3 ms·
Most people are stunned by the way the internet email system is set up. I probably have to explain SMTP error codes on a weekly basis to people who don't get wh
by zdw 13y ago
Most people are stunned by the way the internet email system is set up. I probably have to explain SMTP error codes on a weekly basis to people who don't get why it doesn't "just work".
A common conception is that it works like the telephone system - you make connections all the way through, then send the message. Bounces? Delays? How could those happen?
It's stunning to talk to newcomers about how things were before the internet came to exist as we know it. Mail routing via bang path with UUCP? How many people on HN even have seen that?
The problem is that we need a forklift replacement for SMTP and mail envelopes, both of which which have crypto built into it at a fundamental level.
Switching everyone over to SSL wrapped SMTP would be a good stopgap for the transport portion of this, even if it's just self signed, with some sort of HSTS style cert persistence.
- gnuvince 13y agoDo people create new, open protocols anymore? I feel that if someone decided to tackle the "email is insecure" problem, we'd end up watching a video on Kickstarter about how cool their new Ruby on Rails SaaS is.
- JshWright 13y agoZRTP is a is still a 'new' protocol in my book. OTR is only slightly older.
- zdw 13y agoHTTP is probably the most recent "internet spanning" protocol that has wide use. You could probably make an argument for XMPP (jabber) as well. The message passing libraries like 0mq and similar could probably be viewed like this. More important than protocols are the data interchange formats that they leave behind. SMTP envelopes are particularly horrible to parse. I'd like something newer, but I think it would lead to feature-itis that has given us abominations like base64 encoded MIME attachments (seriously, what system isn't 8-bit clean in 2013?) , HTML mail (used mainly for spam), return receipts (aka "automated privacy violation"), etc.
- rdl 13y agoBitcoin? SPDY?
- nileshtrivedi 13y ago> Do people create new, open protocols anymore? https://tent.io/ https://tent.io/