4 ms·
US embassy closures used to bolster case for NSA surveillance programs
- uptown 13y agoIt's the modern-day version of raising the terror threat-alert level to RED.
- briandear 13y agoThe hilarity is that if the surveillance is so good, then why do they need to close 21 embassies? They apparently received a "specific threat" specifically involving over 20 embassies? Doesn't sound too specific to me. This entire situation is politics. I don't doubt they've received threats and possibly even credible information, but this public show of duck and cover is a farce. The US needs a really loud scare tactic right about now and this seems to fit the bill (regardless of the validity of the threat.) The funny thing is that I historically have been a flag-waver, although the last few years have put a major dent in my perspective.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> The hilarity is that if the surveillance is so good, then why do they need to close 21 embassies? They apparently received a "specific threat" specifically involving over 20 embassies? Doesn't sound too specific to me. It could be a specific threat regarding a plan of coordinated attacks on all of those targets. Not that I think that it is, however.
- briandear 13y agoVery true, it could be, but you're right, it's unlikely. The amount of coordination required for an embassy attack is fairly significant because most embassies in those countries are fortresses, especially in Kabul. In this case, we're talking about over 20 embassies! The man power and communications requirements for such a coordinated attack makes that a threat of almost insane proportions. The likely actual threats (assuming there are any, which is still up for debate) are likely against soft targets. Let's not forget there's a worldwide travel alert as well; threats against specific embassies rarely prompt blanket travel warnings or alerts. I even received a warden message from the Seoul embassy warning potential "danger." Most travelers don't hang out at the embassies, but closing the embassies is a highly public action that gets more headlines than a non-specific worldwide travel alert. It's likely this is a public relations/propaganda move, however if there's a real threat this was exactly the wrong way to handle it. A terrorist doesn't even have to do anything to force the United States government to close over 20 embassies. It's embarrassing. It would be like closing down New York city because of a threat. Interestingly, given such a "serious" threat, no messages have been sent suggesting non-essential personal and family evacuations, which would be one of the first things they would set in motion if the threat were so serious. However, that being said, I hope I'm wrong.
- m8urn 13y agoPlus, addressing this threat likely reveals surveillance methods to terrorists. Why would they blow this for such a vague threat and then publicize it? But hey, nothing will happen and they can say they stopped a terrorist attack!
- mpyne 13y agoThe news stories have said that nothing more specific than 'chatter' has been picked up. It could certainly be a government over-reaction, but it could also be AQ deliberately 'chattering' to induce that over-reaction. After all, what will you say if the next 2 months go by and not a single Western outpost is attacked by AQ anywhere? We'll say the government is making political hay out of all this as that is exactly what it will look like, whether that 'chatter' was actually detected or not. In fact that was the most striking aspect I noted: some of the politician and intelligence agency types expressed surprise that AQ would "deliberately break OPSEC" by discussing their big plans in this manner. But what if we're not understanding the reason they broke OPSEC? It could be a feint to draw this response, or it could be because they are now completely confident in the success of their plan no matter what action the government takes to prepare.
- mtgx 13y agoThis is exactly what I thought when I heard about it. I would also expect a lot worse (real CIA terror plots in some countries?), if they feel the anti-surveillance movement grows to the point where it might actually end everything.
- aaronbrethorst 13y agoDo you actually think the US government would engage in false flag attacks against its embassies in the Middle East because they're concerned about a nascent anti-surveillance movement, or are you just saying that for effect? I cannot even begin to describe how ridiculous I think this is. Alex Jones-esque tinfoil hat fear-mongering should have no place on HN.
- briandear 13y agoThey don't need a false flag attack. Just the threat of an attack. "We are at war with Eastasia. We've always been at war with Eastasia."
- ck2 13y agoIt's an extreme political over-reaction to the massive political attacks over benghazi. BTW Benghazi turns out to be just a CIA front and not an embassy at all. If the terrorists haven't figured it out already, they now know they can cause mass panic and hysteria by just talking about terrorism without lifting a finger.
- viraptor 13y agoSo basically admitting that they completely failed pre-9/11? > the NSA had identified threats that were the most serious for years and akin to levels of "terrorist chatter" picked up before 9/11. At that time it wasn't enough to cause any action, but now the same information is enough to close multiple embassies for a week? There's just no way to frame this news in a positive way for the NSA.