4 ms·
Why report it at all? Seriously. If I'm affected, I'll find out. If I'm not affected, why should you tell me? It seems that every time a well-known service
by ColinWright 13y ago
Why report it at all? Seriously. If I'm affected, I'll find out. If I'm not affected, why should you tell me?
It seems that every time a well-known service goes down, for however long, for whatever reason, instantly there's a flurry of posts here making sure everyone knows something that they either already know, or won't care about.
I'd really like that to stop, although perhaps I'm just a curmudgeonly old grey-beard.
- ignostic 13y ago-People notice that downtime posts end up on the front page. -Those who care about fake internet points see downtime messages as "easy karma." No thought required. -The mad rush to submit the "news" for easy karma results in votes for the first submission. -The cycle repeats. Downtime messages aren't the only thing. Sometimes things make it to the front page based on their perceived likelihood to make it to the front page.
- locofacetwice 13y agoThan why don't you just start downvoting those threads?
- presty 13y agoaka karma whoring. It has become quite (unsuprisingly) prevalent on HN. Wonder if pg has any plans on fighting this and if the high-karma enabled functionalities take into account karma whoring in their formula. You can easily spot the trend if you read HN through RSS. And it sucks :\
- olalonde 13y ago> You can easily spot the trend if you read HN through RSS. Why is it more easy to spot through RSS? (genuine question)
- ville 13y agoI would guess it's easier to spot the amount of noise when you skim through all the submissions as opposed to peeking at the highest voted stories on the front page every once in a while. The the posts that end up in the front page have been filtered, an unfiltered RSS feed has even the failed attempts to get easy points.
- rhizome 13y agoIt appears to be easier to get into the RSS feed than the front page, so if you follow RSS you see many truly terrible submissions.
- steveklabnik 13y agoYes, I too hope pg decides to fight the good fight against others gaining precious Internet Points via methods I find unsavory, even if their accumulation doesn't affect me in the least.
- eksith 13y agoSock puppets = Proliferation of guns. With karma = Availability of bullets. What doesn't affect you individually, affects all of us collectively. I.E. It diminishes the legitimacy of this forum as a whole when those very same mechanisms that are meant to cultivate genuine discussion are abused for petty reasons easily.
- dreen 13y agoHeres an idea: remove karma total - its just an epenis and nothing else. Keep points for posts so you can see if your post was good and for burying trolls but dont show the total in profile or news page. Done.
- derefr 13y agoI would guess that it's just the digital version of the internet going down at work, and everyone hanging out in the office kitchen talking about how the internet is down, until it goes back up. In other words, if you're waiting for [service] to come up in order to get something done, there's not much better to do.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ColinWright 13y ago> if you're waiting for [service] to come up in order > to get something done, there's not much better to do. I don't understand this - it's a distributed document control system. You can continue to work on your local repo - why is it that you can get nothing done? Perhaps I just don't understand your workflow, but why is github the site essential to your progress? It would be useful to me if someone could explain how their workflow requires github to be available, because it would seem that they are using facilities or features of which I am unaware.
- wakeless 13y agoToday it went down, just as I needed our CI server to do a pass. Which is fine, grab a coffee, then I sat down and thought, I'll catch up on some code reviews. Thankfully, it wasn't long till it came back up.
- ColinWright 13y agoThanks for the reply, but if your CI[0] server does passes reasonably often, why would one of them not happening then prevent you from continuing to work? It runs in passes, so it's not really continuous, and I'd expect it to survive running slightly less often, or slightly more irregularly. Do you stop work when it runs? I don't understand your workflow that implies you have to stop while a process that runs often fails to run on one occasion. I remain confused. [0] I assume this is "Continuous Integration"
- edanm 13y agoI disagree. When Twilio went down a few weeks ago, the second place I headed to was HN, and found that it wasn't just for me. And since this is a meeting place for the kind of people I want to hear from (like Twilio's developers), reading the thread helped me a lot. So I agree with the "if it's less than 5 minutes, don't report it" sentiment, but I do like it when larger outages are reported.
- rpgmaker 13y agoAlso, when the down time starts you don't know how much time it will last. Having the problem reported is helpful.
- level09 13y agoUsually there is a technical discussion on why this service went down, on the other hand sometimes someone comes back with an explanation of what happened and how to deal/prevent it, which is kind of helpful.
- themstheones 13y agoI don't think age or beard colour affect curmudgeonness. The grumpiest guy at my office has a beige beard and he's not old.