3 ms·
There have always been reasons to object to working in national defense. During the Cold War quite a few physicists and engineers chose not to go into defense w
by snowwrestler 13y ago
There have always been reasons to object to working in national defense. During the Cold War quite a few physicists and engineers chose not to go into defense work because they did not want to feel like they were hastening nuclear Armageddon.
And yet, the U.S. government developed effective new defense and energy technologies during this time.
There are reasons to work for the government that are attractive to top tech talent: access to information and tools that no one in private enterprise has; gigantic budgets, with no demand for profitability; a great mission: protecting the American people.
And if the issue is privacy, there are objections to made at most top tech companies now as well--most of their product development treads on or over the privacy line of their customers.
I'm not advocating for defense work BTW, just expressing skepticism that the Snowden affair will substantially harm the government's ability to attract tech talent.
It probably will scare off the most innovative, forward thinking hackers...but they've never been a crowd that works for the government anyway. Too slow and bureaucratic.
- dclowd9901 13y ago> most of their product development treads on or over the privacy line of their customers. I think most people now understand and have well-embraced the idea of "if you don't pay for a product you are the product." Given the relative odds of being injured or killed by a terrorist attack, it's debatable if any utility is gained from giving up your privacy to government.
- usefulcat 13y agoIf by "most people", you mean "most HN readers", then I agree. But if you actually mean "most people", then I'd say that issue is probably not even on their radar.
- yareally 13y ago> "There have always been reasons to object to working in national defense. During the Cold War quite a few physicists and engineers chose not to go into defense work because they did not want to feel like they were hastening nuclear Armageddon." Robert Oppenheimer, the "Father of the Atomic Bomb," lost his security clearance and his position on the Atomic Energy Commission for voicing concerns and refusing to directly help build the hydrogen bomb in the 50s. He argued it was against the United States' best interests to develop it, because the USSR had no cities large enough to use it on, while the United States did. The United States also had plenty of large atomic bombs with pretty high yield already that were much cheaper to build. Thus, when the Soviets eventually created their own, they would be ones with a reason to have it, while we wasted tons of money giving it to them that could have been spent elsewhere. Just for reference: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Openheimer#Atomic_Energy_Commission http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Openheimer#Atomic_Energy... http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0078037/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0078037/ Great miniseries on Oppenheimer done by the BBC, if one can find it.
- gregd 13y agoI also highly recommend reading the book, American Prometheus. http://www.amazon.com/American-Prometheus-Triumph-Tragedy-Oppenheimer/dp/0375726268 http://www.amazon.com/American-Prometheus-Triumph-Tragedy-Op...
- yareally 13y agoI'll have to pick it up. I've always considered Oppenheimer one of the most interesting people to have lived. He was very charismatic, winning over scientist and bureaucrat alike and a compromiser when necessary, but yet would not compromise when it came to the issue of the hydrogen bomb at the height of "McCarthyism". Too bad he's mostly forgotten in present day history.
- gregd 13y agoHe was interesting. It's a shame how much he was ostracized by the very same people who used him to get to the atomic bomb. The book does his life and his life's work justice. It's an extremely interesting and well written account.
- walshemj 13y agoYes to play devils advocate working for Google on say algo updates means you are responsible for people losing their jobs. And I wont go into two faced nature of removing organic search terms from Google analytics but allowing the PPC customers access to that data. if I where Matt Cutts id sleep happier working for the NSA than Google at the moment