't have that one, but both my GMail accounts are linked so I wonder if that was the weak point. Definitely something strange going on and it scared me somewhat... I should also note that at no point did I use the "find my friends" type feature and give it access to my GMail to mine my contacts either.
- wouterinho 13y agoProbably based on your IP (range). If 5 people from IP address X work at company Y, chances are you work there as well.
- kamjam 13y agoThis was long after (4 years) I had left the company in question, so nothing to do with IP range. Besides, it was a BIG company, and it fairly accurately found my colleagues that I worked most closely with.
- logn 13y agoI think this might be a good example of how to communicate software architecture to non-technical people. It was informative on that level. And by the end, we saw a full-blown process diagram, with even a loop, of Facebook waiting to create a shadow profile.
- singold 13y agoIt happened to me before I created an account on facebook, that there was a profile with my name but the photo was of another guy. Later I googled "him" (or myself) but found nothing except that photo about "him", it is really weird. Some of my friends already had facebook accounts, so maybe it has something to do with this, maybe it was my not-so-invisible profile...
- greenyoda 13y agoMost probably it was just another guy who happens to have the same name that you have. And if this person has never published anything to the web, he won't show up on a Google search.
- singold 13y agoI thoght that too, but is really strange that he has the same photo five or seven years later.
- jfb 13y agoI find this very creepy, but I think that fundamentally, the idea that my contact info isn't mine, once it's "public", is correct.
- pessimizer 13y agoWhat if that info became "public" because it was conned out of one of your friends, a friend hypothetically fully aware of your distaste for facebook and also someone who would never put any of your info into it consciously, when that friend allowed facebook to access their email/phone contact list to find people on facebook that they knew?
- jfb 13y agoWell, right, which to me points out that we have to learn to cope with the difference between "private" and "public" being fuzzy.
- xpose2000 13y agoLet's think of a typical use case where a "shadow profile" is useful. Let's say my friend Jane is on facebook. She has my phone number on her phone with my first name. Facebook notices that this phone number is not linked to any other accounts, therefore I must not be registered. Fast forward two months, and I decide to sign up for facebook. I put my phone number in (as a form of password recovery I believe) and it automatically asks me if I'd like to add Jane. "Shadow profile" sounds scary, but in actuality it's just the modern web at work.
- jerrya 13y agoNo, that's how modern privacy invasion works. After Facebook scanned Jane's phonebook, and made the invites Jane asked, Facebook should have deleted your phone number.
- mason240 13y agoYou are going to be in for a real shock if you ever see a phone book. Pages upon pages of names matched with phone numbers!
- RobAtticus 13y agoBut a phone book doesn't show connections between people nor have people's unlisted numbers, like somebody's phone contacts might.
- threeseed 13y agoAnd Facebook isn't showing unlisted numbers to the public.
- npsimons 13y agoAnd you're going to be in for a shock if you ever decide to do some research and find out that you can request your name and number to not be listed in a phone book.
- 13y ago
- trebor 13y agoGreat. So all my effort in an attempt to keep my info off Facebook has not paid off; my friends with Facebook apps have "allowed" Facebook to create a ghost profile for me. Thanks a lot, Facebook!
- unreal37 13y agoWhat's a shadow profile? Sounds so sinister. It's probably just a line in a database with your email address and phone number. It's not like Facebook is actively keeping tabs on people that don't have accounts.
- unclebucknasty 13y agoI wouldn't be so sure about that. We know that FB works with third-party companies to track offline purchasing behavior of its users (data which is supposedly anonymized). So, I wouldn't think it a far leap that Facebook might correlate non-member invitee e-mail addresses with, say, the activities/interests of the inviter. This could be happening right now for all we know, or it could happen in the future. Once they have the data, it's their choice.
- mhurron 13y agoThank god there aren't groups out there that are using Facebooks data to do just that. Then we'd have a real problem on our hands.
- greenyoda 13y agoThe profile also probably contains a list of all the Facebook users who had you in their contact lists, and all the photos that you were tagged in. Since such information would get updated every time a Facebook user uploaded your contact information or tagged you, I'd say this qualifies as Facebook actively keeping tabs on you.
- kamjam 13y agoHow do you tag someone if they don't have a Facebook account? AFAIK it's not possible to tag someone with an email address or telephone number? Certainly you can "tag" someone if they are not on Facebook and not in your friends (of friends) list, but it is then just tagged as text, not associated with an account... maybe I missed an option somewhere...
- pessimizer 13y ago
- samspenc 13y agoDoesn't LinkedIn do this too?
- argumentum 13y agoThe main invasion of privacy here is your friend(s) agreeing to give Facebook (a 3rd party) your information without asking or informing you. This is analogous to Facebook giving the government (a 3rd party) your information without asking or informing you.
