3 ms·
TBH I wished the UK fingerprinted all visitors to the UK as well. Might help with illegal immigration.
by gadders 13y ago
TBH I wished the UK fingerprinted all visitors to the UK as well. Might help with illegal immigration.
- mikecsh 13y agoUpvoted because I don't see why you should be downvoted for expressing an opinion, people should engage you via the comments instead. I see your point, but I disagree with the wholesale collection of fingerprints.
- DanBC 13y agoI'm guessing he was downvoted for the weirdness: Fingerprinting people flying into New York airports on holiday does nothing to prevent people illegally crossing the Mexican / American border.
- Ntrails 13y agoMost illegal immigrants enter the UK conventionally and then do not leave when visas expire. There are certainly some hiding in the back of lorries etc - but it's not the majority. So fingerprinting them means for sure that we know they came in. I'm not sure what that achieves though?
- rjsw 13y agoIt would remove the current Catch-22 situation where they can be shown to be here illegally but can't be deported due to lack of a passport indicating their country of origin. I don't know whether the problem is big enough to warrant this step though.
- gadders 13y agoNo, but it would prevent people giving false information when suspected of overstaying their visa. It would also enable people to be identifed if they try and make several attempts to enter the UK via different methods. EG once legitimately, and once caught under a lorry.
- madaxe 13y agoCould you please explain why? How will fingerprinting people entering the country legally through registered ports combat people entering the country illegally in the back of lorries?
- AlexMuir 13y agoA fairly common thing is for asylum seekers to lie about their age perhaps to support an application. (See also, claiming they are 17 when charged with crimes so that they can face youth justice.) Some of these people have been into the country legally on student/tourist visas, and then come back and stayed illegally. If you can match someone who claims to have arrived from a war ravaged Afghanistan with someone who flew into Heathrow two years ago to study at Thames Valley Uni then you know their claim is BS.
- madaxe 13y agoThat makes sense - although we already do this, and it's not limited to fingerprinting - includes biometric information, including iris imaging and so-forth. You'd also be amazed at just how many people still make it over in the back of trucks. Don't know if it amounts to a majority, but talking to a few friends who drive trucks across Eurasia, pretty much every time they do a France -> UK crossing someone either sneaks, or tries to sneak, into the lorry. Common tactic is cutting the pull cord around the edge and resealing it with a lighter, or cutting a hole in the top of the canvas. I actually subscribe to the camp of "let them come", as I don't believe in nation-state protectionism as a concept, but find the topic as a whole fascinating, from the economic level down to the human.
- stephengillie 13y agoYou want your economy to shrink? Illegal immigration is all that has kept the US economy growing since the 1970s, and probably the UK economy too.
- ronaldx 13y agoHow would that help with illegal immigration? Illegal immigrants typically arrive legally and are said to contribute a great deal to the economy (perhaps since they can't depend on support).
- w_t_payne 13y agoAaahh! The illusion of control! How sweet.