4 ms·
> In other words, just do your job anyway, just taking the inadmissible evidence as a hint of what to look for. But then you're allowing evidence collection by
by grecy 13y ago
> In other words, just do your job anyway, just taking the inadmissible evidence as a hint of what to look for.
But then you're allowing evidence collection by any means.
I'll just break into your house and rifle through your documents and possessions until I find evidence you have committed a crime. Better yet, I'll kidnap and torture you until you confess to something. Once I have that (illegal) confession, I'll start my "parallel construction" until I find another way to prove you guilty of whatever it was you confessed to.
See any problem with that?
- AnthonyMouse 13y ago> See any problem with that? Exactly. The purpose of the rule excluding improperly obtained evidence is to penalize the government for obtaining it improperly. It's a mechanism designed to ensure compliance: Take away the ability of law enforcement to benefit by breaking the rules and you get less rule breaking. What this is is an end run around all that. The government benefits from violating the constitution by learning which rocks to turn over to make their case and the courts can't punish them for that by taking away the fruits of the illegal search because the government doesn't tell them about it in the first place.