10 ms·
Keep Your Identity Small (2009)
- D9u 13y agoAmong my drinking buddies we have one inviolable and long standing rule: No discussions of religion or politics
- ColinWright 13y agoThis was mentioned in the thread: "HN is Becoming 2005 Slashdot" (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6157485 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6157485) It makes for an interesting read concerning speculation as to why HN is becoming less and less technical over time, and more about politics. Technical issues and articles take time to read, digest, and understand. It takes a minimum level of expertise to be able to comment usefully on technical issues, so by the time a technical submission has been read properly, it's too late for it to reach the HN front page. An interesting dilemma.
- dasil003 13y agoDefinitely interesting. I'd say if we want to actively fight the entropy of the social news mechanic (ie. the feedback loop of popularity winning and slight dumbing down of anything increasing popularity), then perhaps we should glance quickly at an article and then jump back and upvote it based a snap judgement of its technical depth. Of course we run the risk of upvoting well-dressed crackpot nonsense, but that's probably a lesser risk than becoming reddit.
- oelmekki 13y agoI don't know if you guys proceed the same as me, but I merely open a tenth of links on home or new page. Actually, when doing so, you can consider any opened link deserves an upvote, provided that at first glance, it is what the link title promised : it attracted your attention so may attract other people. Nevermind if the point made in the linked article you upvoted is valid or not after a detailed review, the subject is interesting and may lead to interesting discussions - and top comments will instantly warn if the point is not valid.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- maaaats 13y agoAnd is why upvotes in the first <period of time> shouldn't be weighted heavier. That only promotes easy-to-digest content.
- DanielBMarkham 13y agoI believe there's a bit of a false dichotomy implied here that there exists a contrast between things that people identify with and things people must have expertise in. I'd argue that anybody spending dozens of hours studying Haskell innards is probably heavily emotionally-motivated to learn Haskell. We just don't know what that motivation is. So it's not tech stuff on one side, fluffy emotional stuff on the other. Much more complicated than that. But yes, HN rewards things that receive quick votes. Any article requiring more than 20 minutes to consume, by definition will never reach the front page. That's why it's always the same cast of clowns who write things with emotional appeal that end up getting on the front. It's the combination of hero worship, easy-to-digest subject, emotional impact, and big fan base. I think PG is way off-base here about the ease of commenting. Commenting doesn't drive articles to the front. Voting does. Popularity on HN and quality of comments are two different subjects. Related yes, but separate. It's always been that way, just in the past the smaller group was much more diverse. Now it's reached the mob mentality point. Small mobs get really upset about chickens in functional testing or gotos in COBOL and easily sway the entire board because they can hit a new submission with so many votes so quickly.
- danielweber 13y agoIt took me a while to find this but eventually I did: http://www.reddit.com/r/Psychonaut/comments/o1zjo/ban_memes_in_rpsychonaut/c3drsz4 http://www.reddit.com/r/Psychonaut/comments/o1zjo/ban_memes_... It's not the entire problem, but posting about politics is low-effort content. It is easy to produce and easy to consume. It's possible to have a good political discussion, but you need really good and hard-working moderators. If HN wants to have political discussion, it would more moderation than it seems to have right now in total, but devoted entirely to that, not to anything else.
- khitchdee 13y agoGood analysis!
- AsymetricCom 13y agoIt's philosophy, not fact. Take it with a grain of salt.
- fnl 13y agoSeems Paul "rediscovered" what Buddhism teaches us: You need to loose your ego to achieve Nirvana. With the difference that the Buddhists also tell you a method for going about this... :)
- precisioncoder 13y agoHeh, don't you see? By identifying as a Buddhist and classifying a particular bit of wisdom as "belonging" to that religion you are falling into exactly the trap that he described. I grew up in the Buddhist community and ironically the greatest trap that Buddhists fall into is pride. Similar to the technology community ;)
- fnl 13y agoInteresting assumption of yours - where in my post did I identify [myself] as a Buddhist?
