4 ms·
I call BS on some of the "facts" in this story. ...an economics professor at the University of Massachusetts at Boston [says]. "You have to work a lot of hours
by yummyfajitas 18y ago
I call BS on some of the "facts" in this story.
...an economics professor at the University of Massachusetts at Boston [says]. "You have to work a lot of hours and still not make a lot of money...."
Just not true. The typical poor family works less than half as much as the typical non-poor family (1000 hours/year vs 2100 hours/year).
http://www3.brookings.edu/es/wrb/publications/pb/pb28.pdf http://www3.brookings.edu/es/wrb/publications/pb/pb28.pdf
You ask him why he didn't just go to a bank...He says he lost his driver's license and now his regular bank "won't recognize me as a human.
A check cashing place requires the same, usually more stringent ID than a bank.
...Jacob Carter finds himself standing in a checkout line at the Giant on Alabama Avenue SE...The clerk suggests that he use his "bonus card" for savings...Carter tells the clerk he has no such card.
Bonus cards are so hard to get. You need to walk over to the courtesy counter, ask for one, then fill out phony information on the card to get it.
- randallsquared 18y agoYou almost never have to walk to the courtesy counter; you can fill it out while standing at the checkout. But people typically don't know this, in my experience, and the cashier is unlikely to enlighten them, since then he'll have to wait for them to fill it out while there are people in line, etc. Things like this are important to know, and if you don't already just know, you have to ask about them constantly. If you don't know that, though, and you're poor, it feels as though you're asking for handouts or special help whenever you aggressively inquire about this sort of thing.
- jrockway 18y agoAt most stores I've been in, the cashier will enter the store "bonus card" number if you ask them to. In fact, they often enter the number before I can even get my card out. I'm surprised they don't do this in DC. It must be a Chicago thing.
- randallsquared 18y agoOh, they do that around here at some stores, too (not the more upscale ones, interestingly). Around the Columbus, GA area, though, where I used to live (in east AL), I don't remember that happening. Of course, I shopped mostly at the super Walmart, then, and they don't have a card.
- nostrademons 18y agoSafeways here in Silicon Valley will ask for your phone number (the card is linked to this) if you forget your card. Pretty handy. Curiously, my parents never signed up for a bonus card because they use it to track your purchases and my dad was not comfortable with this. Once I moved out, this habit lasted for exactly one visit to the supermarket before I realized I could save 10+% and got one. Money > privacy.
- jsrfded 18y agoThey can take a phone number too; I give them nnn-555-1212. It's always registered and you get the discount. I use this on vacation - "What's the area code here?" "808..?" "My number is 808-555-1212". Bingo. But yeah, it's a hack.
- jrockway 18y agoI agree with you here. Some of the things that the article dismisses as impossible are quite possible, like getting a bank account. You have to waste an hour waiting in line to get an ID, and then you can save $15 every time you get paid. That sounds like a good deal to me. These people should do that, and stop letting the check cashing places take advantage of them. They can also go to the public library and pay their bills online, saving the the cost of either postage or the fee on the money order. None of this costs money or much time, but it will save money. Also, why are people with a 10 minute drive not riding a bicycle? If you can't afford a car, and the bus route isn't convenient enough, it's time to get a bicycle. I also don't buy the article's premise that having a car is mandatory. I live in a big city (Chicago), and I have never owned a car. I ride my bike to the grocery store (even in the winter), take the CTA to other stores I need to visit, or just order what I need online. All of these things save me money, and don't cost me much time. (It would take as long to drive to the grocery store ad it takes to ride my bike.) Don't get me wrong, I know the poor have a hard life. But some of their problems are easily fixed, if they are willing to invest time now to save time later.
- huherto 18y agoThat is kind of the point of the article. Part of being poor is not knowing ways of saving money. That is why they are stuck in this vicious circle.
- profgubler 18y agoNot taking this out on you. But, start a business then that teaches them this and find a way to make money doing, or get donors and do it as a none profit. I am not saying that you are saying have the government do it for them, but that is the vibe, I get with the vast majority of people in this thread. The government is not the only people that can help the poor, and likely not the best to help the poor. Why is this? Because the government does things on tax payers dime, they don't have a 100% control of the money. I am sorry, but even if this is the case in real life that the poor have it harder, which I do not doubt, it does not make the solution government intervention.
- huherto 18y ago<i>...Jacob Carter finds himself standing in a checkout line at the Giant on Alabama Avenue SE...The clerk suggests that he use his "bonus card" for savings...Carter tells the clerk he has no such card.</i> The way I understand the paragraph is that Carter doesn't even ask because he thinks it is something beyond his possibilities. Just one of the many things he cannot get because he is poor.
- greyboy 18y agoIn fairness to the other side, that sounds like a problem with Jacob Carter and his assumptions than with "the system." We can't really blame them for that, can we? I'm sure they WANT him to use they card, just as for any other class of people (so the retailer can use that information for advertising, move the goods they desire to, etc).
- sethg 18y agoI'm sure they WANT him to use they card I'm not.