4 ms·
Let's see if I have that right: * The designer did it, not me! * I argued with him for months and ended up saying "ah, screw it". * Ubuntu and Gnome do it to
by asveikau 13y ago
Let's see if I have that right:
* The designer did it, not me!
* I argued with him for months and ended up saying "ah, screw it".
* Ubuntu and Gnome do it too!
I don't see any of these as exculpatory. Not that what you've done is necessarily wrong per se, I'd just rather you come by it honestly. I don't think any of these designs (or for example some of the icons - or even the decision to group elements into these categories) are "inevitable".
- asveikau 13y agoThis is one thing that frustrates me about Hacker News, and why I am considering just not bothering with this site in the future. Anytime I am honest about my reactions to stuff, along come the downvoters. You cannot justifiably call people on bullshit, vacuousness, "buck-passing", intellectual laziness, or anything like that. You just have to let everybody else's bullshit slide, or pad your criticism with passive aggressive nonsense and pats on the back ("good job, brah"), and sing kumbaya and talk about javascript and entrepreneurship or whatever bullshit. What kind of "hacker" community does not allow room for the occasional independent thought expressed with a hint of abrasiveness? I welcome downvotes from passive aggressive screwballs on this site. They are a badge of honor.
- workbench 13y agoHonestly don't understand why we can't call them out on this. > Did we actively intend for it to be reminiscent of OS X? Absolutely not This statement is a total lie.
- aroman 13y agoThe reason you can't "call us out on it" is because it simply isn't a lie. You may feel differently, but (if it matters), I give you my word that we did not intend for it to look like OS X. As others have pointed out, I never said that it isn't in fact reminiscent of OS X, or that we did not evaluate the design of OS X along with a handful of other platforms when we created our designs. The argument here is about intent, not the result. And there's positively no way you can prove the former, as much as you might dislike the latter. (I would be happy to describe in greater detail the design process if it might help convince you that we didn't set out with the intention of copying OS X.)