3 ms·
>> "Politics, like religion, is a topic where >> there's no threshold of expertise for expressing >> an opinion." > I agree that this is how people
by ColinWright 13y ago
>> "Politics, like religion, is a topic where
>> there's no threshold of expertise for expressing
>> an opinion."
> I agree that this is how people tend to see it.
> But it isn't really true. Like JavaScript or auto
> mechanics or animal husbandry, there is indeed a
> threshold of expertise for expressing a *meaningful*
> opinion.
But that's the entire point. Lots and lots of people feel that they have something to say, and they say it, whereas very few actually have a meaningful opinion, and they get drowned out.
Although you say "it isn't really true" you have, in fact, agreed entirely.
- veidr 13y agoRight, I am not disagreeing with the OP's premise. I'm more just lamenting the truth of it -- and expressing disappointment that we haven't seen better discourse here on HN (where actually I think the signal to noise on stuff like node vs go, should you ever use rails for anything, etc, is actually pretty good, all things considered...). Edit/Addition: What I mean to say is, the article isn't wrong, but the people it describes are wrong. Wrong to think that weighing in on a serious topic with essentially zero knowledge is acceptable, and wrong to conflate their politics with their identity. There is a bedrock of objective truth underlying virtually any political discussion, and it is just as stupid to conflate your own individual identity with a political party or TV station as it is to do the same thing with your smartphone OS or web app framework.