- cscurmudgeon 13y agoThanks for telling what PG said in a self-refutingly hilarious way. Also, Buddhism (Buddhists comprising it) has a huge ego itself. It should let go of its own ego soon :)
- arihelgason 13y agoThis also applies to professional growth. People often have a hard time receiving negative feedback because they experience it as an attack on their identity/ego rather than as an opportunity to learn. The ability to take feedback constructively is probably one of the most important traits to hire for.
- lazyjones 13y agoShould this "identity" definition also include possible (conscious) vested interests in the subjects of these discussions? E.g. when people defend various corporations against their better knowledge, simply because they own a few shares or their business depends on them. I suspect this to be the case frequently when, for example, Google's wrongdoings lead to heated discussions here on HN and elsewhere.
- veidr 13y ago> "Politics, like religion, is a topic where there's no threshold of expertise for expressing an opinion." I agree that this is how people tend to see it. But it isn't really true. Like JavaScript or auto mechanics or animal husbandry, there is indeed a threshold of expertise for expressing a meaningful opinion. The value of somebody else's commentary on political issues is pretty much directly proportional to their understanding of the political system and their command of objective facts. This is true even if they subscribe to political ideals diametrically opposed to your own. Personally speaking, this is why I have been so sad about the political discussion on HN since SOPA and Snowden. I thought it might be one of those rare forums where empirical facts and "evidence-based" thinking prevailed -- but it really hasn't. People still seem mostly trapped in their private little jihads, just like they are in the youtube comments section. To me that's disappointing because government is something so fundamentally amenable to hacking, and the stakes are so incredibly high. The state of the art is so so sad and primitive, with so much low-hanging fruit. (The state of the art in governance, that is, at least if you accept at face value the objective of representing the interests of the electorate; the state of the art of getting elected is actually incredibly advanced, but rarely publicly talked about in earnest.)
- chasehood 13y agoDujdjdfjshjx
- ColinWright 13y ago>> "Politics, like religion, is a topic where >> there's no threshold of expertise for expressing >> an opinion." > I agree that this is how people tend to see it. > But it isn't really true. Like JavaScript or auto > mechanics or animal husbandry, there is indeed a > threshold of expertise for expressing a *meaningful* > opinion. But that's the entire point. Lots and lots of people feel that they have something to say, and they say it, whereas very few actually have a meaningful opinion, and they get drowned out. Although you say "it isn't really true" you have, in fact, agreed entirely.
- veidr 13y agoRight, I am not disagreeing with the OP's premise. I'm more just lamenting the truth of it -- and expressing disappointment that we haven't seen better discourse here on HN (where actually I think the signal to noise on stuff like node vs go, should you ever use rails for anything, etc, is actually pretty good, all things considered...). Edit/Addition: What I mean to say is, the article isn't wrong, but the people it describes are wrong. Wrong to think that weighing in on a serious topic with essentially zero knowledge is acceptable, and wrong to conflate their politics with their identity. There is a bedrock of objective truth underlying virtually any political discussion, and it is just as stupid to conflate your own individual identity with a political party or TV station as it is to do the same thing with your smartphone OS or web app framework.
- timinman 13y agoI think his 'theory' that discussions have more potential to be divisive when they involve our identity is dead on. His advice to 'keep your identity small', follows on from that premise well. Many people let their identity get polluted by what they do for a living to such an extent that they find it very difficult to cope when that is taken from them. I have always been opinionated - I'm analytical and I enjoy forming opinions. Since moving to Europe, I have learned not to let political opinions become so ingrained that they become part of my identity. I have seen so many things done differently and still done well. My question is this: Which things are worth being part of my identity? Values I esteem? Relationships I hold dear? Family roles? I think it is fair to say that belief (or disbelief) in God is a foundational human issue. If you are a believer, I think that belief demands something - it necessarily becomes part of your identity. I am a believer, so I don't know if same is true for non-believers.
- icebraining 13y agoI am a believer, so I don't know if same is true for non-believers. Well, everyone is a non-believer in something that others believe. Assuming you don't believe in, say, Isis, do you think that non-belief becomes part of your identity?
