9 ms·
Technology enables crops to take nitrogen from the air
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoThis is deeply enormous - if it can make the leap from lab to field. Nitrogen fixing in factories costs something like 5% of global energy, the run off is horrific and delivery spotty. There are a lot of hurdles first though. The one thing that worries me, is years back Dubbya said something like "I'm not worried about global warming, those scientists will invent something". I laughed at the feeble excuse to avoid Kyoto - but now ... Bush may have been right.
- hrkristian 13y ago[Insert free market rant here] No but really, while science can work magic with the proper motivation, that's no excuse to ditch conferences on legitimate concerns. It's like the saying goes, work hard and apply yourself and you'll get somewhere. I've always thought that applied to the environment as well.
- gjm11 13y agoI don't see (1) how this would solve the problem of global warming, or (2) if it did, how it could possibly be worse for Bush to have been right than for the problem of global warming to go unsolved. [EDITED to add: or (3) how, even if it turns out that this does solve the problem of global warming, it would have justified Bush in blowing off warnings about that problem. Saying "I am not worried about X, because scientists will solve it somehow" is generally not a sensible thing to say if X is a big problem and no concrete solution is in sight, and it doesn't become sensible even if it turns out that scientists do solve it in the end.]
- iaskwhy 13y agoI find it strange how we frame global warming as something that might or not happen but the causes of it are already upon us with the heavy levels of pollution in the air and all its consequences. There's really no excuse to be pro-pollution with or without global warming. Bush was deeply wrong.
- lifeisstillgood 13y ago> ... Bush may have been right. I saw the attitude had two parts - "We will soon invent a technical solution" and "so, we don't need to alter our behaviour" The first part seems to be true -surprisingly. The second part, might also be true. That worries me. If the whole planet altered its behaviour slightly to become vegan, most energy, water and agricultural crises will vanish. Instead we invent lab-grown beef. Economics seems to be the science of individual behaviour and crowd behaviour. Every long lived and successful person or company seems to recognise moderating ones own behaviour leads to more sensible restrained wants and needs. Franklin might be a good example. I guess I am saying I worry that technology is enabling in the co-dependence sense of the word, humanities worst excesses - and that it is feasible for politicians to support that.
- freehunter 13y agoThe whole world becoming vegan would not be a slight behavior modification. That would be a huge shift in the behaviors we evolved to have, which is the eating of both meat and plants. The reason people like eating meat is because we evolved to find meat delicious.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoI'd say we evolved to find just about any source of protein delicious, simply because we need protein and finding it delicious confers a selection advantage. Meat is one such source. So we didn't really evolve to eat meat and plants (and mushrooms), we evolved to eat whatever was available.
- freehunter 13y agoTrue. We evolved to find protein tasty, and we evolved the ability (digestive system and teeth) to eat meat as one protein source.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoI searched a little and apparently the evolution of a specific ability to eat meat is something that people fight about: http://paleohacks.com/questions/56542/humans-werent-designed-to-eat-meat http://paleohacks.com/questions/56542/humans-werent-designed... I'm not sure it's even possible to have a reasonable discussion about it because it seems tied up with the question of whether veganism is righteous or idiotic.
- acheron 13y agoSo you are "worried" about a possible world-changing breakthrough because you'd have to admit one of your political opponents was right? Reminds me of people who still seem disappointed that Reagan didn't start a nuclear war like they kept claiming he would.
- moconnor 13y agoSo, plants able to do this have a strong evolutionary advantage over many other plant species on this planet? Nah, couldn't possibly go wrong.
- VLM 13y agoStrong evolutionary DIS-advantage compared to non-fixing plants in any non-nitrogen-deficient soil. Doesn't matter if you fix nitrogen in a chemical plant or a plant root, it takes lots and lots of energy. Its a natural ecological cycle like many others with oscillations and such. Given a couple decades, a soil saturated with nitrogen would probably result in the non-fixers wiping out the fixers. The more flippant answer is it can't be any worse than Kudzu. Kudzu is an edible (edible by goat standards) nitro-fixer that is eating the south. I would guess that issuing a human edible competitor to Kudzu would be a net win? Cover the American North with kudzu-like layer of super-wheat wouldn't be so bad...
