5 ms·
This is deeply enormous - if it can make the leap from lab to field. Nitrogen fixing in factories costs something like 5% of global energy, the run off is horr
by lifeisstillgood 13y ago
This is deeply enormous - if it can make the leap from lab to field. Nitrogen fixing in factories costs something like 5% of global energy, the run off is horrific and delivery spotty. There are a lot of hurdles first though.
The one thing that worries me, is years back Dubbya said something like "I'm not worried about global warming, those scientists will invent something". I laughed at the feeble excuse to avoid Kyoto - but now ... Bush may have been right.
- hrkristian 13y ago[Insert free market rant here] No but really, while science can work magic with the proper motivation, that's no excuse to ditch conferences on legitimate concerns. It's like the saying goes, work hard and apply yourself and you'll get somewhere. I've always thought that applied to the environment as well.
- gjm11 13y agoI don't see (1) how this would solve the problem of global warming, or (2) if it did, how it could possibly be worse for Bush to have been right than for the problem of global warming to go unsolved. [EDITED to add: or (3) how, even if it turns out that this does solve the problem of global warming, it would have justified Bush in blowing off warnings about that problem. Saying "I am not worried about X, because scientists will solve it somehow" is generally not a sensible thing to say if X is a big problem and no concrete solution is in sight, and it doesn't become sensible even if it turns out that scientists do solve it in the end.]
- iaskwhy 13y agoI find it strange how we frame global warming as something that might or not happen but the causes of it are already upon us with the heavy levels of pollution in the air and all its consequences. There's really no excuse to be pro-pollution with or without global warming. Bush was deeply wrong.
- lifeisstillgood 13y ago> ... Bush may have been right. I saw the attitude had two parts - "We will soon invent a technical solution" and "so, we don't need to alter our behaviour" The first part seems to be true -surprisingly. The second part, might also be true. That worries me. If the whole planet altered its behaviour slightly to become vegan, most energy, water and agricultural crises will vanish. Instead we invent lab-grown beef. Economics seems to be the science of individual behaviour and crowd behaviour. Every long lived and successful person or company seems to recognise moderating ones own behaviour leads to more sensible restrained wants and needs. Franklin might be a good example. I guess I am saying I worry that technology is enabling in the co-dependence sense of the word, humanities worst excesses - and that it is feasible for politicians to support that.
- freehunter 13y agoThe whole world becoming vegan would not be a slight behavior modification. That would be a huge shift in the behaviors we evolved to have, which is the eating of both meat and plants. The reason people like eating meat is because we evolved to find meat delicious.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoI'd say we evolved to find just about any source of protein delicious, simply because we need protein and finding it delicious confers a selection advantage. Meat is one such source. So we didn't really evolve to eat meat and plants (and mushrooms), we evolved to eat whatever was available.
- freehunter 13y agoTrue. We evolved to find protein tasty, and we evolved the ability (digestive system and teeth) to eat meat as one protein source.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoI searched a little and apparently the evolution of a specific ability to eat meat is something that people fight about: http://paleohacks.com/questions/56542/humans-werent-designed-to-eat-meat http://paleohacks.com/questions/56542/humans-werent-designed... I'm not sure it's even possible to have a reasonable discussion about it because it seems tied up with the question of whether veganism is righteous or idiotic.
- acheron 13y agoSo you are "worried" about a possible world-changing breakthrough because you'd have to admit one of your political opponents was right? Reminds me of people who still seem disappointed that Reagan didn't start a nuclear war like they kept claiming he would.