- precisioncoder 13y agoThis is an excellent point. I find it interesting that so many things that I use in my own life for orientation are not even noticed by a broad section of humanity. Philosophy, technology, religion, politics, these are often monumental issues to certain people while rarely even noticed by others. It's interesting that the human experience is so diverse especially intellectually. It's hard to escape the belief that what I follow is IMPORTANT though. As well as the follow up thoughts of "If only more people paid more attention to X the world would be a better place...".
- timinman 13y agoNo. I realise that I over-simplified that part by highlighting only two opposites: belief and unbelief. I do realise there are degrees of distinction between belief in a deity and atheism, and there are polytheism and agnosticism as well. I could have asked a question: for those who don't believe in god(s), is your Atheism a significant feature of your identity?
- NanoWar 13y agoI haven't seen any forum topic about politics escalate as quickly as one with religious discussions...
- dasil003 13y agoI like pg's theory here, it's definitely something I try to live by (keeping my identity small), but I think he missed a key observation: Religion (perhaps moreso historically) and especially politics are mine fields because there are so many inputs and so many outputs. That is to say almost any policy decision will affect a lot of people in a lot of different ways. He touches on this by discussing vague and definite questions, but he doesn't really explore that avenue. For instance, consider the evaluation of how much a government program is going to cost. It doesn't matter how precisely you can answer that question because it just leads directly to other questions such as where the money will come from and what the results of the program will be. Even if the follow up questions are precise as well, they bloom out into innumerable consequences far and wide. It's not just that the bar of having an opinion is low, it's because these decisions actually affect all these people, and all in different ways. The fact that they may not have the expertise or knowledge to know the true affects and are easily manipulated by identity-appealing propaganda just exacerbates the problem, but it's not the root cause. The more fundamental problem is that politics is a direct view into the massively interdependent organic ecosystem of large-scale human society. Even if you are the foremost expert on the implications of some political issue and your facts are indisputable, people will still (with good reason) disagree on the merits of those indisputable implications.
- SomeCallMeTim 13y ago>It's not just that the bar of having an opinion is low, it's because these decisions actually affect all these people, and all in different ways. The fact that they may not have the expertise or knowledge to know the true affects and are easily manipulated by identity-appealing propaganda just exacerbates the problem, but it's not the root cause. You make it sound like people end up voting to protect their own interests. A lot of studies show this is frequently not the case: Far more frequently they vote their values, which ends up with a very different result. This is why the Republican "Family Values" theme has been so effective. >Even if you are the foremost expert on the implications of some political issue and your facts are indisputable, people will still (with good reason) disagree on the merits of those indisputable implications. George Lakoff talks about two major philosophies in the US that define the Liberal and Conservative movements, respectively. [1] I think he gets to the heart of the disagreement between these two sides, explaining why large groups of poor people, for instance, vote Republican despite this being against their own self interest (workplace safety, minimum wage, workers' rights, etc.). That said, it seems sometimes that even indisputable facts (dangers of cigarette smoke, seriousness of lead poisoning, and more recently, anthropomorphic climate change and the proven failures of "trickle-down" economics) are frequently politicized such that people end up believing that there's still a debate among experts, and that all politicians are lying to support their own side. Propaganda at its best (or worst, I suppose). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_Politics_%28book%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_Politics_%28book%29 or http://www.chelseagreen.com/bookstore/item/elephant http://www.chelseagreen.com/bookstore/item/elephant
- reedlaw 13y agoThis reminded me of point #2 of a comment I just read [1] on mistakes journalists make: > "Mention every possible debate on the subject, without attempting to either offer a conclusion or a new set of arguments for any of them." Keeping your identity small may prevent you from participating in certain arguments but it doesn't make for a good story. I'd rather hear a spirited debate between proponents of radically different ideas than bland statements that scrupulously avoid engaging anyone's identy. The more I think about it the more ridiculous it sounds to exclude things from one's identity. An exclusive identity is not any smaller than an inclusive one--it's just identified by its exclusions. Identity is who you are and thus can be no larger or smaller than the whole of you. I think the real argument here is one for skepticism as can been seen in the second footnote: > "A scientist isn't committed to believing in natural selection in the same way a bibilical literalist is committed to rejecting it." Really?? First, I don't think biblical literalism requires a rejection of natural selection (unless that's shorthand for a naturalistic origin of life). Secondly, this statement itself seems like a religious argument in the sense that it implies scientists are somehow more detached and objective than biblical literalists. 1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6171593 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6171593
- philwelch 13y agoFrom context it's clear that by "scientist" pg means an idealized scientist, i.e. a disinterested empiricist. Actual scientists are fallible humans who may indeed get caught up by identity.
