4 ms·
Gods, could the NSA get any more short-sighted? Once they started tapping into all of this data, how long did they think they could keep it secret, especially w
by javajosh 13y ago
Gods, could the NSA get any more short-sighted? Once they started tapping into all of this data, how long did they think they could keep it secret, especially when tens of thousands of contractors knew about the program? Once the news leaked, what did they think other countries were going to do?
Whenever people in power setup perfect systems of abuse, the people being abused will change that system by going out-of-band.
- miga 13y agoSome say that privacy will disappear in this century anyway. Nice book about it is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Database_Nation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Database_Nation
- bowlofpetunias 13y agoThe short abstract at Wikipedia states the opposite if what you're stating: "His most important point is that the right to privacy is a constitutionally protected right and it does not have to be traded away for our way of life." Unlike other forms of "progress", the disappearing of privacy is very much a choice. Yes, we're on the back foot at the moment when it comes to regulating the way technology is (ab)used, but those of us with a functioning democracy still have ample opportunity to fight back. Also: "He calls the government to take a stand for privacy by establishing an agency that will enforce privacy laws and act as a representative of individual privacy." I presume this is an American perspective. Each EU country for instance is obliged to have such an agency.
- Gormo 13y ago>> "He calls the government to take a stand for privacy by establishing an agency that will enforce privacy laws and act as a representative of individual privacy." > Each EU country for instance is obliged to have such an agency. This sounds like a good way to create a centralized clearinghouse for abuse and corruption via regulatory capture. The viable solution here will be to develop and use technologies that protect privacy as part of their inherent design; relying on the oversight of bureaucracies, especially political ones, to protect privacy just isn't going to work.
- DanBC 13y agoI want to subscribe to a print magazine. I send my payment to them, with my name and address. Each month they send me a magazine. At the end of the year they send me a couple of reminders. What technologies will protect my information? Here, the magazine has to register. They need to say what information they're collecting, and why. There are penalties if they then do other stuff with the information.
- Gormo 13y agoYour name and address are already matters of public record, anyway. This is hardly the kind of data that we're talking about. For important, sensitive data - the kind of stuff that could someone could use to blackmail or manipulate you - the relevant technology is cryptography. The bureaucratic solution will inevitably end in anyone you send any data to being required by law to transfer the data itself to a central government-run data store which will make PRISM look trivial in comparison.
- DanBC 13y agoI was responding to this - >> Each EU country for instance is obliged to have such an agency. > This sounds like a good way to create a centralized clearinghouse for abuse and corruption via regulatory capture. The EU has these agencies. You said > The bureaucratic solution will inevitably end in anyone you send any data to being required by law to transfer the data itself to a central government-run data store Which hasn't happened in the EU.
- Gormo 13y ago> Which hasn't happened in the EU. As far as you know.
- mtgx 13y agoThis is the problem with having so much unchecked power. It's extremely tempting to abuse it and take full advantage of the benefits it gives you, and not think of the consequences years down the road, because you know you have the whole government backing you (even if it's unconstitutional) - at least at the time.
- dhimes 13y agoIt's not even abuse in the sense that it will be done with evil intent.. It is, in fact, a natural consequence that even good people will do 'bad things' when put in the position. Imagine the following: You, mtgx, are put in charge of protecting the mid-Atlantic states from an attack. You have been given complete access to all of the legally obtained intelligence that the nation has about the region and potential conspirators for said attack. Do you not use it? What are your options? If you don't use it, and the attacks are successful, it will be your fault. You will have to live with the knowledge that your inaction, for whatever higher purpose, cost those lives. I posit that even good people like you would take all of the steps you have available to do your job. Even if by day you are writing letters to the editors begging the nation to take those powers away from you. For a reak example, look no farther than what happened in the case of the Boston Marathon bomber Tamerlan Tsarnaev. It turns out that we had a lot of intelligence on him; the Russians even alerted us that he was trouble. And yet, we did not feel we had enough evidence to invade his privacy. We didn't stop him (this is why I think that the people doing this are basically trying to do the right thing). And when we found out after the bombing that this could have been stopped? The shit hit the fan: People were declaring the FBI/CIA incompetent, etc. The main reason to act on this privacy issue is to help the good people who have to do these jobs, not to stop evil people. The rules are now such that good people have to do evil things in order to be good. We want to keep this in mind so that we solve the right problem.