3 ms·
Yeah I thought it was balanced. I expect insiders will consider the study incomplete, because he's just looking at indictments, and those aren't among the objec
by jessaustin 13y ago
Yeah I thought it was balanced. I expect insiders will consider the study incomplete, because he's just looking at indictments, and those aren't among the objectives for the black-bag squad. (Although frankly I don't know what the relative percentages are, it's not as though Anwar al-Awlaki was a one-off.) Still, when we have a public discussion, only public information is relevant. You can't base an academic work on "secret" information. Within the NSA, this analysis is probably old hat. I'm pretty sure some of the geniuses know queuing theory.
The comparison between lightning and "terror" emphasizes that security is a game of trade-offs. Although this is one of the basic mantras of computer security, we rarely hear it from those employed at public expense. Why do they have a different emphasis? We do spend some money on lightning protection, and most of us do use caution to avoid lightning-prone situations. Each of those costs is a pittance compared to those of the War On Terror.
Really though, since lightning is not a sentient opponent who changes his tactics in response to human action, the more fair comparison in TFA is to violence in general. While that has dropped precipitously for decades, credit is given by many to the tyrannical police state we've built to match our tyrannical security state, so the proper amount to spend is still "more". LEOs are just as unlikely as NSA people to raise questions of priorities and trade-offs.
If this were a dilemma the USA political system could solve, it probably would have been solved already for both of these cases. In my more pessimistic moments, I consider the widespread public apathy in the face of common knowledge about The War on Drugs to presage similar apathy to revelations of The War on Terror.