5 ms·
Julia and Python: a dynamic duo for scientific computing [video]
- astrieanna 13y agoI'm very impressed by the smoothness of the Julia-Python interoperation they demonstrate here. The IPython implementation (IJulia) has made a lot of progress since then and is really cool.
- coolsunglasses 13y agoClojure and Incanter have served me well in the place of Python and R lately.
- jparmer 13y agoWe're thinking about adding a Julia API: https://plot.ly/api https://plot.ly/api Hit us up if you'd like to be a part of this or have input. And hey, we're also hiring: https://plot.ly/jobs https://plot.ly/jobs
- daemonk 13y agoNice. I know plenty of biologists who would love to have a simple to use interface for making publication ready figures. Excel just isn't cutting it anymore with the complexity of the data we get today. Hope you guys will still be hiring when I graduate next year. This sounds like a really fun project to work on.
- cabacon 13y agoTo be fair, I haven't used Julia, but I have heard it suggested as an open-source replacement for Matlab/Octave. To that end, I hope it turns out well. When I was looking to see where the project was at, I got nervous when I read a recent thread on the -dev mailing list: https://groups.google.com/d/msg/julia-dev/2JcZdFKisis/Ag9rBJrrqQQJ https://groups.google.com/d/msg/julia-dev/2JcZdFKisis/Ag9rBJ... In particular, the line "[...] I suspect that isequal should be transitive (it has to be for hashing to work), while == will not be transitive. We still need some coherent theory of what == means." made me wince. If one of the benefits that the video makes for Julia over Python is a type system, then there ought to be a pretty well-developed sense of how promotion and equality between types is going to work. That seems like a piece of the language whose theoretical underpinnings should have been nailed down already.
- tomrod 13y agoHave you considered pointing this out to them? Perhaps the people in the project are unaware that this is a solved problem.
- cabacon 13y agoNot really - the discussion on the thread makes it sound like the kind of thing that comes up from time to time anyway. If I had to guess, I'd expect that it happened based on the mission of making something that was good enough to replace matlab, and going from the matlab interface people were used to and working backwards, rather than starting from a concept of what a language ought to be like and working forwards. Given my understanding of their aim and the kinds of things I have read about Matlab at http://abandonmatlab.wordpress.com/ http://abandonmatlab.wordpress.com/, I suspect that "close enough to matlab to have people jump ship" and "first-principles CompSci" language aren't really going to intersect very hard. Given the low popularity of some of the first-principles programming languages, that may be okay? That said, I'm encouraged to see so many people interested in it and contributing to it. My perspective, though, is that of a C/Fortran HPC person who is cheering for things that will help people move to a more scalable coding environment. I was looking at Julia to see if it was an alternative to Octave for university users; the impression I got was that it was still too subject to change to recommend at this point.
- carterschonwald 13y agohehe, then it'd interest you to know I'm working on writing HPC grade numerical tools in Haskell. I'm actually a few weeks away from doing a preview release even (terrifyingly enough). [edit: and the preview release will include some cute simple SIMD codes i've written, not the optimal ones, but a really nicely written set none the less.]
- jamesjporter 13y agoI (and I'm guessing some of the people involved with Julia) would argue that regardless of how good the numerical programming tools are, you'll never get the average working scientist to use Haskell. That sounds like an interesting project though, I've become curious lately about the prospects for integrating high performance numerical computing with functional programming.
- Mikeb85 13y agoIt's interesting. When Julia first came onto the scene, it seemed everyone was gung-ho to rewrite everything in Julia. Now they've capitulated and are simply incorporating Python bits...