3 ms·
I've now started flagging these kinds of submissions on HN, for the simple reason that they are little more than ads for something vaguely specified that may or
by Silhouette 13y ago
I've now started flagging these kinds of submissions on HN, for the simple reason that they are little more than ads for something vaguely specified that may or may not even exist yet. There is absolutely no directly actionable content in this article that I can see, nor any other original ideas that anyone following HN doesn't see several times a week on the front page alone.
I post this only so I can note that this is not intended as a criticism of Patrick, just a view that the hero worship and endless reposting of A/B evangelism has far overstayed its welcome IMHO. If people want to read the fluff as well, then as we get told every five minutes they can sign up for Patrick's newsletter. Please, for the love of all that is holy, spare those of us who have chosen not to do so the endless join-my-mailing-list spam that is starting to dominate HN, and save the HN submissions for substantial content.
- gus_massa 13y agoThis email is more infomercial than the emails from the past weeks. I reread the last two emails and I think they are more interesting, but this got much more upvotes here. Anyway, this email convinced me to try to run an A/B test. I have a button that I don't like and I got negative feedback about that button in the past. So I will (probably) try to optimize the microcopy, but I must understand and change the php code that renders that button. I'll report the result when the experiment finish. Wish me good luck!
- wakeless 13y agoIt's worth mentioning that that's exactly why Patrick doesn't normally submit this stuff himself. Infact, I've seen him apologies/ask people not to just re-post stuff here and just subscribe to his newsletter/blog/etc. It's also worth noting that you don't HAVE to click through to something that's on the kalzumeus domain, if you subscribe to the newsletter or don't want to. Personally, I think anything that generates a reasonable number of good comments is great (not necessarily this.) That's why HN is great.
- davidw 13y agoFlagging is for stuff that's inappropriate for this site, like political articles, the latest injustice, politics, news stories, conspiracy theories and so on. For stuff like this that you may not happen to like, just don't vote for it, and ignore it. I tend not to vote up patio11's stuff these days even though it's good, just because it gets so much attention. But it is 100% on topic for this site and does not deserve to be flagged. How much time has patio11 spent giving free advice and information here? So what if he also sells some stuff? That's what businesses do, sheez!
- Silhouette 13y agoFlagging is for stuff that's inappropriate for this site I don't think almost completely content-free promotional material is appropriate for this site, whoever writes it and whatever it is advertising. I don't flag many submissions, and following the FAQ, I don't normally comment at all when I do. However, I don't know what actually happens when something gets flagged, so in this case I made an exception because I'm aware that Patrick himself is wary of submitting pieces like this. I didn't want anything to imply a personal attack, nor general criticism of links about A/B testing if they do offer new/interesting material.