5 ms·
The studies have been done. Nicotine on its own is orders of magnitude safer than tobacco (and so I find this scaremongering sensationalistic NYT article deeply
by gwern 13y ago
The studies have been done. Nicotine on its own is orders of magnitude safer than tobacco (and so I find this scaremongering sensationalistic NYT article deeply anger-inducing if it means that anyone decides to keep smoking rather than switch to e-cigs or if it helps ban or regulate e-cigs), which is why things like nicotine patches and gum are no longer prescription-only.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- MrMember 13y ago>My question would be, what's the effect to people around you when you smoke one? Is it a stench? I found this (pdf warning): http://www.healthnz.co.nz/RuyanCartridgeReport30-Oct-08.pdf http://www.healthnz.co.nz/RuyanCartridgeReport30-Oct-08.pdf "Inhaled nicotine in cigarette smoke is over 98% absorbed, and so the exhaled mist of the e-cigarette is composed of propylene glycol, and probably contains almost no nicotine; and no CO." It's also completely odorless.
- nanidin 13y agoFrom the wikipedia page about fog machines[1]: "Short term exposure to glycol fog can be associated with headaches, dizziness, drowsiness and tiredness. Long term exposure to smoke and fog can be related to upper airway and voice symptoms. Extended (multi-year) exposure to smoke and fog has been associated with both short-term and long-term respiratory health problems." [1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fog_machine http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fog_machine
- freehunter 13y agoI would wonder if this isn't caused by the fact that it's difficult to breathe something that isn't the fog when you're in an area with a fog machine. I don't know any smokers who don't take a breath of fresh air when they're smoking, or e-cig users who don't do the same. In a room with a fog machine going, there may not be any fresh air to breathe.
- guizzy 13y agoTo be clear; most liquids are not really odorless, but the odor is not inherent to ecig vapor. It's the odor of the flavoring used, so fruit-flavored liquid will smell like fruit-flavored air freshener.
- readme 13y ago@MrMember Sorry I deleted my other comment, but I can't help but laugh at your response that they exhale propylene glycol, ROFL. That's the chemical used to de-ice airplanes!!! Wikipedia says that the oral toxicity of it is low, but it can be harmful in large amounts. So I would have to casually guess that the long term effects of it, and if you smoke heavily, that it could be a problem.
- freehunter 13y agoYou know what chemical we use around here to de-ice? Salt. Both of these are generally recognized as safe and are approved for both human and animal food additives. The anti-freeze that is made with propylene glycol is labeled as non-toxic. So really I'm not sure what you're laughing at.
- readme 13y agoI wouldn't want to inhale and exhale salt all day, either.
- EpicEng 13y agoIt's also the same chemical used in asthma inhalers and, oh yeah, food. Your argument is completely irrational. Oh, it's used for 'X', it must be bad!
- dsl 13y agoAccording to Wikipedia, "Propylene glycol is considered generally recognized as safe (GRAS) by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, and it is used as an humectant (E1520), solvent, and preservative in food ... It is also used in pharmaceutical and personal care products."
- daraul 13y agoPropylene glycol is indeed a major component of antifreeze, such as what is used to de-ice airplanes. It's also a major component of automobile antifreeze. It's also true that automotive antifreeze is generally toxic to humans and animals. It's especially concerning because the propylene glycol helps make them sweet, which makes them attractive for kids and animals to drink. However, the toxicity of these liquids has more to do with the methanol and ethanol glycol in them than the propylene glycol. The first two are generally known to be toxic: The third is generally recognized as a safe food additive, and is indeed used as coolant/antifreeze around food processing where the potential for leaks and ingestion exist.
- mathattack 13y agoIn Japan they have (or had) nicotine energy drinks.