- iancw 13y ago> A scientist isn't committed to believing in natural selection in the same way a bibilical literalist is committed to rejecting it. All he's committed to is following the evidence wherever it leads. At the risk of responding out of identity, but also with the hope of contributing constructively despite having some identity at stake: A literal interpretation of the bible doesn't preclude accepting natural selection as an ongoing, observable process. It may reject that process as the explanation of our species' origins. Those two are often conflated, contributing to the identity-driven, emotion-filled discussion that PG describes. Regarding the main premise of the article, I think it's possible to have rational, logical discussions about topics in which identity is involved. They are more challenging than, say, discussing Javascript. But I don't think those discussions work well on the internet. They require trust (that both parties will be heard in good faith) careful check of emotions, motivations, and reasoning. Those are even more challenging without high-bandwidth communication aids like facial expressions and tone of voice.
- reedlaw 13y agoIt's quite possible to see flamewars when discussing javascript, e.g. ember vs angular, OO-style or functional, etc. Or the classic emacs vs vim. So I don't think argumentativeness is exclusive to politics and religion by any means.
- hugofirth 13y agoI don't feel the need to add anything to a discussion on an old article, except to say that it was very elegantly and succinctly written.
- nandemo 13y agoA related idea is expressed by philosopher and mystic Paul Brunton's motto: Study everything, join nothing. Discussed here by Bill Vallicella: http://maverickphilosopher.typepad.com/maverick_philosopher/2011/09/study-everything-join-nothing.html http://maverickphilosopher.typepad.com/maverick_philosopher/...
- Ixiaus 13y agoFirst: notice how we are all expressing our opinions :) I think what religion and politics have in common is that they become part of people's identity, and people can never have a fruitful argument about something that's part of their identity. By definition they're partisan. (NOTE: I'm not rigorously defining the word "governance" in this response, I can expand on my meaning further if people are interested) Paul Graham is on to something in this essay. I think, however, that Carl Jung pinpointed the exact mechanism with far more accuracy. Politics and Religion (for many people) in Jung's system of thought are often vehicles of "transferance", or, the transferring of one's spiritual principle or governance principle to a receiver (a priest, or politician, or guru) because people's psyche's are largely unconscious and rarely question or examine their own identity (consciousness, although Jung has a much deeper definition of identity). People "transfer" to the closest external match for that which their unsconscious wishes to have integrated. Paul's statement about it being a part of their identity is inaccurate because it's actually the opposite. If the person in question were not transferring their spiritual principle it would actually be an integrated peice of their identity and consciousness. There would no longer be an imperative to defend the vehicle that carries such an important peice of their "self". As people integrate more of their transfers and projections they have less and less need to justify their existence because that existence is self-contained rather than fragmented. Understanding that the spiritual and governance principles within the psyche are actually subjective and not objective experiences is a sign of someone that has truly identified those components. I say "truly identified" not because truth is defined by an authority or natural principle but because the person has identified the truth of it in relationship to their own non-physical (mental/psychological) experience.
- jdc 13y agoI think pg is using the word identity differently than you (or Jung) here. He doesn't attempt to explain the source of the "strong convictions" that drive political or religious beliefs. He simply observes the connection between the case where people think of themselves as a certain type of person and consequently will defend the associated beliefs regardless of evidence. So there's something about peoples minds that makes it costly for them to accept certain facts. For a long time now, professing a certain belief with conviction has been a way of associating yourself with a certain group has had and continues to have direct implications on a person's physical well-being. Given acting is hard and cognitive-dissonance is nasty, actually adopting the belief makes sense. A more precise way express the essay's thrust might be "don't get attached to your beliefs."
