6 ms·
I donated money to Obama's 2008 campaign and voted for him twice. I am very disappointed with him. Now, my honest opinion is that at worst he sometimes flat ou
by mark_l_watson 13y ago
I donated money to Obama's 2008 campaign and voted for him twice. I am very disappointed with him.
Now, my honest opinion is that at worst he sometimes flat out lies, or at least cleverly tries to confuse people. He says that he had an orderly plan for reviewing privacy issues, all the while, I think that his administration has consistently been trying to keep things hushed up.
- JPKab 13y agoMark, I agree. I think that the situation is this: politicians, in the short term, view the security side of the security vs. freedom debate as the best option. If you can stop a terrorist attack from occurring by infringing freedom, then do it. An attack will make you look much worse than a few intelligent people being upset about privacy invasion. That, sadly, is the unfortunate incentive happening here. I think this short term benefit of always choosing security over freedom has always been too tempting for politicans and leaders not to do it. The founders recognized this, which is why the 4th Amendment, along with the rest of the Constitution, is supposed to be enforced by the separate branch of government that is the Judicial Branch. But you know what? The Judicial Branch hasn't kept up with the Executive at all. The Executive Branch has huge agencies within it. The Judicial Branch is just a few judges and their staff. Why isn't there a Judicial Branch agency that safeguards the Constitution from the other two branches?? Why couldn't this agency have a bunch of people with Top Secret clearances working for it who answer to nobody but the Supreme Court and can be contacted by Edward Snowden type whistle-blowers whenever someone feels the folks they work for are undermining the Constitution? We need a Constitution Protection Agency that is part of the Judicial Branch. Their entire job should be going after the bastards in the other two branches who go against the constitution.
- jivatmanx 13y agoMany countries have more powerful and interventionist Supreme Courts. Notable, Germany[1] [1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Constitutional_Court_of_Germany http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Constitutional_Court_of...
- anigbrowl 13y agoThe founders recognized this, which is why the 4th Amendment, along with the rest of the Constitution, is supposed to be enforced by the separate branch of government that is the Judicial Branch. You're saying the police power is the province of the Judicial Branch?! This is a...unique interpretation. The Constitution divides the power of the government in legislative (making law), executive (promulgating and enforcing law), and judicial (evaluation of the law). In common law jurisdictions the judicial branch does not have any kind of police power, and to the best of my knowledge never has had. I am perplexed by the number of HNers that seem to think we live in a civil law jurisdiction. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_law_(legal_system) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_law_(legal_system)
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Why isn't there a Judicial Branch agency that safeguards the Constitution from the other two branches?? Because there is no authority for such an agency in Article III, and because the type of ombudsman agency you describe would be undertaking investigations of a sort that are executive, rather than judicial, so that even if Congress attempted to create such an agency, it would be (were it Constitutional at all) an Article II agency subject to the President even if Congress gave the Judiciary the power to appoint its officers.
- jtc331 13y ago>> "We need a Constitution Protection Agency that is part of the Judicial Branch." I don't believe that a government can /ever/ effectively regulate itself--not matter how many/how strong the agencies you create. The only effective remedy is a truly informed citizenry and civil disobedience.
- Clanan 13y agoThe Executive Branch enforces, the Judicial judges. The Constitution says it quite explicitly in Articles 2 and 3. You give far too much credit to politicians. They don't think of this as security vs. freedom, they think of it as power. Power for them, power for their party, power for their people. It's a simple explanation, but it fits. Heck, research has even shown that politicians will decide based on what keeps them in office, not what they "should" do [1]. Jefferson said it best: "All men having power ought to be mistrusted. Perhaps it is a universal truth that the loss of liberty at home is to be charged to the provisions against danger, real or pretended, from abroad." [1] Congress: The Electoral Connection by David R. Mayhew
- dictum 13y agoWhat saddens me is that while in the 2012 elections it seems most Obama voters were effectively choosing the lesser of two evils, in 2008 they were voting for Obama. They believed in what he was supposed to represent. In retrospect, maybe they were voting against Bush. In the next election maybe a majority will vote against Obama, and the game will keep going.
- bitwize 13y agoWhat saddens me is that while in the 2012 elections it seems most Obama voters were effectively choosing the lesser of two evils, in 2008 they were voting for Obama. They believed in what he was supposed to represent. They wanted to believe. Even then Obama gave off considerable whiffs of being a relative political neophyte who felt entitled -- or even destined -- to power, and was given an easy path into the White House by an all-too-eager Democratic apparatus. Still, I was glad he won in 2008 because of his platform; he eventually reneged on so many of his campaign promises that I could not, in good conscience, vote for him in 2012.
