8 ms·
Two Providers of Secure E-Mail Shut Down
- camino020 13y agoInteresting to see talk about what is legal and what is not. Think about this: Everything Hitler did in the Nazi Germany was legal. How about a law that classifies tracking or stalking on the internet is the same as in person, therefore illegal?
- serf 13y agosnowden used lavabit? it shouldn't, but it makes me more confident in my choice of lavabit. good thing I didnt use webmail.
- philip1209 13y agoIn response to these email shutdowns, I propose a PGP key signing party in SOMA tomorrow.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- sker 13y agoReminds me of when they took Megaupload down. There was a domino effect where a lot of torrent and file sharing sites decided to pack their things and go home. First the file sharers, then the secure emails. I wonder who's going to be next? The reddits? The HNs?
- philip1209 13y agoI think it's just going to lead to decentralization. More, smaller fish.
- filipmaertens 13y agoI think you're absolutely right. The only effect that NSA/... (and let's be honest, any other country is just jealous they don't have the capabilities of an NSA :p) has on the Internet community is going to be a wider and further proliferation of darknets, P2P and F2F services.
- eliasmacpherson 13y agoIt's funny I think that's one of the primary results of the internet. I think of movie and music production, software, bitcoin, bittorrent and so on. I would argue they have been decentralised by the internet. I think centralised services are against the 'spirit of the internet'.
- guard-of-terra 13y agoThis is officially Iran level of government-busdiness interaction guys. US seems to have state religion now, that is State Security. Sin and get destroyed. Reminds me of USSR in that regard.
- tootie 13y agoSo long as they are doing this to target legitimate national security threats, it isn't. There is no filter on free speech nor any hint that one might be coming. Right now it's just overzealous prosecution that is nipping at the 4th amendment. The 1st amendment is secure for now.
- shiven 13y ago"State Security" as defined by a handful of war-mongers living in the past and bent upon visiting its ghosts on the present, and sadly, the future generation.
- MWil 13y agoRelated but I just checked the USPTO, and the trademark for "State Secrets" is available.
- raverbashing 13y agoThe question is, why is this "secure email" safer? Apparently, not as safe as some people assumed. Focus on security on the ends, not on the middle.
- mknits 13y agoIt's a victory of NSA-US govt. over the efforts of EFF and similar organizations. We must continue this fight to safeguard our future. Here are two free and secure email providers who keep themselves up only by donations: 1. https://openmailbox.org https://openmailbox.org 2. https://autistici.org https://autistici.org
- gregd 13y agoThere's also: https://www.cotse.net/ https://www.cotse.net/
- chadillac83 13y agoSSL errors on the 2nd... seems... worrisome.
- pero 13y agoI'm but a layman but browser-side SSL verification is essentially 3rd-party centralized validation of the authenticity of one side of an encryption mechanism - predetermined vendors tell the browser whether a SSL cert is as claimed and an SSL cert is only an encryption key. This service doesn't care whether a browser-maker thinks its cert is real; they also provide a means to validate that their downloadable cert is as claimed - the cert is valid encryption between you and them, from anyone not you and them, despite whatever errors a browser throws up.
- gphilip 13y agoPrevious discussion on OpenMailbox: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6174603 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6174603
- jacquesm 13y ago" Mike Janke, Silent Circle’s chief executive, said in a telephone interview late Thursday that his company had destroyed its server. “Gone. Can’t get it back. Nobody can,” he said. “We thought it was better to take flak from customers than be forced to turn it over.” That guy has brass balls. It may very well be that this will be interpreted as obstruction of justice, there is a specific element in there about destroying evidence. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obstruction_of_justice http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obstruction_of_justice
- binarymax 13y agoI wonder if they destroyed it before it was part of an investigation? It may have been preemptive to avoid that scenario when the Feds eventually did come knocking on the door. Edit - yes that looks to be the case. From their blog: We see the writing the wall, and we have decided that it is best for us to shut down Silent Mail now. We have not received subpoenas, warrants, security letters, or anything else by any government, and this is why we are acting now.
- filipmaertens 13y agoWhat he did was equally an act of heroism (in face of Internet history) and stupidity (in face of his own life). Perhaps, he should just have wiped and destroyed the disks, and have it "seemed like a system crash at a bad timing" caused it :)
- StavrosK 13y ago
- Spearchucker 13y agoObama is willing to deprive his constituents of their bread and butter to enforce surveillance. Un. Fucking. Believable. This is in no way Schadenfreude, but it does provide an opportunity for countries with more transparency, or less appetite for strong-arming their people.
- bredren 13y agoHow did Silent Circle become a "major secure email service provider?" Lavabit launched in 2004. Silent Circle launched "Silent Mail" four months ago. I don't see how SC's action belongs in the same sentence as what Lavabit was forced to do.
- SODaniel 13y agoLavabit was a much more "under the radar" provider. Silent circle has gained huge traction since they started and provide secure Phone, SMS and mail services. They may not be "equal" but silent circle is certainly more of a high profile target.
