3 ms·
In the US the private sector spends several times what the government spends on R&D and that gap has been growing continuously since the 1950s when the US gover
by jandrewrogers 13y ago
In the US the private sector spends several times what the government spends on R&D and that gap has been growing continuously since the 1950s when the US government did spend more than the private sector. Now government funded R&D is a small piece of the pie. Academic R&D has been shrinking in many areas. The biggest growth area in the US is non-profit R&D foundations that focus on areas that all three of the other sources tend to ignore.
Where R&D money is focused is a matter of goals and incentives. Private companies invest in R&D that can add long-term value to their core business and are unlikely to invest in R&D that in an area where no business currently exists (perhaps due to a lack of foundational R&D). Governments invest in R&D to achieve political objectives. In some cases this means investing in foundational R&D that private R&D can build upon. In many cases though, government R&D follows fashion because it has little incentive to return value. It will over-invest in areas with low ROI but great PR value while studiously ignoring high ROI R&D that does not seem as sexy. The growth of R&D by non-profit foundations has been in part to address those areas of R&D that businesses have no incentive to invest in and which are also politically unfashionable such that the government will never invest in them.
Academic R&D has been faltering for some time partly because its role is being better served and better funded by the growing investment in private R&D labs by companies. Consequently, there has been a selection effect where many of the most productive pure researchers have been absorbed by companies that can offer compelling research environments and high pay but it is reducing the average quality of what remains in academia. Importantly, the R&D that is done in private labs is often treated as trade secrets and rarely published, which in many domains has created a growing gap where the work being done in private labs is years ahead of what is being done in academia. I see this all the time for computer science.
The R&D ecosystem in the US is quite complex. Right now, there is a slow, large-scale shift toward private R&D. Ironically, this is enabled in part by how inexpensive and widely available many kinds of high technology have become.