- rthomas6 13y agoTechnically I think Kudzu is human-edible. I don't know how good it tastes, but I know you can eat it.
- garysweaver 13y agoAlso fit for livestock, but difficult to bale. And used medicinally (anti-inflammatory, antimicrobial to treat headaches, tinnitus, vertigo, Wei syndrome, alcoholism and hangover), and even for basketry. Unfortunately, the U.S. just considers it a nuisance and doesn't take advantage of it.
- jlgreco 13y ago"I, for one, welcome our new soybean overlords."? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soybean#Nitrogen-fixing_ability http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soybean#Nitrogen-fixing_ability
- Blahah 13y agoThis could be a world-changer if managed properly. I therefore think it's a great shame to see this being commercially licensed. The research was at least partly charitably funded: Cocking has had Leverhulme Trust money (http://link.springer.com/article/10.1079%2FIVP2005716 http://link.springer.com/article/10.1079%2FIVP2005716). I find it remarkable that he's pursuing a for-profit commercialisation. Others have commented about the 'strong evolutionary advantage' this will convey crop species. I think that unlikely: a large number of species in the Fabaceae family (legumes) have the ability to form symbioses with nitrogen-fixing bacteria, and this simply allows them to exist on nutrient poor soil. But because it's a symbiosis, i.e. the plant trades some of the sugar it produces for the nitrate fixed by the bacteria, it's not a cost-free situation. Legumes don't dominate many habitats, but they do OK in very nutrient poor soils. Modern crops don't perform well outside intensively nurtured field conditions. N-fixed crops will require less intensive nitrogen supplementation than before, but they will still perform poorly when competing against wild plants.
- twic 13y agoI wouldn't be surprised if part of the condition of the grant was that any inventions should be commercialised, and some of the ownership of the invention transferred back to the funding body. If a charitable body like the Leverhulme Trust can recoup some of its investment, that enables it go on and fund even more research. If the commercialisation involves extracting money from people who will gladly pay it to get better crop yields or lower fertiliser costs - like industrialised farmers in the first world - then it seems like a perfectly reasonable thing to do. What would be a real shame is if the prices were set so that people in the third world could not use this advance to keep themselves and each other from falling into food poverty. However, food shortage is rarely about production capacity, and more often about allocation. Amartya Sen's work and all that.
- Blahah 13y agoI agree that may be the case in general, but the Leverhulme trust explicitly doesn't fund research whose purpose is commercialisation (http://www.leverhulme.ac.uk/funding/RPG/RPG.cfm http://www.leverhulme.ac.uk/funding/RPG/RPG.cfm). Your second and third points are very good ones; it all depends on the implementation. I join you in hoping for a licensing strategy that maximises the social benefit of the technology.
- BetaCygni 13y agoMy fathers(!) PhD thesis was about this (in peas). Not much has happened since then. Nitrogen based fertilizer is inexpensive enough and famine is usually caused by war or other instability.
- Blahah 13y agoThis process happens naturally in peas, in small nodules which grow out from the roots. A huge amount has happened since 'then' (assuming your father did his PhD prior to about 1990. We can now induce many major crop species which don't naturally enter into symbioses with nitrogen-fixing bacteria to do so in every cell, not just in accessory root nodules. This is huge.
- BetaCygni 13y agoYes, it is very interesting but I don't think it will be "world changing".