- DalekBaldwin 13y agoWhere politics really differs from JavaScript is that we are taught from a young age that it is important to hold strong opinions about it even if we know nothing about it. Flaunting one's ignorance is celebrated as civic engagement. Hell, when politics comes up at holiday dinners, my family gets more worked up if I recuse myself from discussion than if I say something that violates their most cherished beliefs.
- gbog 13y agoWhen going slightly against common sense, people tend to randomly add Chinese quotes, usually from Lao-tzu, and it is almost always a bad idea. But here this text is vibrating strongly with one of the core idea of daoism, it is impressive. It could be found more closely in Zhuangzi or even Lizi. These guys were living in a time when many have been killed for their ideas, and many had strong beliefs. Their solution for survival was to be an empty vase, a useless tool. A good example is the tree: a straight trunk is the sure path to death for a pine tree, while if you are twisted in a way that makes you useless you survive much longer. There is also this empty boat story. If a big vessel sees a small boat in her way the captain will shout at the small boat, but let the small boat be empty and the captain will just move around. Daoism is all about being this empty boat. And it is it's limits: society also need people with strong belief and ready to die for them. Just take slavery; it is a moral belief and duty to be against slavery. Even if by some rational reasoning slavery was proven a better solution than freedom, we would still have to stand against it, and some have died for this moral belief. So I think I cannot fully agree here. Edit: Or to be more precise, there is a limit to the reduction of one's identity. Maybe this limit is just that common identity we all share: humanity.
- mbrock 13y agoGreat comment. I'm not particularly gung ho about humanity as identity. That concept has very often been used as a carrier of more or less conscious prejudices and ideals. Some philosophers (Agamben among others) make the case that humanity traditionally defines itself as the animal which goes beyond animality. This means that humanity is not a simple essence, but a process of separation and an attempt at transcendence. Which is obviously kind of messy and complex. Plus, what's the reason to identify as human rather than mammal, animal, or simply life?
- gbog 13y agoYes, this differentiation between humans and other animal is kind of axiomatic here, but I fear that if you remove it the consequences are too dangerous. I believe that exploiting crops or cows in a field, and killing them, is morally acceptable, while exploiting fellow humans in a factory is not.
- TausAmmer 13y agoBoth discussions are fine way to learn. You always learn, even from stack full of "meaningless" comments. Either you accept it or nor, makes no difference, you have learned something. Learned to not read comments or proceed reading and absorbing other people expressions that you adopt/use willingly/unknowingly. To decide importance, scale, seriousness or whatnot of discussion, it is up to individual and for his needs. Some are more defensive of set value and want to preserve idea. Some give up ideas to change perspective and understanding regularly. Diversity makes it all interesting.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- sspiff 13y ago> There may be some things it's a net win to include in your identity. For example, being a scientist. I know a lot of people who would consider this wrong, and I've noticed that sometimes, this is correct. I look at things from a scientific point of view, and because of this, I have a hard time understanding and empathizing with people with a religious background in discussion on religion. I think it would be wrong of us to consider science as a concept above the scrutiny we eagerly apply to religion and politics in this article. Who says us scientists can't be wrong on an important level about certain things?
- atondwal 13y agoI think you're missing the point here. pg's saying the scientist identity is useful here, not because of science, but because it reminds you not to take any other identities.
- gbog 13y agoYes. Moreover, relativism has its limits, science and religion cannot be said equal before scepticism: if you have doubts about a theory or some experimental results you can and should investigate their truth. While it is not possible to falsify religious beliefs, or most political views.
- bsbechtel 13y agoSo this raises the question: "How do you coax someone into questioning their own identity, or perhaps questioning whether they should consider themselves an x?"
