4 ms·
The commenting/upvoting system stink over at /. The Reddit/HN style is so much better. They should have switched a while ago. It makes the site still feel like
by bluedino 13y ago
The commenting/upvoting system stink over at /. The Reddit/HN style is so much better. They should have switched a while ago. It makes the site still feel like 1997.
- qu4z-2 13y agoPersonally, I prefer the slashdot system. Limited voting points makes you think more carefully about spending them, and being able to differentiate between +1 Insightful and +1 Funny is nice too. Also, moving popular posts to the top is great for readers, but voters will then tend to upvote the already popular comments.
- jdp23 13y agoAgreed about the value of differentiating between different kinds of +/-1. Also Slashdot's meta-moderation is a significant advancement on its successors.
- lmm 13y agoDisagree with the meta-moderation. It makes the site very echo-chambery, because people start modding up posts in line with the groupthink so that they will get meta-moderated positively.
- OGC 13y agoLack of a slashdot-like voting system is one of the reasons why, on reddit, subreddits become unreadable when they they hit a number of subscribers (e.g. 100k).