- Blahah 13y agoWhy do you think it won't? To respond to the brief points you made in the earlier comment: At the moment inorganic nitrogenous fertilizers are cheap. They are derived from the methane in natural gas by the Haber-Bosch process, so the price of fertilizers is tied to natural gas supply. Estimates vary, but we probably only have about 60 years of natural gas supply left when you factor in the increasing use and near-peak production (according to the 2013 International Energy Outlook [1]). And the extraction methods are becoming more environmentally challenging: fracking and shale gas are the natural gas sources of the future. The food-price effects of that will be felt as soon as we pass peak gas production. So we need a new way of fixing nitrogen in the near future. Secondly, while much famine is caused by war, there are many other causes, and hunger is more widespread than famine. Increasing world population, especially in poorer areas, and a complete failure to make any progress so far in fixing the inequality-related causes of hunger mean technological crop solutions are likely to be important in feeding the future population. [1]: http://www.eia.gov/forecasts/ieo/index.cfm http://www.eia.gov/forecasts/ieo/index.cfm
- smackay 13y agoPerhaps Professor Cocking should have read James Lovelock's "Gaia: A new look at life on earth" first. "The day came for the tropical trial at the field station in Northern Queensland. A culture of P. eegarii was without ceremony sprayed in diluted form upon a small patch of experimental rice paddy. But here the bacterium forsook its contrived marriage with the cereal plants {40} and formed a more exciting but adulterous union with a tough and self-sufficient blue-green alga growing on the water surface of the paddy field. They grew happily together, doubling in numbers every twenty minutes in the warm tropical environment, the air and soil providing all they needed. Small predatory organisms would normally have ensured a check on such a development, but this combination was not to be stopped. Its capacity to gather phosphorus rendered the environment barren for everything else. Within hours, the rice paddy and those around it took on the appearance of a ripe duck pond covered with lurid iridescent green scum. It was realized that something had gone badly wrong and the scientists soon uncovered the association of P. eegarii and the alga. Foreseeing the dangers with rare promptness, they arranged that the entire paddy area and the water channels leading from it be treated with a biocide and the growth destroyed. That night, Dr Eeger and his Australian colleagues went late to bed, tired and worried. The dawn fulfilled their worst fears. The new bloom, like some living verdigris, covered the surface of a small stream a mile away from the paddies and only a few miles from the sea. Again, every agent of destruction was applied wherever the new organism might have travelled. The director of the Queensland station tried desperately but in vain to persuade the government to evacuate the area at once and use a hydrogen bomb to sterilize it before the spread was beyond all possibility of control. In two days the algal bloom had started to spread into the coastal waters, and by then it was too late. Within a week the green stain was clearly visible to airline passengers flying six miles above the Gulf of Carpentaria. Within six months more than half of the ocean and most of the land surfaces were covered with a thick green slime which fed voraciously on the dead trees and animal life decaying beneath it." EDIT: Added full title of the book.
- Blahah 13y agoFirstly, it's extremely likely that Cocking has read Lovelock's Gaia. Secondly, Lovelock made that story up: there is no Dr Eeger nor a P. eegarii. It's a fantastical situation unmatched by anything ever recorded in nature (except cancer, which is exactly what it was supposed to be a metaphor for). Thirdly, the technology is being extensively tested, and will be more so before it gets regulatory approval.
- dnautics 13y ago[reposting my comment from a lower level] "Traditional" nitrogen fixing bacteria make their way to specialized nodules. Basically this is because the nitrogenase enzyme is incredibly oxygen-sensitive, and it's quite difficult to shield the interior of the enzyme selectively against oxygen (oxygen and nitrogen look awfully alike from a physical perspective). Inside a nodule, the plant maintains an anaerobic condition that protects the bacteria from oxygen, which for some reason plants like to produce. Not surprisingly, these nodules tend to be in the roots (which, from a naive design point of view would not necessarily be where you would think of grabbing nitrogen from). Added efficiency is critical, because nitrogenase is already a VERY inefficient enzyme. 16!! ATP + N2 -> 2ammonia + hydrogen! There are often enzymes in these bacteria whose purpose is to recycle the wasted energy from the hydrogen produced from nitrogenase. Upshot, without some serious plant engineering, at the very least using aggressive husbandry techniques, it's likely this tech will hit a hard ceiling in terms of usefulness.
- Blahah 13y ago[Also reposting, from the thread of your other comment...] This problem is already solved in C4 plants, which account for many crops (sugarcane, maize, sorghum, barley, etc.). C4 photosynthesis creates an anoxic environment in bundle sheath cells to stop RuBisCO wastefully fixing oxygen instead of CO2. So nitrogenase, suffering as it does from the same oxygen discrimination problem as RuBisCO, will operate efficiently in BS cells. C4 is being introduced to more crops, and that's what I'm working on. So, two birds with the same fistful of stones.
- dnautics 13y agoAssuming your bacteria make intracellularly into those particular cells. That might require a lot of luck, or reengineering those plants or the bacteria.