4 ms·
"Pennsylvania is one of just a handful of states that do not provide any money to counties to defend those who can't afford a lawyer."[1] Perhaps the DA and Pu
by protomyth 13y ago
"Pennsylvania is one of just a handful of states that do not provide any money to counties to defend those who can't afford a lawyer."[1]
Perhaps the DA and Public Defenders office should have equal budgets.
I am hoping some very smart lawyer figures out how to sue the prison company for these children. I am sure their is a corporate veil, but it can be pierced in the cases of criminal activity. Public-private partnerships work in a lot of cases, but this one needs a serious hammer to show that pulling this crap is bad and will put some scheming folks in jail.
1) http://www.npr.org/2012/03/03/147876810/after-scandal-new-rules-for-juveniles-in-pa-courts http://www.npr.org/2012/03/03/147876810/after-scandal-new-ru...
- tracker1 13y agoI would prefer that the public defenders office and the DA office have to rotate their staff out to eachother... so you cannot just serve as a DA.
- aswanson 13y agoBrilliant. That would align incentives more along the lines of serving justice rather than sensationalism/careerism.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- protomyth 13y agoThat would be very interesting. Does any country do that? A pool of lawyers randomly chosen might be an interesting variant. I do wish the $ were closer, but your idea would basically fix that.
- rbehrends 13y agoEngland and Wales. While the CPS has moved towards having more permanently employed barristers, it still regularly hires barristers in private practice to represent the Crown in the lower courts as so-called "agents" that are "instructed" by the CPS [1]. This has largely historical reasons; until not so long ago, England did not have designated prosecutors (in fact, well into the 19th century it often fell to private citizens to initiate prosecution, until the police started to take over that role). That said, the CPS will likely still have more resources at its disposal than public defenders. [1] http://www.euro-justice.com/member_states/england_wales/country_report/451/ http://www.euro-justice.com/member_states/england_wales/coun...
- agwa 13y agoThat's how it works in the military. There was recently some interesting discussion about the merits of this idea amongst some defense attorneys (including some PDs and a lawyer with military justice experience) in the comments section here: http://web.archive.org/web/20130523171557/http://blog.simplejustice.us/2013/01/23/response-to-radleybalko-why-loser-pays-in-criminal-law-is-a-loser.aspx#comment-18872691 http://web.archive.org/web/20130523171557/http://blog.simple... Bottom line, there are advantages but also downsides to this approach. (non-Wayback Machine link, where unfortunately the comments are no longer threaded: http://blog.simplejustice.us/2013/01/23/response-to-radleybalko-why-loser-pays-in-criminal-law-is-a-loser/ http://blog.simplejustice.us/2013/01/23/response-to-radleyba...)
- gohrt 13y agoI worry that the corrupt DAs would just be more corrupt PDs.
- norswap 13y agoNice idea, but wouldn't it lead to "win trading" (I let you win this case, then you let me win next)?
- sixothree 13y agoI was a juror on a murder trial and the number one reason for me voting not guilty was the absolute glaring disparity between the budget of the defense and the budget of the prosecution. The defendant essentially had no representation. I would do it again without reservation.
- nfriedly 13y agoGood move. Another thing along these lines that's worth mentioning is jury nullification. You can believe that the person is 100% guilty as charged and still vote "not guilty" if you believe that the situation merited the actions or even if you believe that the action was wrong but the punishment will be too harsh. It's one of the checks and balances we (citizens) have over our government. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_nullification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_nullification