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- catwork 13y agoGood essay - as all PG's are. One critique - a scientist's identity can be in science itself (or its latest set of widely-held beliefs), which itself can also result in a essentially political/religious response wrapped up in scientific garb. I am thinking of periods of time leading up to a paradigm shift where there can be significant resistance to "where the facts lead" by those invested in defending the status quo (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Structure_of_Scientific_Revolutions http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Structure_of_Scientific_Rev...). Certainly, this not the same situation as a purely political or religious issue. It is worth noting though, since everyone works off of a basic set of assumptions that are not provable. Each person has a philosophy - a practical "religion" or "political party" regardless of whether they are officially associated with any public entity or institution.
- tsax 13y agoEvolutionary history probably plays a role here. Science has given evidence that our faculties of reason are probably meant to persuade and not to reason about the world in an abstract manner. We probably evolved in hunter-gatherer tribes of 150-200 people where voice counted for a lot. You can influence by arguing within a group that small. And losing an argument could mean expulsion from the group leading to a low-chance of survival. The problem is that this simply doesn't scale. Arguing political questions feels as real to us as it did to our hunter-gatherer ancestors whose lives literally depended on it. But this is just not the case in polities of a few hundred million. Hence it's likely beneficial to reduce political bickering for those not involved with politics.
- rokhayakebe 13y agoMatters of Fact, vs. Matters of Opinions. I cannot recall which of Socrates' discourses goes into this in detail (I think Symposium), but it was a nice read. It makes you really stop and evaluate whether there is a point in having an argument or not, because when things are matter of opinions you may as well just accept and respect what the other party says.
- alexvr 13y agoYour opinion on politics reveals how you think, which is why people tend to be defensive of their opinions: They don't know any better -- anything that directly challenges how they perceive the world is too threatening to be the subject of a rational conversation. If you talk to someone on a similar wavelength who has similar experiences, you can probably have a meaningful conversation. In this case, politics is like music: Not everyone has the same taste or understands/appreciates the same things, so it's hard to explain the virtues of Radiohead to someone who only gets a buzz from the best classical or, forgive my elitism, someone who can't see past Lil Wayne. It's hard for polar opposites to hold meaningful conversations for the same reason it's hard for a super smart person to hold a stimulating conversation with an idiot, or for an old person to do the same with a young person (they're effectively from different worlds). People on significantly different areas of the spectrum perceive the world very differently and have dramatically different experiences to draw on.
- grandalf 13y agoIn terms of being rational, identity is just a kind of bias (among many) that needs to be removed. I think a slightly more accurate generalization of PG's point is that many beliefs and belief systems permit learning (changing the belief) in the face of new evidence or perspective. The things we most often consider "identity" oriented beliefs are the things that people are unable or unwilling to question (or to consider that they might be wrong about). So a good way to find you own rationality limiting beliefs is to ask "What am I certain about?". Politics attempts to solve the coordination problems around use of force, coercion, bribery, money, and infrastructure. Identity is simply a useful way to rally voters for a political cause, which is why it's used by political and religious charlatans alike.
- undoware 13y agoKeeping your identity 'small' is really easy when you're rich and don't need to team up to effect change. Identities are what form motivated groups, and groups -- or parties -- are, for better or for worse, what our form of democracy runs on. Rich dudes can keep small identities and still make shit happen; poor everyone-else has to form teams, and with a diversity of levels of education, talent, intelligence and common sense, that will invariably mean pandering and WOOOOing a bit. Why? Because not everyone is smart enough to be affected by rhetoric. Ex hypothesis everyone else has already been 'taken', i.e. has considered opinions, so by elimination it's the aggressive, passionate idiots who play kingmaker. Thus explaining US politics. So, Paul Graham, keep your identity small, but please enlarge your perspective. People are getting irrational because they're getting riled up, and they're getting riled up because riling-up is what gets the Irrational Vote, and that's the only one that's not already either bought or reasoned into passivity. It's game theory, in other words. Like most human suffering.
