3 ms·
This is really a tough sell as a policy issue. I'm supposed to be all upset that wages are being depressed from $200,000 to $100,000 for people who happened to
by bradleyjg 13y ago
This is really a tough sell as a policy issue. I'm supposed to be all upset that wages are being depressed from $200,000 to $100,000 for people who happened to have fallen out of their mothers on one side of an invisible line even though it means opportunities for people to make $100,000 who would otherwise be making $25,000 but happened to be born on the other side of the world?
Sorry, far from being upset, that sounds to me like a great trade-off. Sure the companies aren't doing it out of altruism, but the net result is quite positive. All those 'underpaid' American born engineers working in silicon valley can comfort themselves knowing that they will still be among the 1% richest people in the entire world.
N.B. Look up PPP before objecting based on how much an apartment in SF costs.
- rayiner 13y ago> to have fallen out of their mothers on one side of an invisible line It's not an invisible line. It's a line that was defended and delineated by the blood of people who wanted to establish and preserve a nation.
- bradleyjg 13y agoI think you mean the blood of the people who were already living here. Isn't it enough that nationalism killed 100+m people in the 20th century, do we really need to have it hanging around our neck in the 21st?
- rayiner 13y agoWhat you derisively call "people who were already living here" other people might call a "community."
- bradleyjg 13y agoThey might well have been a community before your glorious war dead who "established and preserved a nation" slaughtered them. How exactly is that justification for continuing to treat people born on one side of a line as valuable human beings and those on the other worthless? Is it a moral sunk cost theory -- as long as we've committed all these atrocities in the name of nationalism might as well keep going?
- rayiner 13y agoThey are certainly communities, and it is the obligation of the governing bodies of their communities to maximize the prosperity of the people in those communities just as it is the obligation of the governing bodies of our community to maximize the prosperity of the people in our community. Inside versus outside isn't theoretical. People in other communities will not come to your defense when you need help, they will not perpetuate your culture and values, and they are not part of the body politic that animates your democracy.
- bradleyjg 13y agoAre you really trying to justify genocide on the basis that people who live in a community have no moral obligations to anyone outside their community? I would have thought that reasoning went out of fashion circa September 30, 1946.
- rayiner 13y agoThere is an intermediate point between supporting nationalism to the point of genocide and asserting that nationality means absolutely nothing.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 13y agoSo how much of your income would you like to part with in order to give the children of rural Indian farmers access to the same education as European children get?
- bradleyjg 13y agoWell I'm not European, but I'd be willing to pay the same amount as I'm willing to pay for the children of rural Arkansas farmers. Which is to say nothing at all. But I'd gladly hire either one if they could do the job.
- geebee 13y agoI don't think you're required to be upset about it. In fact, your honesty is very refreshing. No CEO lobbying for this bill would ever openly state that this program dramatically reduces wages for US citizens, but that they don't care because they view US citizenship as a meaningless invisible line.
- bradleyjg 13y agoSo the plan is to appeal to rank nationalism? I suggest any lobbying group that's formed concentrate its ad dollars on Fox News.
- rayiner 13y agoThe idea that representatives should care about the prosperity of people who aren't their constituents strikes at the very heart of republican democracy.