2 ms·
Many of the comments here boil down to: At least he's doing something - let him get on with it. If you think you can do better, then do so. To so
by ColinWright 13y ago
Many of the comments here boil down to:
At least he's doing something - let him get
on with it. If you think you can do better,
then do so.
To some extent, I agree with that.
However ...
In the past I've been faced with students who have a serious mental block about some operation, or some process, or some concept, and upon digging deeper into what they believe and why, I have usually come across a moment in their past where someone has taught something badly.
The KA videos are generally great, especially because they teach things differently, and therefore provide an alternate approach, or an alternate viewpoint, and thus provide the opportunity to bolster existing instruction.
They are especially brilliant at providing access for those who are otherwise disenfranchised.
However ...
In some cases they give examples or exercises that experienced teachers know are fraught with the potential for misunderstanding.
I know there are some fantastic people on the KA staff, I have full confidence that problems like this will be sorted out over time, and I desperately wish this letter had been better phrased. But I suspect it wouldn't have got this level of attention had the writer written a respectful note pointing out that recent research advises against the methods being used.
- ScottBurson 13y agoThe letter is blunt and to the point, but what's disrespectful about it? I just watched the first included video, "Understanding decimal place value exercise", and I am flabbergasted. This is pointless; it conveys no understanding whatsoever. In fact, I agree with the letter writer: it gives completely the wrong impression about what the place values mean, suggesting that they're all of the same importance. What would be better would be to have the student pick out a number on a virtual slide rule. You'd have to do some zooming even to get four significant digits; showing seven is probably not worth the trouble (well, maybe do it once to make the point). That would show very graphically the relationship between successive place values.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- grogenaut 13y agoSo why don't you just re-record it correctly and send it in? It would take about as much time as the blog post took to write up.
- jbellis 13y agoKA doesn't accept community-produced videos. Which makes sense if you think about it; it would take more time to vet them than they're worth, on average. Edit: additionally, if he just sent a video with a quick note, KA may continue repeating the same mistake, as they have done over the past year.