3 ms·
I can't use Linux on my laptop without some closed source blobs - does that make Linux not open? No, because you can get other laptops without this problem. Li
by Macha 13y ago
I can't use Linux on my laptop without some closed source blobs - does that make Linux not open?
No, because you can get other laptops without this problem. Likewise, you can get other Android devices such as the Nexus 10 or Galaxy Nexus which are capable of using the result.
This sucks as it means you now need to choose between a device that's sufficiently open or a device that's up to date, and it's certainly worth criticising Google for, but it's not enough to claim that Android is as closed as iOS or Windows (yet - if they do the same to the next Nexus 10 and continue releasing Nexus devices that can't boot AOSP, then it's concerning, or if they drop support for the devices that are currently able to use the open source code)
- georgemcbay 13y agoI agree with you overall but find the Linux analogy a bit flawed since it doesn't apply to any laptops that are officially "blessed" in the way Nexus devices are with Google/Android.
- binarycrusader 13y agoI'd buy that argument if there weren't an obvious, gigantic flaw with it: no video device support (which means you can't even boot to the Android home screen) for the new Nexus 7 Google was aware of all of these issues and still made the hardware choices they did. They could have chosen differently. These are flagship Google devices; my expectations are (I think rightfully) different for those than some random device.
- sangnoir 13y agoOf course they were aware of the issue, if you read what JBQ wrote, he mentioned this was escalated 6 months ago. It doesn't take a leap of the imagination to conclude that the expectation was the issue would be resolved by the time the product was available for sale. Perhaps Qualcomm even stringed them along (I'm speculating) JBQ says he's very frustrated with the "lawyers", for what exact reasons- I don't know. Maybe he feels like they are not exerting enough pressure, or maybe it's Qualcomm's lawyers he's pissed at. You cannot say Google (or at least JBQ) knew how this would turn out.