9 ms·
Just as Soylent is disrupting the traditional food industry Huh? I've asked this before and never got an answer. How is Soylent different from Ensure Complete
by jgrahamc 13y ago
Just as Soylent is disrupting the traditional food industry
Huh?
I've asked this before and never got an answer. How is Soylent different from Ensure Complete? Is it cheaper? Better made? Easier to order? Tastes better? Better for me? Higher quality?
Because if it isn't really any different then what Soylent will need to do is market better than those other companies. Because I'd definitely trust Abbott with my health over random start up with indistinguishable product.
You see I'm actually interested in things like this as a 'meal replacement'. I quite often drink chocolate milk instead of eating lunch and I can buy nutritionally complete things like Ensure Complete. So, what makes Soylent special?
- billybob255 13y agoIt seems like it's purely marketing to the Silicon Valley/quantified self crowd.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoIt has an outstandingly good name and some quirky, viral Steve Pavlina-like self-experiments by the founder.
- alainmeier 13y agoHere's a very thoughtful response from Rob, the creator of Soylent answering your very question: http://discourse.soylent.me/t/comparing-soylent-to-existing-nutritional-products/431/7 http://discourse.soylent.me/t/comparing-soylent-to-existing-... tldr; There's room in the market for more than one non-solid dietary product, the goal of Soylent is to be a complete alternative that supports an active life rather than something that just lets you survive, ensure is expensive and low calorie.
- jgrahamc 13y agoYes, I've read that in the past and without being rude I do not consider that to be 'thoughtful'. It's a repetition of what he's said a number of times about his goals for Soylent, but it does not answer my question. He mentions Ensure as follows: "I considered Ensure but found it much too expensive, low calorie, unpalatable, and an ingredient make up that was far from complete or optimal." That does not tell me anything about Soylent. Sure, he wants to make it cheaper. Can he? About a month ago I posted this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5875246 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5875246 The pricing is very close between Soylent and Ensure Complete. Abbott claims you can live long term on it etc. My suspicion is that he's comparing Soylent with the common consumer "Ensure" product which is relatively low-calorie etc.
- schiffern 13y ago4 bottles of Ensure Complete would only be 1400 Calories/day, vs. 2200 Calories for Soylent. You'd have to drink 6/day, making it $66.43/wk for Ensure Complete (cheapest Amazon price) vs. $52.88/wk for Soylent. Of course, you said that you considered $73.48/wk to be "very close to Soylent pricing". Sure it's in the same order of magnitude, but a 40% increase is nothing to sneeze at.
- anonymoushn 13y agoThe response is definitely worthwhile, and a bit of it seems to be that the use case is different. It would be a bit expensive to replace a majority of one's diet with Ensure Complete. A 16-pack of 8oz Ensure Complete is 5600 Calories for $42, so eating for a day costs $15. The preorder price of 1 week of soylent is $9.29/day, but worryingly we don't know how many Calories that is... A quote from Vice on the crowdfunding page indicates that it should be about 700 Calories/day[1] (making it several times as expensive as Ensure), while Rob Rhinehart's blog indicated that he was consuming a reasonable number of calories earlier this year (2629 C/day)[2]. [1] https://campaign.soylent.me/soylent-free-your-body https://campaign.soylent.me/soylent-free-your-body [2] http://robrhinehart.com/?p=474 http://robrhinehart.com/?p=474
- JoshTriplett 13y ago"More expensive per Calorie" is not necessarily "more expensive" for the target audience. The classic "2000 Calories per day" assumes some level of physical activity. If you don't have any physical activity, you're better off consuming fewer Calories per day, as long as you get all the other nutrients you need.
- anonymoushn 13y agoThis is an important consideration. The target audience of Soylent likely has some wild variation in desired caloric intake, perhaps 4-6x between people who want to drop some pounds and people who lift as a hobby.
- JoshTriplett 13y agoYeah. The creator of Soylent makes a point of saying that it should be tuned for the person using it. Hopefully in the long-term they'll offer versions with varying calorie content. Alternatively, they could offer a two-component system with nutrients and minimal calories in one and pure calories in the other, to make it easy to tune that one variable for your target calorie consumption.
- baddox 13y ago> How is Soylent different from Ensure Complete? Is it cheaper? Better made? Easier to order? Tastes better? Better for me? Higher quality? More popular and prominent in certain demographics. Which is what "disrupt" implies, versus "improves upon."
- princess3000 13y agoSo, marketing?
- baddox 13y agoWell, sure, everything can be thrown under "marketing," because obviously if no one knew about it no one would be talking about it.
- corin_ 13y agoNot everything can be thrown under it, only.. marketing can. Sure, marketing may be why Ferrari sell cars, but that doesn't mean that marketing is the only difference between a Ferrari and a Ford.
- mehwoot 13y agoJust because marketing lets people know about a product's advantages doesn't mean every improvement can be labelled as marketing. And it certainly doesn't make a product whose only improvement is marketing something worthy of equal attention to a product that actually improves some other aspect.
- Lemmih 13y agoI wanted to compare the ingredients and their amounts but I can't seem to find the formula for Ensure Complete. If you know where to find it, please post a link. If not, I guess that would be one reason why Soylent is preferable to Ensure Complete.
- jgrahamc 13y agohttp://ensure.com/products/ensure-complete-shakes http://ensure.com/products/ensure-complete-shakes Click the [+] to expand ingredients etc.
