4 ms·
Really, "parallel construction" sounds like what any forensic analyst would do in the case of definitive-yet-inadmissible evidence: find other evidence to prov
by derefr 13y ago
Really, "parallel construction" sounds like what any forensic analyst would do in the case of definitive-yet-inadmissible evidence: find other evidence to prove what you already "know" (which can also turn out to go against what you "know.") In other words, just do your job anyway, just taking the inadmissible evidence as a hint of what to look for.
- biff 13y agoIt also sounds more pleasant than "dragnet" or "fishing expedition", but if this starts by treating everybody as a possible suspect for an undetermined crime those terms are closer to the truth. A forensic analyst doesn't get started until it looks like a crime's been committed.
- mtgx 13y agoIt's almost like they're using the 1984's Newspeak as guidelines for naming this sort of stuff.
- AnthonyMouse 13y agoNineteen Eighty-Four was published the same year the US changed the name of the Department of War to be the Department of Defense. It's not like it's a new thing. The sad part is that people continue to fall for it.
- caf 13y agoI thought the "fruit of the poisonous tree" doctrine disallowed that.
- stonemetal 13y agoIt does that is why you have to hide it by parallel construction.
- mtgx 13y agoSo it's illegal.
- stonemetal 13y agoI would say it clearly violates the 6th amendment, but I am an uneducated bumpkin when it comes to legal matters. to be confronted with the witnesses against him; Witnesses in this passage supposedly applies to evidence, not just people witnesses. Therefore it should violate that part.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Witnesses in this passage supposedly applies to evidence, not just people witnesses. Witnesses are the people that are the source of evidence. Testimony is one form of evidence, but physical evidence still comes from people.
- zachrose 13y agoWould anybody not expect the U.S. Supreme Court to strike down parallel construction, given a clean enough case?
- jacoblyles 13y agoJaded libertarian here - I'm pretty sure the Supreme Court interprets the Constitution with the help of a Ouija board, a fifth of whisky, an intern dressed as lady liberty, cryptic signs hidden in the music of Katy Perry, and Alito's pair of lucky dice.
- apalmer 13y agowell any given set of supreme court judges may come to any particular conclusion, and i am not a lawyer so take it for what its worth: parallel construction as concept probably there could be some debate over the specific implementation where neither defense, prosecution or judge is made aware of the actual facts of the case and the enforcement officials actually lie in sworn testimony? not sure why this would even have to go to the supreme court its plain simple and unambiguous perjury.
- apalmer 13y agoIf you know the 'hint' is 50% likely to be true, and the 'hint' is specific enough to check this person at this time, in this place, and the 'hint' provider and the 'hint' acceptor are all working for the same government and are aware of this fact... then how does this differ from the government just using whatever means it wants to collect whatever evidence it wants and pretending that it didnt?
- grecy 13y ago> In other words, just do your job anyway, just taking the inadmissible evidence as a hint of what to look for. But then you're allowing evidence collection by any means. I'll just break into your house and rifle through your documents and possessions until I find evidence you have committed a crime. Better yet, I'll kidnap and torture you until you confess to something. Once I have that (illegal) confession, I'll start my "parallel construction" until I find another way to prove you guilty of whatever it was you confessed to. See any problem with that?
- AnthonyMouse 13y ago> See any problem with that? Exactly. The purpose of the rule excluding improperly obtained evidence is to penalize the government for obtaining it improperly. It's a mechanism designed to ensure compliance: Take away the ability of law enforcement to benefit by breaking the rules and you get less rule breaking. What this is is an end run around all that. The government benefits from violating the constitution by learning which rocks to turn over to make their case and the courts can't punish them for that by taking away the fruits of the illegal search because the government doesn't tell them about it in the first place.
- VladRussian2 13y ago>Really, "parallel construction" sounds like what any forensic analyst would do in the case of definitive-yet-inadmissible evidence that said analyst came by as result of committing a crime (deliberately violating 4th of citizens without probable cause)