I think you are right about the motives of the FBI, and the reasoning of the copyright cartel. However, there is a relevant difference. The copyright "maximali

I think you are right about the motives of the FBI, and the reasoning of the copyright cartel. However, there is a relevant difference. The copyright "maximalists" seem to think everyone should be able to accurately detect piracy, effortlessly - but in fact it is unreasonable to expect service operators to know the names of the latest Hollywood movies, or to have any way of knowing what files are authorized by the copyright holders, for which recipients, and which are not authorized. In contrast, there are, I assume, signs of CP which would alert any reasonable person - it requires neither special knowledge nor knowledge of other parties' business relations.