- peterjancelis 13y agoI think most people, even those who follow politics, buy into the emotional experience rather than the actual politics. It makes people feel good to listen to a great speech on paying back birth control pills, who cares that it's a really small issue compared to foreign policy or economic policy. The number of real 'political engineers' is really small anyway. I don't even blame those people. For example I am a car enthusiast but not a car engineer, so while I may love the Porsche brand for the emotional connections it has in my mind, a car engineer who really knows what he's talking about may very well know for a fact that the tech for part X is better in a Toyota. I don't know and I don't care. People just get disappointed in politicians because they operate in an incentive system that rewards them for not keeping their promises, because votes are a 'sunk revenue' once in office. If laws were made in a private market, they'd be incentivized to be more consistent.
- andy_ppp 13y ago
- jseliger 13y agoI wrote this a couple days ago in response to another HN comment but it's relevant here too; the first paragraph is the one I responded to: >The question is then; in a two party system where both offer the blue pill, who the hell do you vote for? Greens or libertarians, which I have been doing for a long time. Real change starts at the ballot box.
- bitwize 13y agoBarring a constitutional amendment that implements a multiparty, proportional-representation parliament, your choices in Murka are either Kang or Kodos.
- pekk 13y agoPolitical analysis from a cartoon show, regurgitated endlessly to shut down any more nuanced discussion.
- bitwize 13y agoActually, the currently-accepted theory among political scientists is that America's first-past-the-post electoral system, in which the plurality candidate wins and everyone else loses, necessarily leads to an effectively two-party system.
- anigbrowl 13y agoCitation needed. In the US there have been other parties that have put presidents in office (Theodore Wilson was a Progressive Party candidate - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Progressive_Party_(United_States,_1912) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Progressive_Party_(United_State...) and in the UK, which also has a first-past-the-post system, there are multiple parties and the country is currently governed by a coalition of Conservatives and Liberal Democrats. FPTP certainly makes 2-party outcomes more likely, but then so does unlimited election spending. It's not the foregone conclusion you suggest it is.
- jczhang 13y agoI think humans rationalize quite a bit to please both sides. Spend enough time with people who are smart and promote issue X strongly, and you will soon bend whatever 'principle' you had. The idea of balance is very tempting.
- madaxe 13y agoHe explicitly denied warrantless surveillance in his press conference a few hours ago - a few hours after the guardian published a piece on exactly how they go about it. Also telling were the pregnant pauses when posed questions about the NSA, the backtracking on and modification of sentences that he realised were about to be dangerous, and the fact that he quipped about journalists reading body language when he met Putin - which rather tells us what was on his mind.
- betterunix 13y ago"I donated money to Obama's 2008 campaign and voted for him twice." ...after the first four years, why would you vote for him again? It became clear almost from the first day of his presidency that his campaign promises were hollow. Stop letting your fear that a Republican might win get the better of you. Vote third party until the Democrats get their act together.
- chinpokomon 13y agoI do that when I fear the Democrats might win too. Honestly, I wish more people would realize there are other options. We'd be much better if we had a greater range of choices. Unfortunately the two parties at the top have made it very hard for third party candidates.
- specialist 13y agoWith winner takes all politics, there is no third party. Duverger's Law: to get 51% of the vote, everyone tries to form the smallest winning coalition. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duverger's_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duverger's_law If you want to build a viable third party, start with local elections, build your farm team. It takes decades to be viable. Then at some point, one of the dominate coalitions will pivot and subsume the new platform. It's happened many times in the USA.
- betterunix 13y agoMy point was not that we should be overthrowing the major parties. My point was that we should be punishing the major parties when they do not do what we want them to do. The Democrats are supposedly a center-left party, supposedly the choice for liberals in this country. In reality the Democrats are a right wing party, with some centrist leanings on very specific issues. That means we do not really have a choice. The only solution is to vote third party until the Democrats get their act together, especially in the swing states -- we need to hit them where it hurts until they get their act together.
- specialist 13y ago
- specialist 13y agoI am very disappointed with him. Yup. My disappointment is tempered with the knowledge that we (The People) aren't doing our jobs very well either. "Power concedes nothing without a demand. It never did and it never will." -- Frederick Douglass "I agree with you, I want to do it, now make me do it" -- FDR Politicians only respond to pressure. Period. From a game theoretic standpoint, it makes perfect sense: Why take a position today which could come back and bite them tomorrow? Better to take the safe route, the status quo. I have modest experience with this, mostly disappointment. The small successes we had happened when we packed hearings with bodies. If you can mobilize and won't go away, politicians will do anything to make you go away. It doesn't matter who's in the chair: Democrat, Republican, fruitcake, saint, elected, appointed, whatever. You make a stink, you get your way. Sometimes you have to make a very big stink. And the personal costs are often very high.