2 ms·
> I had said identity authority, not currency authority. Look at Chaum's online protocol again, and find the place where an authority on identities is required.
by mindslight 13y ago
> I had said identity authority, not currency authority. Look at Chaum's online protocol again, and find the place where an authority on identities is required. The bank is the only party in the system that requires a signing key.
Yes, but something has to instill faith in that bank. This is real-world identity in a rule of law jurisdiction, which is why they used the word "bank". "Banks" can't have their only point of contact be an onion address.
> .. you can have multiple banks that are responsible .. or to reimburse the bank's customers e.g. FDIC
You're missing that all of these systems rely on the incumbent identity providers (governments) to not shut down the banks. "Group signatures" only obfuscate this problem, the signers still cannot be anonymous, lest you're back in Sybil attack territory.
> you need to present a novel definition ... What I am saying is that such a definition is necessary, at least as far as cryptography is concerned
First, most of the definitions you want for don't globally exist because we've given up the assumption of global consistency. The answer to my hypothetical ABC example is "no" if you are deciding to accept the coin, and "how fast can you spend it" if you already have it. Each node's view of the world is quite simplistic - the emergent system behavior is the important part. And IIRC the paper does analyze as-coded transaction validity, and of course comes out with a probabilistic answer.
More importantly, stop talking about "cryptography". Do you have reason to believe that ECDSA signatures or SHA2 proofs of work are broken? These are the only cryptographic parts of Bitcoin, and there is nothing novel about them. The novelty is a stochastic solution to Byzantine agreement, which is a protocols problem. I keep mentioning this, and you keep blowing right past it to harp on transaction properties that only make sense in the context of well-defined authority.
- betterunix 13y agoI think the problem here is that you are trying to decouple money from the government. If you have a definition of money and an economic theory that allows for such a system, that is fine. Do you have such a definition or theory, and are you willing to share it? "most of the definitions you want for don't globally exist because we've given up the assumption of global consistency" You might have, but for currency to work there needs to be consistency across the entire market (not necessarily all markets, of course; currency exchanges exist mainly to allow people to move between markets). One of the most important functions of money is as a medium of exchange, which requires an agreement across the entire market about what constitutes valid money. "More importantly, stop talking about "cryptography"." Why should I? Digital cash is a cryptography problem. Secure multiparty computation is a major field of study in cryptography; Silvio Micali and Shafi Goldwasser, the pair who recently won a Turing award for their work on defining public key cryptography, also happen to have done extensive SMC work over their respective careers. Cryptographic solutions to the Byzantine Generals problem have been presented many times over the past 20 years. No matter how you try to describe Bitcoin, it absolutely is a cryptosystem and cryptography absolutely is relevant to the conversation. Furthermore it is dead wrong to think that the security of a signature system or a hash function is the whole story. Unless you can rigorously prove that the security of ECDSA and SHA256 imply the security of Bitcoin (whatever the rigorous definition of security would be for Bitcoin), there is no point in saying that ECDSA and SHA256 are secure. Nobody is calling their security into question here. Bitcoin can be insecure in the cryptographic sense even if ECDSA and SHA256 are secure, unless you think that Bitcoin is a signature system or a hash function. "you keep blowing right past it" What I keep doing is asking for definitions. You have ignored or avoided the question over and over again here. To be clear, I am asking you to give a rigorous definition of the security property you want to achieve. That can and should be given as a corollary to a definition of money, since you are not using the definitions economists are familiar with. If Bitcoin is nothing more than a solution to the Byzantine agreement problem, then I see no reason to continue talking about money -- unless you can define money in terms of Byzantine agreement.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]