- bredren 13y agoWhat evidence is there of the huge traction? Have they announced actual numbers?
- shocks 13y agoThis is why I setup my own email server... Here is a great guide for anyone interested: https://www.exratione.com/2012/05/a-mailserver-on-ubuntu-1204-postfix-dovecot-mysql/ https://www.exratione.com/2012/05/a-mailserver-on-ubuntu-120... I set mine up on CentOS 5 using this guide. I would recommend you also look at DKIM signing and SPF records to improve deliverability! :)
- rgbrenner 13y agoemail is not encrypted... they'll just have your hosting provider or ISP copy your email when it's received/sent
- techsupporter 13y agoMy e-mail system is set to prefer TLS wherever possible. Spot-checks of headers incoming from other sources show that, at the minimum, a TLS session is successfully negotiated approximately 85% of the time so messages from those sources are presumed to be encrypted while in transit. All clients must connect using TLS (either IMAP-S or HTTPS). Yes, unencrypted copies likely exist on the sending side (the data storage disks for my e-mail servers are encrypted) and the client storage for some of my users is in the clear but it's not possible for my ISP to read the bits in flight.
- rgbrenner 13y agoso the nsa gets a list of IP addresses of mail servers that sent you mail, and sends a subpoena to each of those providers instead.
- dasil003 13y agoIf they want to get you they're gonna get you. The point is that takes a lot more work than the analyst sitting at his desk typing in friggin Google searches on your Gmail.
- 13y ago
- tghw 13y agoIt seems like there's an opportunity for a PGP mail forwarder, a service that encrypts all incoming mail and then forwards it without saving anything in the process. I'd pay bitcoins for that.
- __alexs 13y agoThis sounds totally useless as a 3rd party service due to how obvious a target it would be but a simple encrypting proxy or MTA config would be pretty useful for self hosted setups.
- tghw 13y agoIt'd be much less of a target than any encrypted hosted mail since it wouldn't store anything, just be a pass-through filter. Yeah, ideally we would all have our own encrypted, self hosted setup, but that's just not realistic.
- zem 13y agoas someone who (wisely or unwisely) depends on my email account as an online datastore, the prospect of it just shutting down overnight and my losing everything is terrifying. which probably means it's time to start some sort of active backup mechanism, but more to the point i do wonder if any of lavabit's or silent circle's clients ran into the same predicament.
- kayoone 13y agoHm, i wonder why Silent Circle just went ahead and shutdown their relativly young and unknown mailservice without any clear reason other than to use the opportunity to do get some publicity for their other secure services. Lavabit was alot bigger than Silent Circle and this announcement seems a bit suspicious to me. I might me totally wrong, but going ahead and shutting down the service on the same day a popular competitor does without any clear reason while at the same time embracing their other still running services seems a bit strange to me.
- eliasmacpherson 13y agoI don't think 'any news is good news' applies to secure services providers. It will not make other offerings more appealing. Why bother with a provider that has to resort to this kind of behaviour to protect its customers?
- jonahx 13y ago> Taken together, the closures signal that e-mails, even if they are encrypted, can be accessed by government authorities and that the only way to prevent turning over the data is to obliterate the servers that the data sits on. Can someone explain to me how this is possible? Or is this inaccurate?
- bhitov 13y agoI think it is inaccurate. The concerns of lavabit and silent circle seemed to be about unencrypted email.
- MagicWishMonkey 13y agoTheir concerns are not about unencrypted email, they refuse to install eavesdropping equipment in their server rack. You can encrypt your email all you want but it's not encrypted in the space between your load balancer and your app server.
- bhitov 13y agoI think in general "encrypted email" refers to end-to-end encrypted email which of course does not have that problem.
- Zigurd 13y agoThat's probably inaccurate. It is likely that the problem Lavabit faced was being required to transmit malware to their customers.
- eliasmacpherson 13y agoA slashdot commenter put this up a few weeks ago, it's worthwhile viewing for an hour - you can get an idea of what the providers are going through. There's a good interview with an archive.org employee around who also received one, and tried to resist in his capacity as a librarian. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C25EkdWLU1k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C25EkdWLU1k
- mtgx 13y agoI remember that guy. I think he was the first to fight an NSL, and to make it so you can tell your lawyer about NSL's. He also tried to crowdfund a very privacy-oriented ISP a while ago, but he could only do it on IndieGoGo, and it was very new at the time, and I don't think he completed the goal. http://news.cnet.com/8301-31921_3-57412225-281/this-internet-provider-pledges-to-put-your-privacy-first-always/ http://news.cnet.com/8301-31921_3-57412225-281/this-internet...
- eliasmacpherson 13y agoThe archive.org guy: http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/elements/2013/06/what-its-like-to-get-a-national-security-letter.html http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/elements/2013/06/what-...
- fastfade 13y agoThe USGOV just shot Paul Revere's horse. No big deal - the majority of the US electorate are so disengaged they'll never know/care.