3 ms·
> hey would charge him with violating the terms of the NSL and the jury would acquit him anyway. You're assuming he would have a trial with a jury. I think th
by grecy 13y ago
> hey would charge him with violating the terms of the NSL and the jury would acquit him anyway.
You're assuming he would have a trial with a jury.
I think that's a big assumption.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoAssuming he is a US citizen, and doesn't waive his right to a jury trial (which he should not), the only way to try him would be in front of a jury. That doesn't apply if you are an 'enemy combatant' and held at Gitmo. I am not aware of any criminal proceeding in which the prosecution can prevent it from being heard by a jury, but I am also not a lawyer. Do you know of a situation other than military tribunals or court marshalls where the jury right does not apply?
- grecy 13y agoSure, the American citizens overseas that are purposefully being killed by drones. They didn't get a jury trial. Also, you don't know about any of the criminal proceedings going on in the FISA court, that's the whole point.
- mc32 13y agoYou can say that about anyone engaging in war. Let's say the US were at war with Mexico and you were an American but fighting for the Mexican Army, you would not get special treatment from the American side for being an American --at that point you're just a foe. That's how they view that.
- grecy 13y agoOf course, they are the ones determining if you're fighting for the other side. Let's say I'm an American living in a foreign country and I read the Koran, or attend a Mosque, or even actually hang out with some known Al Qaeda guys because they are hilarious (not because I in any way want to do anything they do).... I'm labeled guilty and murdered without a court case to determine what I was even doing.