7 ms·
I wrote this a couple days ago in response to another HN comment but it's relevant here too; the first paragraph is the one I responded to: >The question is th
by jseliger 13y ago
I wrote this a couple days ago in response to another HN comment but it's relevant here too; the first paragraph is the one I responded to:
>The question is then; in a two party system where both offer the blue pill, who the hell do you vote for?
Greens or libertarians, which I have been doing for a long time. Real change starts at the ballot box.
- bitwize 13y agoBarring a constitutional amendment that implements a multiparty, proportional-representation parliament, your choices in Murka are either Kang or Kodos.
- pekk 13y agoPolitical analysis from a cartoon show, regurgitated endlessly to shut down any more nuanced discussion.
- bitwize 13y agoActually, the currently-accepted theory among political scientists is that America's first-past-the-post electoral system, in which the plurality candidate wins and everyone else loses, necessarily leads to an effectively two-party system.
- anigbrowl 13y agoCitation needed. In the US there have been other parties that have put presidents in office (Theodore Wilson was a Progressive Party candidate - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Progressive_Party_(United_States,_1912) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Progressive_Party_(United_State...) and in the UK, which also has a first-past-the-post system, there are multiple parties and the country is currently governed by a coalition of Conservatives and Liberal Democrats. FPTP certainly makes 2-party outcomes more likely, but then so does unlimited election spending. It's not the foregone conclusion you suggest it is.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> In the US there have been other parties that have put presidents in office There have never been more than two nationally-competitive parties in the US. There have been times when a party collapsed and subsequently was replaced (the Federalists by the Whigs, and the Whigs by the Republicans.) > Theodore Wilson was a Progressive Party candidate Presumably, you mean (former) President Theodore Roosevelt, who, formed the Progressive Party in a factional split from the Republican Party over his dissatisfaction with his hand-picked successor. And who didn't win, so isn't an illustration of your claim that parties other than the two major ones have put Presidents in office. > and in the UK, which also has a first-past-the-post system, there are multiple parties and the country is currently governed by a coalition of Conservatives and Liberal Democrats The UK and US differ in that, in additional to FPTP voting for members of the national legislature, the US has a separately (and indirectly) elected strong executive using a means that is even more strongly favors the two major parties than simple single-member district FPTP elections do; this not only gives a greater tendency for a major party to win control of the administration by winning the Presidential election, it further limits the expected influence of non-major party candidates for the national legislature, which further reduces their prospects. So, yes, there is a well-understood structural reason in the electoral that the US has even less representative government and a stronger tendency to a two-party system (even though it has weaker parties) than the UK, even though both use FPTP for the national legislature.
- anigbrowl 13y agoTheodore Roosevelt indeed - I jammed his name together with Woodrow Wilson, his Democratic opponent. Wilson beat him handily, but Roosevelt still outpolled the GOP candidate, WH Taft. You are quite right about the key difference with the US having an elected executive vs the parliamentary democacy system of the UK, but I don't see how FPTP prevent the election of Congressional candidates from outside the two major parties. There are usually a few independents in either chamber of Congress, but I don't see any particular reason why another party couldn't make a showing if it were willing to put in the organizational leg-work. In my (limited) experience American politicians and parties are excessively focused on elective office; being from Ireland myself I think long-term success stems from building a solid local constituency. So for example, I think it's a complete waste of time for the Green party to run candidates in the US presidential election, instead of working to capture a few seats in Congress or in state legislatures. I have been involved in a few such local campaigns, and what I've observed is that on failing to win a major election the candidates tend to exit politics instead.
- a3n 13y agoIf what you're doing isn't working, do anything else. Voting 3rd party is anything else. I vote 3rd party, which to me is invoking "none of the above."
- dragonwriter 13y ago> what you're doing isn't working, do anything else. That's a fairly silly proposition that could justify any arbitrary change of action no matter how unlikely it was to produce better results (indeed, even if it was certain to provide worse results) than your current course of action. > I vote 3rd party Is it working? If not, shouldn't you, by your own standards, be doing anything else?
- chinpokomon 13y agoI don't know about that. It's a vote for left Twix or right Twix; just pick a side and eat it, and keep the other for later - or have a Milky Way instead. It's time to start eating Milky Ways.
- AnthonyMouse 13y ago> If what you're doing isn't working, do anything else. I can't tell if you're being sarcastic. That's just the legislator's fallacy: "We must do something, this is something, therefore we must do this." You would be better off to try something that has more hope of actually working, like voting in the primaries. Or encouraging your state representatives to publicly finance elections for federal office in your state, so you have a better choice for federal candidates in the future. Or finding a way to convey to your representatives that you won't be supporting them in the future if they don't do something about this in the present, rather than waiting for the next election when the issue may no longer hold the attention of the public.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Real change starts at the ballot box. No, real change starts with working to build a mass constituency that believes that real change is necessary, and agrees on the general direction of change. If you want it to work, change through the ballot box is fairly late in that process.
- bsbechtel 13y agoIf you want to affect change, maybe helping out with this would be a start: https://medium.com/surveillance-state/7d456a6a04df https://medium.com/surveillance-state/7d456a6a04df
- chinpokomon 13y agoI'm on board with this, but I expect little traction. I got actively involved with the Republican Party because I saw them as the lesser of two evils. I hoped that my fresh outlook might be able to influence the party to become the party I imagined they could be. To become involved to the point you might make a difference, you need to demonstrate that you share the same values as the leadership... effectively preventing the party from adapting or changing. In Washington, we have a top two primary. Since the primaries mostly attract political party activists, this means that third parties are almost universally blocked from appearing on the general election ballot. I see neither party willing to give up this power they have obtained, so I expect politics in Washington State to go nowhere. We as a people passed that initiative so now we're stuck with the consequences.
- jseliger 13y agoTake a look at Hirschman's Exit, Voice, and Loyalty, which describes in general terms the political phenomenon you're describing. I hope you check this—you should put an obfuscated e-mail address in your profile.
- bsbechtel 13y agoDo you have write-in candidates in Washington? I'd see what I'm proposing as more of a platform for introducing new ideas and gathering popular support for them. You just need to identify who is credible to bring forth those new ideas, and give them a platform first.