3 ms·
> Owning and asserting a copyright does not make you a monopolist [...] All property rights are monopolies. Copyright is not a property right, it is exactly a
by tjaerv 13y ago
> Owning and asserting a copyright does not make you a monopolist [...] All property rights are monopolies.
Copyright is not a property right, it is exactly a state-granted monopoly privilege, instituted on ostensibly utilitarian grounds. See http://stpeter.im/writings/essays/publicdomain.html http://stpeter.im/writings/essays/publicdomain.html
Cory Doctorow has elsewhere explained how IP used to be discussed in terms of a "creative monopoly" until the 1970s when the copyright industry began actively promoting the "intellectual property" moniker. The reason? It's a lot easier to go hat in hand to Congress to ask them to protect your "property rights" than to petition them to further extend your monopoly privileges. In much the same way, they'd like to now redefine copying as "theft". "You wouldn't steal a car." Don't fall for it.
- rayiner 13y agoThe modern understanding of copyright is indeed a property right, both legally and and economically. And only in the US is it rooted in the idea of building a public domain. In Europe the basis is the idea of the moral rights of content creators. The Europeans have been a the forefront of extending copyright terms, because within their framework of thinking, there is no reason for copyrights to ever expire.