3 ms·
The biggest thing that jumped out at me was that signal vs. noise is the most important criteria for a service to be used, but what a lot of analyses miss is th
by btilly 13y ago
The biggest thing that jumped out at me was that signal vs. noise is the most important criteria for a service to be used, but what a lot of analyses miss is that you have to interpret something before you can decide if it is a signal or not, and that interpretation is by definition individual. I think this is what happens a lot of the time when people complain about a site becoming "too big", idealizing the past when the "riff-raff" hadn't gotten in. But I think this is mistaken for the same reason that generational rants about the fecklessness of the youth are mistaken, ie Occam's razor says that we are probably not all Nietzschean superman vs newcomer's being idiots, but instead we are probably more or less equal. What is happening instead is that as a larger group comes to a site, a larger number of interests and opinions come as well. And what I interpret as noise, what those people interpret as signal.
What you say sounds reasonable, but I believe it is wrong.
Sites like Slashdot back in the day, or Hacker News when it started, start with a core of people who were self-selected in a way that really does select for competent people. That is why they become an "in crowd" that others want to become part of.
As more enter, there is a natural tendency for topics to broaden, AND for average quality to drop.
That is not to say that it is only groups of tech people that can be consistently above average quality. It isn't. But the forums that expand out of their original niche and go mainstream do tend to start off as particularly special places.