4 ms·
Costco is also interesting due to subtle non-uniformity between stores and a steadily changing product line-up. I'm lucky to live in an area where I'm an easy d
by bane 13y ago
Costco is also interesting due to subtle non-uniformity between stores and a steadily changing product line-up. I'm lucky to live in an area where I'm an easy drive to 3 Costcos within 10-15 minutes and 2 more within 25-30 minutes from my home and they all have subtly different products.
We'll find some item that we like there only for it to be completely gone 3 months later and never to return. While at another local Costco they have palettes full of it. 3 months after that the product will disappear from all Costcos and a different, but better one will show up everywhere. Things like Wine selection will also differ quite a bit from store to store.
That or there will be sudden changes to the packaging of staple items in the store for no real reason. Milk, for example, seems to get a packaging overhaul every year or so.
Either way, even with limited choice, over time the number of products you might buy at a Costco turns out to be quite a few.
Other retailers, on the other hand, are surprisingly more uniform in their product selection. The half dozen Targets in my area offer more or less the same products and fit it all within 1 or 2 master floor layouts.
- jmduke 13y agoI discovered this when going to a Target in Seattle after two decades of going to Targets in Virginia, and was pleasantly surprised when I could more or less find everything easily. It's, in a way, a similar value proposition as Starbucks/McDonald's: you trade quality for consistency. The fact that Aisle 17 is for dishwashing and cleaning supplies becomes a core principle of your company.
- twoodfin 13y agoI have heard that Costco is brutal with their suppliers and has no compunction about dropping products if they can't get them at a price that makes sense, given the limited number of SKUs they're prepared to stock. Their customers are now more or less trained to expect this, but I think it's a definite weakness in their model. If Amazon can reliably provide me with my "favorite" detergent, I'm likely to forgive a few dollars a year in added cost. Wine selection is probably a little easier to explain, given the bizarre maze of the three tier system. Thank god for the 21st Amendment, but the way states handle alcohol distribution makes me thankful for an expansive reading of the Commerce Clause.
- mikeash 13y agoI'm not sure that's a weakness so much as merely a difference. Some people have a "favorite detergent". Other people, such as myself, just want something of decent quality, and could not really care less what name is on the container. For you, Amazon's approach is better, because you're willing to pay more for the specific item you want. For me, that's completely unimportant, so why would I pay more? The two companies are covering different niches in that respect. Nothing wrong with that. No single company needs to be all things to all people, although I suspect Amazon wants to (and Costco does not).
- twoodfin 13y agoSure. If you can live the "Kirkland Life", you are Costco's perfect customer. But as the parent comment pointed out, their strategy puts them in a somewhat awkward position. As a rule, you want your customers to love your products. But then your business model requires that you take away products whether they're loved or not. Indeed, if they're loved so much that your supplier thinks they're entitled to a higher premium than an un-loved competitor, it's the more popular product that goes! Even the Kirkland products are doubtlessly farmed out to varying suppliers (with varying results). You're probably right that there's a big market for consumers of "good enough, consistency be damned". But I think a lot of Costco's market is after convenience and "low enough" prices. If Amazon can hit "low enough" prices and a wider, more consistent selection, Costco could be in trouble. Zero trips to the store is better than one, especially when you don't need to supplement Costco with other retailers to cover their gaps.
- mikeash 13y agoCostco needs their customers to love their products in aggregate, but not any one product in particular. They're good about quality, so I don't really have to care about brands. If I want detergent or paper towels or whatever, I just pick whatever looks good. If they pull one in favor of another, I don't care. If you want to buy specific brands on any given trip, Costco isn't for you, but if you just want something decent and don't care who made it, it works out well. You don't have to love the specific brands, just the stuff they carry in general. I'm sure Amazon could cause a lot of trouble for Costco if they can match their prices or come close, but I don't see that happening. I basically buy three categories of products at Costco: frozen food, fruit, and non-perishable bulk items like paper towels or toilet paper. I can't see Amazon ever coming close on the first two, simply because the inherent costs of delivering perishable items to the house are too high. They can pull off Prime because they're delivering items that have no problem being in transit for two days, but I can't see how they could deliver e.g. strawberries for a reasonable price ever. I'd love to be wrong, but I don't see it happening.
- cosmie 13y agoThose packaging overhauls are evil, even from a suppliers perspective. However, they're almost never for no reason, as they're very expensive for a supplier to do. Club packaging requirements are very particular to how they sell, in large bulk packs directly off pallets or steel racks. Usually the packaging is completely custom to the club, from the product packaging itself to the pallet packing. And no club wants the same as another (if they even stock the same product). This leads to new packaging having all kinds of unforeseen problems that slip through testing; from shifting in transit when using certain trucks, pallet crushing due to stack design, stretch wrap ripping for some reason, sub-optimal presentation when the pallet is thrown on the floor for sale, etc. The package refresh itself will take the supplier ~6-12 months (unless it's a critical deficiency in the packaging), so even if the problems present themselves immediately you're looking at a "yearly" overhaul. And then the cycle repeats itself, when new bugs are introduced (you just can't test for everything that's gonna hit at Club scale sales). Standard retailers use the same basic packaging styles, even if slightly customized for that client, so most of the 'gotchas' with those have been rooted out and accounted for, so refreshes are much less frequent. Edit: Unless you were talking about simple label changes. In which case you are correct in there being no real reason beyond the marketing department trying to keep itself employed. Supply chain departments hate it due to the headaches and costs associated with switching over (and writing off unused labels/packaging).