- dmead 13y agoi brought this up when my family using the "family tree" app a few years ago. they kept marking their familial relations online for all to see, for free and in great detail. needless to say, i was met with blank stares when i brought this up.
- unclebucknasty 13y agoSame here. I barely spend time on FB, but check in once and a while. A while back I received a stream of "family tree" invitations from a relative, who'd noted our relationship via the app. She'd done the same with a bunch of other relatives (who in turn did likewise). None of them meant any harm, but it turned my stomach.
- fsckin 13y agoYou're worried about family tree data? Births, marriages, deaths, etc are all public information. This data should be free and open instead of behind pay walls or locked away in a records office or library. Google combinations of your full name, father/mother and birthdate in various formats and you might be pleasantly surprised how much is out there.
- sp332 13y agoIf they made the data available for free, it might be OK. But really you're just doing free work for a company who's going to lock up the data and sell it.
- pessimizer 13y ago>You're worried about family tree data? Births, marriages, deaths, etc are all public information. Not databased and internetted they're not. The lion's share of that data on living people (not to mention dead people) is probably only on paper, and to get pieces of it often required a written request. Not to Godwin too hard here, but that's exactly the information that the Nazis and IBM used to detect Europeans who were descended from Jews but who didn't self-identify as Jewish.
- mathattack 13y agoIs this any shadier than a credit bureau aggregating data?
- coreyja 13y agoOk so maybe I'm alone here, but this doesn't bother me at all. How is this an invasion on anyone's privacy? They are just using the info a user already gave them access to. Why does it matter if Facebook has information about you you can't see? Is it really surprising that they do? It's not like FB just shows us the DB tables so that we know what info they are storing on us. As programmers we should all understand that there is some data that you keep that doesn't need to be shown to the user but helps make your program run. That's all I see this as.
- tonylemesmer 13y agoIts connection as well as contact information. Who you have been in communication with as well as your contact details.
- TheCowboy 13y agoWhy wouldn't you consider it a violation of privacy simply because another person provided information about you? If you had friends and family who intentionally shared any information you provided in private, you would have no problem with that, and think it should be a generally acceptable societal norm? The idea that any information you share beyond your own mindspace is up for grabs by any method seems bizarre to me. It is simply too inconvenient to live in a way where you give up zero information about yourself to everyone. It shouldn't be a black or white decision when it comes to sharing any information, but it's to the advantage of companies that make money on other people's information to want people to believe such a severe stance on personal information is a reasonable choice people have to face.
- coreyja 13y agoA few days late in my reply, sorry. The distinction I make is that it isn't Facebook that is violating your privacy. Facebook. If anyone is violating your privacy it is your friend/family that is giving the information to Facebook, and I think that in providing this information to Facebook they are violating your privacy, but you shouldn't blame Facebook. My best analogy is the 'guns don't kill people, people kill people' argument. It isn't the gun makers fault if you murder someone, just like it isn't Facebook's fault if someone gives them info about you, you didn't want shared.
- jagira 13y agoI wish Facebook fades into oblivion like Myspace.
- greyfade 13y agoWe'll need a replacement for all the pleebs to use.
- cJ0th 13y agoIn my opinion that is highly unlikely. For one thing, myspace was largely a network of early adopters. Therefore it was not a surprise these people would look for something new soon. For another thing, "everyone" is on facebook and thus it is not convenient to leave. Most people don't like change after all. We all know how long people stuck with IE6 (and that was just a browser). I'd say we have 2+ decades of FB ahead of us.
- drunkenmasta 13y agoThe bigger picture is in terms of Social Network Analysis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_network_analysis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_network_analysis and the fact that companies are able to figure out lots of stuff about you even though you never consented to being a part of their service. Hopefully the next "leak" will be about one of these big companies and what they do with your information.
- alternize 13y agolast year, i - without having a facebook account - tried to get the data facebook might have stored about me through the corresponding EU privacy protection laws. all i got was the answer that they do not compile custom data exports upon request anymore and that i would have login into my facebook account [sic] to any data through some data downloading service... now i wonder if i should have pestered a bit more, i.e. by demanding the release of the possible stored data (which definitely exists seeing the "please join"-spam from some years ago) in writing through snail mail. anyone had any success with that?
- gknoy 13y agoWould you get a lawyer to write the letter? That might be most fruitful.
