3 ms·
I wonder how much of Musk stepping slightly back from this is the realistic notion that he could spread himself too thin and how much is a realisation that Hype
by prawn 13y ago
I wonder how much of Musk stepping slightly back from this is the realistic notion that he could spread himself too thin and how much is a realisation that Hyperloop could be less of a home run than first thought? Any tough proposal will have its critics or become mired in government/environmental hassle. If it was exceptional, I don't know that it would be released in this way (after a wait, freely, etc).
I'm also curious, if it is a strong concept, as to who will pick up the ball and run with it? People talked about electric vehicles and commercial space exploration for a long, long time before very few people did either as effectively as Musk has done.
One thing that I think he might've overstated is the ability to show up and leave without the waits seen at airports due to security. Even the Eurostar has a security line. Unless baggage was deposited/couriered to a departure point in advance and passengers showed up later?
If it is all the real deal, Sydney-Melbourne would be a good pairing. Ranks as the third highest route for passengers flown if Wikipedia is to be believed.
- alexhawdon 13y agoTaking the baggage separately is an interesting idea and possible solution to the security problems. If the 'Loop is as I'm imagining it (based on scant details, granted) then the actual vehicle components are small, numerous and frequent. Given the short transit time it could be reasonably expected that people carry NO luggage whatsoever and could be quickly processed by a walk through a (potentially computer-operated) backscatter x-ray machine. Luggage runs could be carried in separate vehicles, spaced so that if anything were to 'go off' there would be loss of infrastructure but no loss of life.
- larrydag 13y agoSince Musk said that it was a people transportation concept everyone immediately jumped on that bandwagon. The hyperloop could be a concept that disrupts the cargo train market. I could see GE taking a look at this concept with the idea of improved cargo transport.
- prawn 13y agoIt's pitched as a better option than a bullet train so I think it's safe to assume the primary thrust is transporting people.
- marssaxman 13y agoWhat would be the market for transporting cargo at the speed of sound, and why would anyone able to afford such a service prefer a train to a jet?
- prawn 13y agoEven hand luggage would hold things up and I can't see this being a good option without at least hand luggage. Without it you'd rule out almost every commuter (handbags, laptops, etc). And if the infrastructure is a tube, then damaged infrastructure would grind everything to a halt for some time. Still, something more like a train would still avoid the headache of boarding and taxiing that you get with a flight.
- alexhawdon 13y agoMaybe I'm overcomplicating this: if the vehicles were small, well-spaced and able to stop in the event of a failure ahead of them then the impact that any one passenger could have is equivalent of getting in a car and causing a bad collision on a motorway. Obviously a Very Bad Thing, but if we feel it necessary to protect against that then we might as well write off transport altogether! Anyway, enough speculation from me - I'll patient wait for Elon to finish his breakfast and press 'go' on the release.(Very frustrating!)
- prawn 13y agoWouldn't an explosion in a tunnel two metres wide be likely to destroy the tunnel? In that case, it'd be more akin to destroying a motorway/bridge. Road's going to be out of action for a while.
- gsnedders 13y agoThe Eurostar is unique in terms of high speed rail in that it has any sort of security check, to the best of my knowledge. Anywhere else, even for international journeys, you merely turn up for the time the train is due to depart, as with any other train service. (In the Eurostar's defence, given a highest class ticket, you merely have to pass through the automated check-in gates ten minutes prior to arrival, and half an hour is the furthest deadline, for the lowest class tickets. I'm unaware of any major airport that expects you to be able to get from check-in to the gate in half an hour.) Regardless, the Eurostar security is utter nonsense anyway — especially given you're allowed to take almost everything onboard! It makes a whole load of hassle for nothing. At least at airports they're actively stopping you from taking a fair amount of stuff… It seems like the right solution here is to drop the security, rather than anything more drastic! [Edit: oh, looking this up, they appear to have changed this. They now have most of the same restrictions as air flights do.]
- prawn 13y agoTravelled on Eurostar a few weeks ago (London-Paris) and there were security queues at St Pancras plus an immigration gate. Almost missed the train. Security queues with full luggage are a bit unwieldy when you also have a 1yo in a pram!