3 ms·
I think Stephen Hawkins is a great example here. He was an average performing student in his class (albeit a highly advanced course). Many of his lecturers woul
by laumars 13y ago
I think Stephen Hawkins is a great example here. He was an average performing student in his class (albeit a highly advanced course). Many of his lecturers would comment about how lazy he was. It wasn't until his health turned against him that he really started to apply himself. (to paraphrase his life somewhat).
Genius can help - massively. But it doesn't automatically guarantee success.
It's like how Olympic athletes still have to dedicate their lives towards training and competing in their chosen event despite being fortunate enough to posses the right genes.
- wslh 13y agoI didn't say that being a genius is a guarantee to success and the Olympic athletes comparison doesn't exactly fit in the scientific field: only one wins the gold medal each 4 years while there are multiple gold medals opportunities on each instant in science. What I said is that people who are genius in a different scale (I am not talking about a specific measure like IQ) work in a different way. They need to learn and train because the knowledge is not encoded in the DNA but they have so less friction doing this, that one unity of their efforts is like 100 or 1000 of the other genius units. Another skill to take into account is creativity, some people can produce new things with less knowledge and efforts because they see things in a different way.
- laumars 13y ago> the Olympic athletes comparison doesn't exactly fit in the scientific field: only one wins the gold medal each 4 years while there are multiple gold medals opportunities on each instant in science. There are multiple gold medal opportunities in the Olympics. Plus you don't even need to win a gold medal to be an Olympic athlete. It seems to me that you're complaining more about fame than accomplishments; which really isn't anything to do with genius at all. > What I said is that people who are genius in a different scale (I am not talking about a specific measure like IQ) work in a different way. They need to learn and train because the knowledge is not encoded in the DNA but they have so less friction doing this, that one unity of their efforts is like 100 or 1000 of the other genius units. Another skill to take into account is creativity, some people can produce new things with less knowledge and efforts because they see things in a different way. Well yes. But that's such a vague and obvious remark that it borders on being a platitude. And frankly, I'd rather celebrate Turing's achievements than dwell on how much easier he may or may-not have found his work. In much the same way as I like to enjoy good music for it's music rather than moan that creativity comes easier to some artists than it does to me. Like I said before, some people might be lucky enough to be born with a natural aptitude in some areas of life. But they still have to put the effort in to reach the top of their respective fields. And it's that which really matters at the end of the day.
- wslh 13y agoMy main point in the original thread is that, probably, effort for Turing and other geniuses is a different thing that effort for the rest of the mortals. Also, that effort is overrated for geniuses because many of them can do it in a natural way like people walk. Take my other comments as a decoration. I don't think writing a comment in HN is the same that writing a formal proof.