4 ms·
Snowden: "Google, Facebook, Microsoft, Yahoo, Apple, and the rest of our internet titans must ask themselves why they aren't fighting for our interests the same
by mtgx 13y ago
Snowden: "Google, Facebook, Microsoft, Yahoo, Apple, and the rest of our internet titans must ask themselves why they aren't fighting for our interests the same way".
Indeed, they must. Your move Google, Facebook, Microsoft, Yahoo and Apple.
- MrKurtz 13y agoShifting the blame and the burden for policy reform onto firms is not only silly but also unfair, you can't really expect them to shut down, they are not one man operations like Lavabit.
- zokier 13y ago> you can't really expect them to shut down Why not?
- greyman 13y agoIt is not unfair. At least some of them, most notably Google and Facebook, actively allure their users to share more and more of their private data, while misleadingly claiming, that they are able to keep them safe. If more and more people will realize the risks of sharing their personal data with those companies, it can endanger their whole business model. So who should fight most vigorously, if not them? And nobody says they have to immediately shut down.
- MrKurtz 13y agoYou can't declare that they're not fighting because you have no knowledge of what is being done by their lawyers and lobbyists, especially since the courts involved are secret. Lobbying scales better than shutting down or suspending service.
- craigching 13y agoRight, we have no knowledge that they're fighting for us. And until we do, we put our money where our mouths are, stop using their services until we can be sure they're honoring our privacy. If anyone is able to fight, it's them, not the small businesses. So put the burden on them, if they want our data, then prove they can keep it safe.
- kamjam 13y agoIt really is time for a Facebook competitor to stand up and say "we will say FK YOU to the NSA/US/any other government requesting your data" by being based somewhere else safe. I'm sure they could use all this to their advantage to gain a lot of traction right now. I remember a couple years back there was a lot of talk about open srouce/p2p based social network (mind is coming to a blank to remember the name)... something like that more appealing to the masses!
- rumbler 13y ago> you can't really expect them to shut down Well, before a few weeks ago, I couldn't really expect my government to spy on all its citizens, use secret courts to bully companies into giving them access to my data, share it with law enforcement for "parallel construction" (intelligence laundering) purposes, and lie to congress about what they were doing. If you had told me a few decades ago that this would be the situation in the United States at the start of the 21st century, I would have laughed in your face and called you a crackpot, a lunatic, a conspiracy theorist. Absent something like losing World War III, there was no way the United States could become a totalitarian state in my lifetime. Yet here we are.
- brador 13y agoYou mean: Your move Larry, Mark, Steve, Merissa and Tim. In the end the base unit of society is still the human, no matter how many layers we place around them.
- dmix 13y agocorrection: > no matter how many [lawyers] we place around them A CEO/Chairman hurting a public companies profit via protest against NSA would result in shareholder lawsuits. Another good example of the the legal constructs around corporatism and public stock markets hurting the inherent protectionism from abuse free markets offer society. Corporatism often prevents large companies from acting morally, whether by being protected from real repercussions for acting maliciously via being a single legal entity (resulting in mass settlements not individual employee liability) or their legal obligations to only care about short-term profits (post-IPO), not long term gains or societal benefit.
- robrenaud 13y agoWhat happened when Google left China?
- MrKurtz 13y agoTheir shares went down immediately after due to concerns they forfeited the opportunity to expand their business in the world's 2nd largest economy, but as the immediate economic damage was immaterial their decision wasn't followed with a deluge of shareholder lawsuits. Google already bowed out of one major market due to ethical disagreements, asking them to do that again with their home market is unrealistic - lobbying to mend the laws is the more sensible approach and one that scales better to businesses of that size. Besides despite disagreements with US policy it's still not China.
- mh- 13y agoUS policy: it's still not China. now there's a campaign slogan for 2016.
- a3n 13y agoIt's all about the billion$.