6 ms·
The Concorde’s Cousins
- moocowduckquack 13y agoThe Skylon is not in the same bracket as Concorde. Concorde was largely an expensive route between London and New York, not an attempt to lower the costs to orbit, the economics of the situation are completely different. If the Sabre engine does ever get used on a passenger plane, it will not be until after it has proven itself at getting into space, as getting into space is the job it is designed for.
- supergauntlet 13y agoThe SABRE's primary goal seems to be to get an SSTO (single-stage-to-orbit) into space. Anything else looks secondary.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoThere is the Lapcat http://www.reactionengines.co.uk/lapcat.html http://www.reactionengines.co.uk/lapcat.html which would be comparable to Concorde and uses a Sabre variant called Scimitar, however the article never mentions it. Personally I think whoever wrote the article did almost no research and just conflated the Skylon and Concorde in their heads, then just wrote down why what they had imagined did not make any sense without realising that it was not in fact what was being proposed. edit - thinking about it, they also only used the mach 5 number in the article. The Skylon is designed to go five times that fast to get to low earth orbit, the mach 5 figure is just the speed while air breathing.
- akiselev 13y agoPar for the course in science journalism.
- digikata 13y agoI've been anticipating companies like Virgin Galactic would prove out hardware & know-how with sub-orbital tourist trips, then move on to sub-orbital travel legs. That possibility seems nearer term than Skylon.
- snowwrestler 13y agoThat is the expressed goal of the Scaled Composites "Tier Three" platform, which is what will follow the Virgin Galactic platform, which is Tier Two. (Tier One was the X Prize platform.)
- apsec112 13y agoThis is a terrible article. It presents no arguments, only meaningless statistics quoted out of context. "The costs are astronomical, too. The British government’s financial contribution to the project is just a small fraction of the billions needed to complete it." They conveniently don't mention that every new airplane design costs billions to start producing. This is true even for mundane passenger jets, never mind anything new and experimental (the B2 bomber cost $45 billion to develop - see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B-2_Spirit http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B-2_Spirit). Without technically lying, they make it sound like this project in particular is outrageously expensive, which (as far as I can tell) isn't actually true, compared to other new aircraft designs. "It was one of the greatest economic boondoggles of all time." Of all time? Really? The Concorde (cost: a few billion) is now in league with the 2008 financial crisis and dot-com bubbles (cost: trillions upon trillions)? Evidence presented for this claim: none. In fact, we know it was profitable on its NYC - London and NYC - Paris routes (http://news.google.co.uk/newspapers?id=VAQkAAAAIBAJ&sjid=MO4DAAAAIBAJ&pg=6783,4192544&dq=concorde+braniff&hl=en http://news.google.co.uk/newspapers?id=VAQkAAAAIBAJ&sjid=MO4...). "Very few people could afford a $12,000 round-trip ticket.... " This is true for every elite airline service. Ask anyone who travels a lot - most of those in international first class are using miles, or are on a corporate travel program. "Not to mention the environmental waste—more than 6,800 gallons of fuel per hour." More meaningless numbers designed to look scary. Doing some math, if the Concorde had 100 passengers and flew at 1,350 mph, that's 135,000 / 6,800 = 20 passenger-miles per gallon. Better than most SUVs. "In spite of its well-earned reputation as one of the great economic debacles of the 20th century..." Evidence presented: none. In fact, when the Concorde was retired, Richard Branson offered to purchase the fleet and continue service "for many years to come" (http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-109201077.html http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-109201077.html).
- tanzam75 13y agoBritish Airways' profit on the Concorde was an accounting trick. They took a 100% writeoff of all Concorde capital investments in 1979, and another 100% writeoff in 1983. Write-offs are not charged against operating expenses, but show up as "Other expenses." This made the airplanes essentially "free." They still had maintenance expenses, but the capital cost was zero. And that's just the money that British Airways spent on it. The British and French governments also subsidized the project. Thus, looking purely at British Airways' accounting profit is ignoring the actual costs of the Concorde project. Most jetliners are more efficient than an SUV. It's not hard, because SUVs are so incredibly inefficient. The proper comparison is to other jetliners. The Boeing 747 gets about 100 passenger-miles per gallon. That's 5x as efficient as the Concorde, at 20 passenger-miles per gallon. When the Concorde was retired in 2003, Jet-A cost $1 per gallon. Today, aviation kerosene costs $3.50 per gallon.
- elchief 13y ago[Musk] elaborated just a tiny bit on his future plans to build a “Hyperloop” that would be a “cross between a Concorde and a railgun and an air hockey table”. There ya go.