- seiji 13y agoNone of this is unexpected. If you were making exactly the same service, you would come up with exactly the same evil outcomes. "Hey, we can upload every contact list in the world with no consent then cluster and cross reference every entry behind the scenes!" Sounds fun to me, especially if you have no sense of societal ethics or boundaries (quintuply so if you firmly believe you're changing the world and everybody else only advances at the pace of your unique genius). Imagine the graph the NSA can construct about how people are connected throughout the world. facebook probably has close to exactly the same information based solely on voluntary information coughed up by Social Internet Morons. People aren't trained to think about data and relations and how everything can be sewn together, and that puts them at a gross disadvantage when interacting with global megacorps these days.
- fixermark 13y agoHow does this differ from credit reporting agencies and other forms of legal public spying and data collection?
- wj 13y agoI'm surprised this wasn't widely known. For a couple of years I would get invitations to join Facebook that showed the names and photos of some of my friends (some of who didn't know each other). My problem now is that somebody tried to create an account with one of my email addresses and even though I didn't confirm the account (and contacted Facebook asking them to delete it) I'm now getting emails from Facebook.
- j_s 13y agoThere was a related HN discussion of the fairly recent security vulnerability where Facebook was giving away information about your friends (a shadow profile with additional info on users who hadn't been the ones to give that info to Facebook) when you requested your extended data download: Facebook security bug exposed 6 million users' personal information https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5921092 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5921092
- novum 13y agoIs this it? This is our brave new world of pervasive data gathering, social network analysis, and the dying gasp of any shred of privacy? This is the future we've built for ourselves? I haven't had a facebook account for 3 years. I'm certain FB has a shadow profile for me today and there's nothing I can do about it. My friends don't understand (or don't care about) the implications of everything they do online being tracked, in minute detail, and stored indefinitely. Real-time indefinite mass surveillance is a fact and yet failed to galvanize the public into action. What can I do other than allow the cynicism to take hold and become a recluse? I earn my livelihood from technology. I want to believe technology has great potential for medicine, exploration, and improving the human condition. The cognitive dissonance has to give somewhere.
- pasiaj 13y agoIf 'has your contact info in a database' amounts to a "Shadow Profile", there are quite many shadow profiles of you laying around. It probably has relations to all the people on Facebook who have your contact info added, but overall this is much ado about nothing.
- novum 13y agoBy what measure do you assess "quite many shadow profiles of you laying around" to be "much ado about nothing"? Isn't that exactly the problem? What of one -- and one is all it takes -- company, disaffected employee, or black hat desiring to analyze, filter, or publicize data about me, even in aggregate? What of user preference or control? What of the right to be left alone?
- mtarnovan 13y agoBut how much can others fill in the "blanks" of your shadow profile compared to FB ?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- kintamanimatt 13y ago
- shmerl 13y agoThat's why this is still very relevant: http://betabeat.com/2011/12/in-which-eben-moglen-like-legit-yells-at-me-for-being-on-facebook/ http://betabeat.com/2011/12/in-which-eben-moglen-like-legit-... By merely using Facebook, its users are harming others (i.e. their privacy). And it extends even to those who don't use Facebook themselves.
- Raphmedia 13y agoSerious question here. Why should I care? Convince me why I should close my facebook account. Why I shouldn't purposely feed google with infos. Why I shouldn't answer to phone surveys. Hell. I /like/ having accurate ads on the web. I like reading meaningful spam that sells me the products I want for half the price. Anybody can already look up my name on 411 and get all my infos. Why should I care if the big corps also gather it to sell me meaningful stuff? It's not like they could use magickal voodoo power based on those infos to brainwash me...
- diydsp 13y agoYou meet $g at a caffeinated yogurt startup tasting party. You want to form an intimate relationship with person $g. $g looks you up on SureEros.com and finds a bogus profile for you claiming you actually don't like milk products or stimulants. $g figures you lied to get into $g's pants and you look like a lamer. Race or religion $x takes over a large portion of the local government. You belong to race or religion $y. All of your friends tell facebook you're a $y and their clever algorithm confirms it based on your last name, which you actually only acquired when your father remarried into your stepmother's caffeinated yogurt family enterprise. Local, infiltrated gov't decides to launch a pogrom against $x. They come and get you. You apply for a job at $q. All of your friends have been telling linkedin you're good at $r. You have no profile at linkedin. You show up at the interview. They say, "Well you have lots of $r experience, but we consider that wasted time, you probably picked up bad habits doing $r. We want someone who's spend more time on $q than $r and who doesn't lie about fermented dairy and alkaloids." How do I come up with these scenarios? What is my formula? It's based on an article I once read by a Canadian politician who described the right to privacy as simply the right to not be known before someone actually meets you, to have no false representations before you. (And then I added details about yogurt and caffeine b/c that's what I'm consuming this morning and afternoon.)