- andyl 13y agoForget about politics. Forget about rich people. Most change comes from artists and science/technology folk. You may say I'm a dreamer, but I'm not the only one.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- PavlovsCat 13y agoHmmmm. I agree that you shouldn't identify with notions and ideas and labels, because that's just dumb and putting the cart before the horse. But generally, and ignoring the sensibilities of HN? No to most of that. I started to care about politics since I saw corpses being shoved into a mass grave with a caterpillar while switching TV channels when I was a kid, and it hasn't let up since. Why should it? Politics by definition affects everyone, in ways that actually matter. Just take the web; it matters because it allows people to communicate, the people make it matter. Even more so with politics, which doesn't just affect everybody, everybody owns an equal share of it. Most people let theirs rot, but they still own it, and if the circus around it has been made that complex and hidden among many bloated layers of euphemisms and misdirection, to encourage apathy and and facilitate deception, then those layers need to be removed, instead of removing the "uneducated" from the debate. If a simple but adult mind can't understand it, something is fishy. Politics really isn't that complex as some people would love to make it out to be, or at the very least, sophistry is not complexity, and this makes for a huge chunk of political debate and opinions. As Chomsky said in some talk or other.. when he talks with intellectuals they have a hard time understanding even the most basic stuff, while some peasants in South America for example get it right away. I guess their being on the receiving end of it, instead of trying to rationalize the bloodshed their own gloved hand is doling out (or the hand of the uncle in whose lap they're sitting), helps. Also, it reminds me of this quote: The real damage is done by those millions who want to 'survive.' The honest men who just want to be left in peace. Those who don’t want their little lives disturbed by anything bigger than themselves. Those with no sides and no causes. Those who won’t take measure of their own strength, for fear of antagonizing their own weakness. Those who don’t like to make waves—or enemies. Those for whom freedom, honour, truth, and principles are only literature. Those who live small, mate small, die small. It’s the reductionist approach to life: if you keep it small, you’ll keep it under control. If you don’t make any noise, the bogeyman won’t find you. But it’s all an illusion, because they die too, those people who roll up their spirits into tiny little balls so as to be safe. Safe?! From what? Life is always on the edge of death; narrow streets lead to the same place as wide avenues, and a little candle burns itself out just like a flaming torch does. I choose my own way to burn. -- Sophie Scholl Safe from what, indeed? From being incorrect? From being inefficient? From raised blood pressure? Why not try to be safe from standing for nothing? I don't mean to be polemic but I truly don't get it. What is a "useful conversation"? Useful for what, exactly? Talking about Javascript is terribly useless when it comes to being a decent person. Talking about being a decent person is terribly useless for debugging Javascript. If it has no potential to make anyone sad, angry or happy, it's likely a gimmick in the bigger scheme of things. Which is fine for HN I guess, but not for general advice on what kind of person one should be. Thanks, but no thanks.
- jerryhuang100 13y agoSome observation on HN these days: Many threads about PERL vs Python ... etc, .Net, Java, or whatever programming languages some people really hates are just moving towards polarizations as religion/politics discussions.
- virtu 13y agoI really loved the article, but would go furthermore and say like Mooji find out what you really are, ask the question who is I behind a thought based identity. More on yt: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8_q6gZkoceg http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8_q6gZkoceg
- mcgwiz 13y agoIn my opinion, he describes a basic mechanism of survival for cultures. Cultures that inspire such defensive "inability to think clearly" about the subject have increased survivability (social propagability). But in order to survive, cultures must also change over time. I see the mechanism for this change as the individual's improvement of the culture for oneself, and then attempting to propagate it to insiders and outsiders. Triggers of this modification include conflicting experience, either direct or indirect via dialogue/argumentation with others.
- stasmo 13y agoCan you achieve greatness without passion? Can you feel passionate about a topic without it creeping into your identity? I don't claim to know the answers.
- wittysense 13y agoPlease read Wittgenstein. Or Richard M. Hare. Or Gilbert Ryle. Not all language is truth-functional, and religious language is a language game which consists of no conditions for Assertibility. Mathematics is a language game in which every "argument" must bear Assertibility conditions, before Truth conditions are discussed. Please, stop spinning on this topic, thinkers. This has gone on long enough.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- wissler 13y agoHe's right that people think they can have an opinion on politics or religion without actually knowing anything, but this is something they are taught to believe in school and church. It's a result of widespread poor upbringing and education, it's not an issue of "keeping your identity small".