3 ms·
It's widely covered here in Latvian local media - the general message is that there are grounds to charge (and likely convict) him with a bunch of crimes locall
by PeterisP 13y ago
It's widely covered here in Latvian local media - the general message is that there are grounds to charge (and likely convict) him with a bunch of crimes locally; but -
1) local prosecution claims that there aren't any grounds to prosecute on ~half of claims that USA wants to charge;
2) defense lawyers claim and popular sentiment (including politicians) believe that USA doesn't have a just/fair court system for computer related crimes;
3) there is a strong position for local jurisdiction in crimes in "cyberspace" - if some action is legal locally, then people shouldn't care if it's illegal in USA; if some crime carries max penalty of 5 years, as is here for computer fraud; then extraditing him for charges of the USA requested 67 years - essentially life sentence - is unacceptable.
- walshemj 13y agoIf they had robed a bank physically would they still not be extradited? And given their neighbors experience with cyber war I woudl have expected Latvia to take this a lot more seriously
- uchi 13y agoRobbing a bank physically is different than online fraud. For one, you're not holding people at gunpoint with the threat of violence.
- walshemj 13y agoyes its worse instead of one large institution that can support the loss you are robbing a million members of Joe public who probably wont be able to suffer that loss as easily. Bonnie an Clyde became folk heroes for striking it to the man they wound not have if they had robbed lots of poor farmers.
- xyzzyz 13y agoJust create a law that forces bank to refund defrauded customers. Now you're robbing one large institution that can support the loss once again, problem solved.
- walshemj 13y agoyeah given the banks track record in dragging their feet over phantom atm withdrawals thats going to work real well. The banks will probably try to blame the victim to avoid paying out you must have shared/written down your banking password and/or start selling cyber insurance which will become the next PPI scam in a few years.
- PeterisP 13y agoFYI, such laws already exist - in EU, most of the consumer losses in such frauds have to be compensated by the bank. It's not always pleasant but it motivates banks to take effective measurements against identity theft. Many of USA identity theft horror stories could never happen here; as soon as their own cash is threatened, banks can be much mire diligent.
- CaptSolo 13y agoIf they robbed a bank physically they'd have to have visited the U.S. and it's clear what country they committed a crime in. It is not as clear-cut when they have never been to the U.S.
- PeterisP 13y agoThe whole point is that if they physically robbed a local branch of an USA bank, stealing money of USA citizens and say, even killing USA citizens in the process, then they wouldn't be extradited nor prosecuted for USA laws. And, by the way, even armed robbery w. killings (IMHO far worse than any amount of theft/fraud) would still carry less penalty than the 67 years currently requested, barring serious aggravating circumstances.
- jordanb 13y agoIt's been long established in international law that the crime occurs where the harm occurs. That's why the Lockerbie bombers were tried in Scotland.
- dragonwriter 13y agoThe Lockerbie bombers were tried in the Netherlands by a Scottish Court under Scots Law, with a weird jurisdictional set up, as part of a negotiated compromise to resolve US/UK demands that they be tried in the US or UK, and Libyan demands that they not be tried in the US or UK, and the location and other arrangements for the trial do not represent any "long-established principle in international law", unless you include the principle that international law is mostly just whatever the involved sovereign states agree to at the time on the specific issue in question.
- smutticus 13y ago>international law is mostly just whatever the involved sovereign states agree to at the time on the specific issue in question. Thank you. I've long made the argument that international law is arbitrary and capricious without much buy-in from those around me. It's good to hear you say it.
- dragonwriter 13y agoI'm not saying that there aren't some fairly well-settled substantive principles of international law that aren't just arbitrary and capricious, I'm just saying that you don't find any of them illustrated by the decision of where to locate the Lockerbie bombing trial. (OTOH, even where there are well-established principles of international law, the absence of consistent enforcement and application leads to them not being inviolate.)
- LekkoscPiwa 13y agoit's difficult to take US seriously when it has 67 year sentences for stuff like this. This is ridicolous. You did it to yourself. It's difficult to take you seriously. This and a global war with a billion Muslims that goes for a decade because some idiots blew up couple of buildings in New York. Are you for real? Wake up!
- mpyne 13y agoCorrespondingly, it's difficult to take people seriously who honestly believe the U.S. is at war with Islam, and not terrorism. Has the U.S. started dropping cluster bombs in Indonesia and I just missed it somehow?
- LekkoscPiwa 13y agoNo, but it has bombed Afghanistan, Iraq, willing to bomb Iran. Heeelllloooooo!
- mpyne 13y agoFirst off, you're claiming that there is 1 common reason underlying all those 3, which you've not proven. But even if we assume that, is your claim that the only thing common amongst those three is the majority religion adhered to in each nation?
- LekkoscPiwa 13y agoyep. This and Mr. Bush claiming that God told him to attack Iraq: http://www.theguardian.com/world/2005/oct/07/iraq.usa http://www.theguardian.com/world/2005/oct/07/iraq.usa I think Bush is when we all started taking the US not really so seriously. Or things like the moment we notice the US population still supports him at large even when he says he has to attack Iraq because God told him so. You're just so immature as people and a nation.
- mpyne 13y ago
- mtgx 13y agoIt's becoming increasingly scarier that US can start extraditing people from other countries because they somehow did some wrong to them because what he did was "on the Internet", and US happens to have a large portion of the traffic - especially when some of these crimes aren't even crimes locally, and what he did was legal in his own country. Imagine if China all of the sudden starts wanting countries to extradite people that talk badly about China or help their citizens avoid censorship or whatever, and imagine they actually had the political power to do that, like US has right now.