- VMG 13y agoYou present a compelling case for having profiles on major social network platforms, with you controlling the shared information. I also don't know why I should desire to work at company $q which is has a completely incompetent hiring department. And governments are pretty good at progroms and determining ethnicities without using social media platforms - they've done this literally since dawn of time. If you add this scenario, you'll need to add the increased sharing of information about the government that is happening through facebook and the fact that governments are banning access to social media whenever they are up to something shady. > the right to privacy as simply the right to not be known before someone actually meets you Then you need to ban gossip as well.
- jonknee 13y agoPinterest and Twitter too. It has gained some mainstream attention recently, I remembering seeing it in the New York Times within the past month.
- ddalex 13y agoOh my god, this is it. I posted a story a while back saying that I receive messages from a FB account created with my email. I suspected that somebody may have made an account with my email by mistake, but FB keeps on sending messages with "you know this guys?" etc, and it's about people I know. So I had a FB shadow account created, it inferred my email (probably through looking up some of my friends address books on their email), and now it keeps trying to make me join FB with that account. This is both creepy and scary. Yet, I'll leave it be because it adds to the noise in the data they have.
- junto 13y agoYou need to make sure you mark every single email like this as spam. Eventually, f we all do this, they will be permanently marked as spammers.
- junto 13y agoThis kind of practice just makes me aggressive against the company that practices it. It builds negative connotations towards Facebook. I guess I am the kind of person that is becoming aggressive in general to invasions of privacy, including personalised advertising. In the long run I'm just going to become deliberately blind to it, even extra negative to companies that use such techniques. As an example, I recently used SkyScanner.net to search for flights. Shortly after I kept being shown ads for the exact flights I searched for on third party sites. Bam, I shall never use skyscanner.net again. These companies will only learn when it affects their bottom line. Period.
- morgante 13y agoI really don't see how this is an issue. Your friends have access to your contact information. When the delegate that access to Facebook, of course Facebook would log in. In fact, I've implemented systems similar to this in any number of apps—it helps to improve the onboarding experience of future users, and honestly isn't giving up any information which wasn't voluntarily shared.
- NicoJuicy 13y agoI'm wondering... If someone requests his data of facebook without him having a facebook account. Facebook has to give him all the information they have about him, right? So, i have facebook :-S, who will request their data. PS. I see a class action lawsuit coming up:)
- pit 13y agoYeah, no shit.
- dylangs1030 13y agoTitle is sensationalist and the article is melodramatic. In terms of threat-level to privacy, this isn't all that egregious. The term "shadow profile" is not one that Facebook itself espouses, it's just added for flair. Clearly, this is making a lot of noise about something that's actually fairly harmless. I would place more blame on the people sharing my data with Facebook than I would blame Facebook for "mapping" interpersonal data. It's really not that big a deal people.
- GoodIntentions 13y agoIf there was a browser plugin that would surf some random innocuous crap in the background for me, with an eye to messing up the data scrape, I'd install it. ( Fly fishing? sure. Country Line dancing? OK. Fancy goldfish? sign me up. ) A three for one ratio of random to real would make the data set pretty much crap for advertising purposes. The only drawback, so far as I see, is wasting bandwidth of sites I don't really visit.
- JanezStupar 13y agoI joined Facebook last year and my profile was 80% done and waiting for me to claim it. It was beyond creepy.
- skeletonjelly 13y agoThat is creepy. To be fair that 80% metric is something that Facebook has "measured" and told you, and is probably gear to coax people into finishing things that are unfinished. Some smart social engineering.
- JanezStupar 13y agoOh no... 80% is my own estimate. I even had pictures of me in the gallery.
- aestra 13y agoHow did they do this? Facial recognition? Did you create a profile, upload one picture, and they said "these might also be you?" How did it work?
- JanezStupar 13y agoPeople tagged me on their photos. From there, facial recognition I guess. I wouldn't really know how else it would happen.
- jschuur 13y agoCould Facebook be storing the email addresses/phone numbers in hashed form? They should not need to hold onto the cleartext one, and if it's hashed, there's no temptation (or danger) of it being used to send unsolicited emails.
- thehme 13y agoaha! there is the term I have been looking for all along, "shadow profile"!. I just knew there was something going on in the back ends that seems to keep me connected even when I was not even connected. Sadly, they (FB) are not the only ones who keep this information around, building up your profile with crumbs left by others. The problem is that we are interconnected and while we can be friends with people who respect our privacy and do not opt in to allow "contacts access" in all apps they install, they themselves may not have friends who think the same. Therefore, you are talking about your friends' friends allowing access to their contacts, which in turn probably exposes you as well and this probability just keeps on increasing with the number of friends/acquaintances you have. It almost seems useless to try to avoid it, but we can hopefully at least push for way to have our shadow profiles cleared completely when requested - by law.