- kazagistar 13y agoHmm, this does not have the exact volumes, which is unfortunate...
- Lemmih 13y agoThose are the ingredients, not the formula. Without the formula, there's no way of knowing whether the amounts of vitamins and minerals actually make sense.
- anonymoushn 13y agoWhere can one find a list of ingredients in Soylent?
- Lemmih 13y agoPrototype formula: http://robrhinehart.com/?p=424 http://robrhinehart.com/?p=424
- falk 13y agoIt seems like marketing mostly. Maybe I'm just too old to understand all these crazy kids these days, but I don't see the appeal in drinking my meals. I really don't think this is going to work out.
- loceng 13y agoI agree with it mostly being marketing, though this could gain a regular group of consumers, assuming the product ends up being good enough.
- tlb 13y agoDo you believe generally that Big Food makes healthier products than independents? I believe the reverse is usually true in the US. You can trust Big Food to pump their products full of sugar because testing shows it makes consumers buy more. Sugar is second on Ensure's ingredient list (http://ensure.com/products/ensure-complete-shakes http://ensure.com/products/ensure-complete-shakes) while Soylent is not sweet.
- mbreese 13y agoI trust Abbott far more than some random startup with zero experience in long-term production of food supplements and replacements. I'm sorry, but living off of a concoction for a few months and then claiming that it is better for you than X is crazy. Look, Soylent may not kill you. It might actually be good for you. But until there have been multiple, years-long studies, this just isn't going to fly. Hell, get some actual nutritionists (PhDs) and doctors (MDs) on board and maybe you have a shot at convincing people. Say what you want about Abbott, but they produce baby-formula. Baby-formula that has been around for decades, so they have a pretty good idea of what works and what doesn't.
- sard420 13y agoAbbott would be the first to tell you not to try and use Ensure as a substitute for food. Some YC kid thinks you can live off his stuff, hope he doesn't kill too many people.
- cLeEOGPw 13y agoI'm willing to take the risk and test it for a conservatives like you.
- DanBC 13y agoBut that's useless unless it's a large, controlled, randomised, double blind, trial. So far we have people selling stuff telling us "it's okay". I'd be really interested to see what the FDA has to say about Soylent. Have any of the Soylent team got legal advice?
- ynniv 13y agoI suspect that the interest comes from the radical branding. "Ensure" is associated with hospitals and the aging population, whereas "Soylent" is historically associated with dystopia and recently with some ambitious kids. One exit would be to create an energy drink-like (young target market) product that's just a re-branded Ensure. But if you're currently using Ensure, perhaps you know of other ways to improve on it? They're both basically ramen for the well-off. (And +1 to tlb: simply removing sugar is an improvement in my eyes.)
- cube13 13y ago> I suspect that the interest comes from the radical branding. "Ensure" is associated with hospitals and the aging population, whereas "Soylent" is historically associated with dystopia and recently with some ambitious kids. And people. It's associated with people.
- ynniv 13y agoNice. It is an extremely good name for what it is, and it might (sadly?) succeed based on that alone. Countless energy drinks have paved the way.
- pydave 13y agoReally? Soylent sounds like it's made of soy, but the name essentially means cannibalism. I'd expect the former to kill enthusiasm from the energy drink market (where the cannibalism angle makes it sound more extreme) and the latter to put off everyone else.
- ynniv 13y agoThe literary evocation is far more powerful than the word-part "soy". Even so, given soy's ubiquity I suspect that no one would seriously be turned off by it at this point. The name doesn't "essentially mean cannibalism", it refers to a fictional future company that makes the bulk of the worlds' food in the form of Soylent Red and Soylent Yellow. In the movie Soylent introduced a new product Green that you refer to, which means that the only people who are disturbed by the name are those who take things too seriously and also didn't actually watch the movie.
- kazagistar 13y agoA promise to open source their ingredients list, and if I remember correctly, their sourcing and supply chain, is tremendous. Not to mention the last I heard they were going full vegan.
- ballard 13y agoA friend evaluated these folks about 4 months ago and concluded there was too much hype. Since none of this has happened, this is a pattern of not following through. You be the judge.
- tocomment 13y agoThe last time I had an ensure I noticed it had 200 calories. Yes you read that right. Id have to drink ten of them to replace a days meals at $3 each that would be $30 a day or $900 a month to feed just one person.
- ynniv 13y agoThey also sell it as a powder that's $10.25 per 2,000 calories. Soylent is currently pre-selling for $9.29 per "day". http://www.amazon.com/Ensure-Nutrition-Powder-Vanilla-Flavor/dp/B0007XXPLQ http://www.amazon.com/Ensure-Nutrition-Powder-Vanilla-Flavor...
- jgrahamc 13y agoI am talking about Ensure Complete not regular Ensure.
- joering2 13y ago> How is Soylent different from Ensure Complete? One way its different is that it was on Fox News yesterday and millions of people had a chance to hear about it. Versus, until you told me, I never heard of Ensure before.
- JohnHaugeland 13y agoIf I understand correctly, Ensure is not meant to be a whole-diet replacement, and Soylent is. However, I have not studied this, and I caution you to not take me too seriously here.
- northwest 13y agoThe 1st question for me is still this one: Why on earth should I not eat natural and unprocessed foods? It seems to me that this is what our bodies are trained to process. Why change that?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- MDS100 13y agohttp://examine.com/blog/soylent-is-made-from-hype/ http://examine.com/blog/soylent-is-made-from-hype/