5 ms·
Don't marry if you are a guy. At present, marriage is a contract with no upside for you. You gain nothing from marriage that you can't get from a committed non-
by yummyfajitas 18y ago
Don't marry if you are a guy. At present, marriage is a contract with no upside for you. You gain nothing from marriage that you can't get from a committed non-marital relationship, and stand to lose a lot.
- furburger 18y agostill fuming over the CL erotic services decision i see
- endtime 18y agoHow many women out there want to raise kids out of wedlock? Probably not many, and the same is probably true of most men. Or are you assuming that men don't want to have families?
- pohl 18y agoI think that what women want is to raise a child with a partner. Neither a wedding nor a state-enforced contract is required for a committed, long-term, loving relationship. There is an increasing phenomenon of women choosing to give birth out of wedlock. It's not yet clear if they are having children without a cohabitant partner. http://roomfordebate.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/05/17/a-new-trend-in-motherhood/ http://roomfordebate.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/05/17/a-new-tren...
- endtime 18y ago>I think that what women want is to raise a child with a partner. I really think you're being unrealistic if you think women don't care about getting married before having children with someone. You can place whatever value judgments you like on the reasons for that, but to say it isn't the case isn't realistic.
- Jem 18y agoPlease don't generalise women - some of us really don't care. (I'm 15 weeks pregnant, I have no intentions of getting married.)
- endtime 18y agoSorry if my wording wasn't clear - I interpreted my comment's parent as a generalization, actually. I should have said something like: >I really think you're being unrealistic if you think most women don't care about getting married before having children with someone
- calvin 18y agoYou can gain quite a lot. If you want a partner beside you to learn from and grow closer to, it can be a great thing. If you want children to love and raise and educate, marriage can be awesome. Those are two reasons I look forward to marriage when I meet the right woman. If those aren't your priorities though, then I would agree, marriage probably isn't a good option for you. If you view marriage as "what you can get" rather than "what you can give/share" then it will not work and will result in unhappiness.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoYou can get all those things from a committed non-marital relationship. Marriage (by which I mean the contract enforced by your state) adds nothing to the mix beyond a massive financial liability (for the man) if the relationship ends. Read this article for an example of the bad results of marriage: http://www.nytimes.com/2009/05/17/magazine/17foreclosure-t.html?pagewanted=1&_r=1 http://www.nytimes.com/2009/05/17/magazine/17foreclosure-t.h...
- cujo 18y agoI think you're still stuck with a financial liability if you decide to have kids with non person you aren't married to. Plus there are tax breaks for being married. But that is just monetary. In reality most people in the US aren't as inclined to have life partners without the marriage part. And frankly, there is something special about professing your commitment to another person in front of your community that somehow makes your bond with your partner stronger. Is marriage required? Probably not. But I think you are missing a good part of it by claiming financial reasons for despising marriage.
- falien 18y agohow about philosophical, political, legal, and financial?
- grandalf 18y agoTax breaks for being married? Quite the contrary. You pay additional taxes if you marry. Do the math for single vs married tax rates at various income levels. Also, if you file as married (jointly or separately) if one person itemizes the other must itemize, or vice versa w/ the standard deduction. One gets big tax breaks for owing money to a bank for a mortgage loan or for having children, but not simply for being married. Hence the term "marriage penalty".
- garply 18y agoIn all seriousness, if you don't want children, what is the purpose of marriage? What little I know about divorces and children suggests that marriage functions as a crude insurance policy for the kids - which seems reasonable. But if you just want to live with somebody, other than perhaps being able to do some small tax optimization and handle stuff like medical decisions if your spouse is unconscious, what's the point?
- scott_s 18y agoMarriage is a way of saying "My intention is to spend the rest of my life with you as my partner." That means something to your partner. If you're not willing to say that, then that means something, too.
- cglee 18y agoI guess this conversation precludes same-sex couples.
- jrockway 18y agoOnly in third-world states.
- pohl 18y agoThat's an interesting perspective. What you're saying is that marriage is a mode of communication for that one sentiment. Are there other modes of communicating the same sentiment? (an epic poem, breaking into heartfelt song, getting tattoos,...) Are they all equivalent? Does choosing to not express it by marriage necessarily imply that one is not willing to express it at all?
- scott_s 18y agoIt doesn't just communicate it to your partner, but to society. Getting married is a ritualized promise that is done before one's community of family and friends. I think saying the vows to your partner, in front of your family and friends, is markedly different than, say, writing a poem and getting tattoos. I suppose marriage is what you make of it. I consider being married to be a different state than not being married. I don't see any state change happening from writing a poem. But there is one with getting tattoos. Whether or not you get married in the eyes of the state or a church I don't think is important. But I do think that promise is important, and it is further weighted if done publicly.
- pohl 18y agoI can dig that. I've been through the process myself. In the beginning, my thoughts on the matter were perfectly in line with yours. Now that I'm on the other side, I've seen that neither the church, nor the state, nor the social network of community witnesses (nor the legal commitment of having adopted her two sons for that matter) could stand in the way of her caprice-driven dalliances. And, living in a "No Fault Divorce" state meant that her violation of the terms of the marriage provided me no benefit or protection when it came time to kick her to the curb out of self-preservation. Society, with all its witnessing, was nowhere to be found. Everybody wants to come to the wedding. Nobody wants to come to the divorce. Next time I'll opt for the tattoo. ;-)
- axod 18y ago* Children * Taxes * Commitment
- patrickg-zill 18y agoIt used to be that marriage was a contract between you, your intended spouse, and God. Now, it is a contract between you, your intended spouse, and "The State". And therefore when you marry you are giving the State some measure of control over your life.
- eli 18y agoHow so? Seems more like a contract between you and your spouse that has been approved of by the state.
- scott_s 18y agoAnd, I'd like to add, witnessed by everyone important in your life.
- Retric 18y agoLast friday I had to stand in front of a judge and say that two people where not living together for the last year so they could get a divorce in the state of Virginia. After 6 months of marriage it took a year, a judge, an attorney, and a witness, plus some cash to finally separate them. If they had been married for 10 years then there would be Social Security implications etc. Plus I think they still force you to take a blood test ect. PS: Separation of Church and State my ass.
- jhancock 18y agorational for divorce proceedings through state courts has little to do with Church. The courts are mostly dealing with issues of property.
- Retric 18y agoThen why should the state care if they lived together? It's one thing to have both people say we agree to split property like this it's another to say you have to wait and jump though a lot of hoops to get divorced. Consider two people that want a divorce, but can't really afford separate households at this point and don't want to sell the house when the economy is bad. Granted this is not the "normal" path but plenty of people get divorced without hating each other.
- lutorm 18y agoDefinitely not true if you are a foreign national...
- eli 18y agoUh, you are aware of the concept of a pre-nup, right? I'm pretty sure a marriage + a solid pre-nuptial agreement would put you on much better legal/financial ground than a "committed non-martial relationship" without a written contract.
- SteveC 18y agoIn the UK what you can do with a pre-nuptial agreement is very limited.
- vaksel 18y agoapparently prenups are pretty much worthless in this day and age. Even if its air tight, the other lawyer can just say that they were forced to sign the prenup(i.e. no prenup = no marriage) and poof, your air tight prenup is null and void
- eli 18y agoIt's pretty simple: both you and your spouse-to-be need a lawyer to review the document before signing it. Then nobody can claim they were forced or didn't understand. And, really, this is pretty basic legal advice. You should always have an independent, disinterested lawyer review contracts before you sign them.