4 ms·
> Theoretically, an all-knowing Philosopher King would be the best form of government. Just as certain ciphers are mathematically flawless but can still be def
by jacques_chester 13y ago
> Theoretically, an all-knowing Philosopher King would be the best form of government.
Just as certain ciphers are mathematically flawless but can still be defeated by side-channel attacks, certain forms of government are apparently perfect but suck in practice.
The idea of philosopher kings comes from Plato's Republic. I encourage you to read it. He lays out a vision for a totalitarian state in which a specialist Guardian class governs, partly in secret, according to the highest and noblest of intentions.
But consider: you've given these folks unlimited power because you have unlimited trust in their goodness, education and training (Plato lays out a 30-year curriculum).
1. What happens if someone usurps them or there is a coup?
The population, who are used to a government with unlimited powers, might simply shrug and accept it.
2. What kind of person plans such a coup?
Freaking psychopaths.
3. What happens if there is a irresolvable dispute between the Guardians?
A voting mechanism? I guess not, since we're not using democracy. Let's appoint a single arbiter.
4. Who chooses the arbiter?
Oh please, now you're just being ...
5. So who is actually in charge?
The Guardians, still.
6. What if the arbiter bribes one Guardian to always disagree, meaning all disputes are referred for arbitration?
Well I guess you've got a de facto single philosopher-king now.
7. What happens if someone usurps them or there is a coup?
Well shit. I guess that didn't last very long. I guess we need some sort of countermeasures to prevent that. Some sort of policing body, able to gather intelligence on such plots from within the community. I guess they couldn't reveal their intentions in public.
8. What are the incentives for the people who disagree?
To hide their true intentions.
9. What does this do for everything else in society?
Creates a corrosive low-trust atmosphere that slows trade, impedes the spread of innovation, mucks up education.
10. But the philosopher-king will be secure?
Yes. Just stuck with a shitty society, secret police and an unending threat of being replaced with an even worse psychopath.