- Keyframe 13y agoReportedly, supersonic transport also has an effect on the ozone layer - which might have something to do with it too.
- fedvasu 13y agoNot trying to play the authority card, but I am an Aerospace Engineer by training. First thing first Concorde was a marvel of engineering and quite a bit ahead of time as someone mentioned in the comments below it ultimately boils down to economics, per-flight cost was enormous. Concorde effectively gave a 6-hr gain on Trans-Atlantic flight. You need to spend a lot of fuel to fly supersonic , even Concorde had an optimal sub-sonic cruise-point around Mach-0.98. And It was allowed to fly supersonic only over uninhabited areas (read Oceans).If you google around specific-fuel consumption charts for various types of engines against mach number you'll know what I mean.(Also try to search for specific Impulse characteristics for a feel for efficiency over a mach number range)
- nolok 13y agoAs a french, the Concord was a great thing and I am truly sad that it had to go (especially the way the existing plane were dealt with, what with the airlines refusing to sell them to another operator and destroying them instead). I don't know much about the economics of it, and I know it wasn't very good money wise to keep the line open for the airlines which made them pretty much relieved to have an excuse to close it, but still this article throw around "facts" and "numbers" to give an highly exaggerated and misguided view of it. And even if, it was important because it was something great we could do. Supersonic passenger plane ? Yes, we can do that. In fact, we did it, and not just a prototype, a real regular line. I didn't think much about it at the time it closed (I was too busy enjoying high school), but nowadays all I can hear our politics and many countrymen say of my country is "no we can't do that", "that's not possible", "be realistic", ... If you have that attitude, you fail before you even start, and Concord was in the exact opposite direction, it was doing something not because it made economic sense or because you needed it, but to prove a point: yes, we can do that, and we're going to prove it to you. Frankly we need a lot more of that today. I'm tired of all the negativity. I think that's also a huge part of why, despite being a joint FR/UK project, both side kind of think of it as "their" plane.
- ragesh 13y agoI can't upvote this enough. As someone who was lucky enough to have flown on Concorde 20 years ago (almost to the date), I'm extremely sad that it isn't even an option anymore. The thrill of hitting mach 2 and being able to see the curvature of the earth is something I'm going to carry to the grave. That's just sad. It simply feels wrong that we were able to make it happen and couldn't figure out a way to make it sustainable in all this time.
- switch007 13y agoRich people got to fly quicker than they needed to and it was created with public tax money, to the tune of over a billion pounds. If Concorde wasn't the poster child of excess, I don't know what was. Thank heavens we soon discovered we were destroying the planet and environmentalism became a thing.
- DanBC 13y agoPeople are involved in more interesting things, such as silent flying for passenger planes. This would have a dramatic effect. People hate planes and airports because of noise[1] so having very quiet aircraft would reduce opposition and allow longer operating hours for airports. (http://silentaircraft.org/ http://silentaircraft.org/) [1] among other reasons.
- VladRussian2 13y agoThe current big civilian aircrafts are all still mainly follow aerodynamics introduced by B-47. Conceptual models like one referred by parent are trying to break the spell, yet it doesn't seem to be happening any time soon unfortunately.
- rdl 13y agoI'd be ok with even really mundane things -- great video on demand, Internet access, and a marginally more comfortable seat (Economy Plus or old style business class) would be worth more to me on most flights vs. a faster journey. There are even routes where if I could get a real bed onboard and a shower at the airport in arrivals (so, cheap), I'd take twice as long a flight (turning a late night flight into a true redeye). Being productive onboard and immediately on arrival (which, for domestic routes, is actually more about the airport than the aircraft) would make up for a lot.
- chiph 13y agoDad got to fly Concorde one time - he was trapped in Paris by a strike against Air France. The business associate he was visiting went to the counter and started yelling at the Air France attendant. In order to "make the problem go away", the Air France guy gave dad the very last ticket on the Concorde. He said the interior was cramped, but the food was amazing and watching the Mach number climb past 1.0 was phenomenal.
- stcredzero 13y ago> “Trying to change a law to allow very, very rich people to go a lot faster than less rich people over the same airspace—it’s not the easiest one to justify,” But it's very likely that the price will be paid for the representatives to vote for it. I could see it being rolled into a bill meant to eliminate some red tape for commercial space entrepreneurs. (And tha would be a good thing n the whole.) EDIT: Fuel costs made the Concorde uneconomical. Is there a way we can eventually get around this? What about using beamed power to launch vehicles above the atmosphere on ballistic trajectories? There would be tremendous infrastructure and R&D costs up front, but eventually, such a system would blow way aircraft for very high speed personnel and package transport over long distances.