3 ms·
The problem is more multifaceted than just "email is broken". One fundamental problem currently is webmail. People are accustomed to that but providing secure c
by zokier 13y ago
The problem is more multifaceted than just "email is broken". One fundamental problem currently is webmail. People are accustomed to that but providing secure comms over web is currently tricky if not impossible. So even if we had a new fancy email standard, it wouldn't help if anyone cant't access it securely because current web standards are not up to it.
Another problem would be key management. I find it difficult to believe that we could build any sort of secure system without some keys, and those keys need managing. I'd love to see widespread adaptation of HSMs, but to accomplish that it would need support from the hardware all the way to the browser (or what ever client software). Even something like TPM would be nice if actually adopted (and made trustable).
Then relating to key management is the issue of trust. How do we verify the keys? The current CA system definitely seems bust, so we need something different no matter what's the email standard.
- kybernetikos 13y agoI think key management is a really big problem, as I say in my blog post 'I shouldn’t be trusted with anything as precious as my own private key'. http://kybernetikos.com/2013/06/22/how-do-we-make-encryption-more-accessible/ http://kybernetikos.com/2013/06/22/how-do-we-make-encryption... I'm not so sure about the problems with webmail. I don't see why they would be significantly different from the problems associated with serving a web banking site, and there are plenty of those.
- zokier 13y ago> I don't see why they would be significantly different from the problems associated with serving a web banking site, and there are plenty of those. With web banking usually the bank has legitimately access to all information they are presenting to you via web. In email your email-provider shouldn't have access to your unencrypted mail.
- Retric 13y agoPresumably you could use client site JavaScript to decode your message. However, that brings up key management issues.
- zokier 13y agoI don't believe that would be good enough. Encryption/decryption should be done by the browser in a way that JS has no access to either the keys or the cleartext. There should be also clear indications in the browser chrome when accessing such elements.
- kybernetikos 13y agoI suppose the key point is that you can't trust whomever is storing your data with storing your email app code - it's far too easy for them to serve you backdoored app code if they're required to by the government.
- adestefan 13y agoKey management is usually the biggest issue when it comes to any crypto scheme. It's a problem with so many weird corner cases that anytime someone things they have a good idea there's always that "Oh shit" moment when they realize it won't work or it's way too complicated.