11 ms·
You beat me to it! (For those who don't know, the PPACA is sometimes called "Obamacare" although it should be noted that the name is more a result of political
by jjoonathan 13y ago
You beat me to it! (For those who don't know, the PPACA is sometimes called "Obamacare" although it should be noted that the name is more a result of political maneuvering than the result of particularly close affiliation with Obama.)
I still think we should go all the way to single-payer. Other countries have had such success with this model that it's becoming very difficult to argue that it's inherently flawed (rather than the other way around). If the US health industry had to compete directly with any of these systems, it would go out of business tomorrow, since they offer similar care (in terms of outcome rates) at half the price per person. That doesn't even include the effects on entrepreneurship and employment!
While the ACA did little to fix the "US health care costs twice as much and doesn't deliver better outcomes" problem, it does have a good shot at fixing the preexisting condition and individual insurance debacles.
- mjn 13y agoI agree it's not really a proper solution. My move from the U.S. to Denmark has been smooth when it comes to healthcare; I've been very impressed at the lack of paperwork and lack of stress over my coverage. But nonetheless I grudgingly supported PPACA, despite it seeming like a mess, because I can't see another way to solve the tied-to-employers issue that's politically feasible, at least for now.
- jaibot 13y agoIt may become easier to reform healthcare if/when people see that PPACA doesn't Ruin Everything Forever.
- zanny 13y agoThe kind of sentiment that breeds that ignorant opinion is propegated by those that don't want to see single payer because it hurts their profits. The health insurance / for profit hospital / big pharma lobbies are aburdly massive, and like many (most nowadays) industries, they abuse their wealth to exploit faulty political process to see what they want instituted brought into law and to keep advances that invalidate their profit centers from being legal.
- jaibot 13y agoIf you have a plan to fix the entire American political system, I will happily listen. I just spent 2.5 years working tech in US politics and it did not fill me with optimism. When you have eliminated the implausible, whatever remains, however distasteful, must be endorsed.
- mjn 13y agoI recall even Ted Kennedy somewhat later in life commenting that not reaching a compromise with Nixon's health-care proposals in the '70s, flawed as they were, was one of his major regrets, because the end result of holding out for proper reform was that here we were decades later, and nothing had gotten passed at all. The Nixon proposal is an interesting one in retrospect. In some ways it's "left" of PPACA, despite at the time being opposed by Democrats, who preferred a real public plan and criticized Nixon's as a sellout to insurance companies. Although it wasn't single-payer, one of Nixon's proposed compromises would've actually included a public plan as an opt-in possibility (but not the default), reminiscent of the "public option" that more liberal Democrats unsuccessfully tried to include in PPACA.
- tzs 13y agoSingle payer is not necessary to have a good health care system. Proof: Switzerland [1]. [1] http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/sickaroundtheworld/countries/ http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/sickaroundtheworld/c...
- phaemon 13y agoThat link gets UK healthcare wrong. There is private insurance in the UK too, and you can directly buy private treatment. We have a mix of both. Most people do without because the NHS covers everything they need.
- tptacek 13y agoThere is a relatively insignificant amount of private coverage in the UK; something like 5bn versus 110bn in public coverage, and the NHS is a very large component of that 5bn (as a buyer) as well.
- Daniel_Newby 13y ago> Other countries have had such success with this model that it's becoming very difficult to argue that it's inherently flawed ... The British NHS discovered that by not feeding hospitalized patients they could realize tremendous savings in food, shortened length of hospital stay, followup costs, etc. > half the price per person Health care spending will dramatically increase under Obamacare. Americans spend a lot on health care as a lifestyle choice. Obamacare is nothing more than an attempt to recreate the housing bubble using health care.
- tocomment 13y agoThat sounds interesting. Can you explain more about the bubble angle?
- Daniel_Newby 13y agoGovernment officials find something popular, promise unlimited amounts of it to get votes, then create a program to deliver it with total disregard for economic consequences. Last decade they bought votes with easy mortgages. After all, even an idiot could see that home ownership was a sound investment. They won two or three rounds of elections with mortgage policy. This decade it is health care for all! Even an idiot can see that health care for everyone is a sound investment. Just look at these scary charts of runaway growth of medical costs. And the votes roll in. In reality, most health care consists of vaccines, blood pressure pills, diabetes pills, and the occassional antibiotics. That gives most of the benefits and costs almost nothing. Most of the costs come from ludicrous end-of-life procedures on old people, most of the rest comes from ludicrous $500k courses of treatments for this like multiple sclerosis and stage 29 recurrent cancer. These are lifestyle choices for well-off people who would rather pay a doctor than leave an inheritance. Trying to extend this lifestyle to every waitress will destroy the economy. It's no different than last decade's plan to put every hairdresser in a $700k mansion.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- 13y ago
- MrFoof 13y agoMassachusetts already has much of what PPACA provides as "RomneyCare", a.k.a. the Massachusetts Health Connector and MassHealth. It's exactly what allowed me (as a Type II diabetic) to strike out on my own without much concern. I pay ~$430/mo (early 30s, single) for a high-deductible plan with low co-pays from a major carrier with no co-insurance. Do I wish my costs were less? Yes. Is it better than having to be someone's employee? Hells yes. Providing this to the entire country isn't the ideal solution for everyone, but it's a big step in the right direction.