4 ms·
The classified documents being hosted on AWS were in fact illegal to do so, and thus against the AUP of AWS so it was perfectly reasonable and appropriate to pu
by btilly 13y ago
The classified documents being hosted on AWS were in fact illegal to do so, and thus against the AUP of AWS so it was perfectly reasonable and appropriate to pull the plug.
If they were illegal, then what law was broken in hosting them?
Remember, newspapers are in the business of getting information sent to them by people who broke rules in doing so, and then hosting/publishing/otherwise distributing said information to the public. Despite the fact that there are powerful people who do not want that to happen. And said powerful people are quick to claim that the law is on their side, whether or not it is.
Examples include Watergate, The Pentagon Papers, Snowden's revelations, and (of course) Wikileaks. In every case newspapers were threatened.
The wikileaks data dump is in no way comparable to Watergate and singular reporting and investigation of specfic illegal acts.
So exposing one crime is OK, but exposing 1000 is not?
With EVERY case there are people telling us that this case is different, and not like famous cases of the past. They are wrong. We have amnesia about how similar they, in fact, are.
Take Watergate since you brought it up. The burglars were arrested June 17, 1972. Bob Woodward reported that they had connections to Howard Hunt on June 20, 1972. This began a continuous series of reporting that the country as a whole did not care about. Were you alive back then, I would be willing to bet that, like the majority that re-elected Nixon in a landslide on November 7, 1972, you would have thought that this was not an important story, and would have objected to the witchhunt.
Public opinion did not begin its slide until January, 1973. (http://www.nationaljournal.com/politics/wait-about-two-months-then-check-the-president-s-approval-rating-20130522 http://www.nationaljournal.com/politics/wait-about-two-month... has a graph showing the shifts in approval.)
- res0nat0r 13y agoYes Mannings document release was in no way at all comparable to Ellsberg. If Manning had released specific note: specific documents relating to crimes this would be a totally different story. IE: Just leaking the collateral murder video, or other specific crimes, and going through a reporter who properly vets the content is totally different that a site wide document dump. Just because you don't like one thing the government is doing does not mean you can release everything the government is doing. It is illegal to disseminate, store, transmit, etc, classified material if you aren't allowed to do so. That is the crime, and it also against the AUP and is laid out right near the beginning of the document here: http://aws.amazon.com/aup/ http://aws.amazon.com/aup/
- btilly 13y agoIt is illegal to disseminate, store, transmit, etc, classified material if you aren't allowed to do so. Really? Which law? Can you point to examples of judges agreeing with this theory? Why did nobody come down on various newspapers for transmitting the clearly classified information that they got from Snowden?
- res0nat0r 13y agoFeel free to read wikipedia as a starting point: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classified_information http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classified_information > Access is restricted by law or regulation to particular groups of people and mishandling can incur criminal penalties. I'm sure someone could have tried to throw the hammer down about the Snowden leak, but they probably realized they would look ridiculous doing that over a few Powerpoint slides vs. thousands of diplomatic cables and other information which were released by Manning. Also note: Snowden is releasing specific information related to a specific crime. I keep repeating this because it is highly relevant to whistleblower protections && reporter shields etc.