3 ms·
No. It is opinion at best. _You_ think his videos are boring; I find them engaging but not precise enough.
by eshvk 13y ago
No. It is opinion at best. _You_ think his videos are boring; I find them engaging but not precise enough.
- mkr-hn 13y agoYes. This is what we're doing here. Sharing our opinions. We rarely have the benefit of solid fact when criticizing things.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- incision 13y agoIs English your first language? Saying that "A are B", particularly with emphasis and without a qualifying introduction isn't a typical way of expressing an opinion.
- mkr-hn 13y agoEnglish is my first language, and I'm decent at it. "Boring" is inherently subjective, so stating that it's an opinion would be redundant. I don't usually need to open a statement like that with "It is in my opinion that..." to make it clear that it's an opinion. This is a weird outlier where a few people are taking it to be a statement of fact. At least as many picked up on the fact that it's an opinion without extra words.
- incision 13y ago>"This is a weird outlier where a few people are taking it to be a statement of fact." I actually agree with you in general, but I don't agree with that bit. I'd say that kind of interpretation is par for the course, particularly on the Internet. I expect it probably has about the same interpretation spread as sarcasm. Some get it, some don't, many learn to simply avoid it. It would be nice everyone could understand and respect what all is inherently subjective, both in statement and response. Imagine many wars of politics, religion, culture and choice of smartphone would disappear overnight. Until that happens, a simple "IMO" goes a long way.
- Symmetry 13y agoBoring is generally a subjective word and when someone say "these are boring" I interpret that to mean that that's just their opinion. But when says "these are boring" I interpret that as the writer trying to overcome the inherent subjectivity of 'boring' by emphasizing the objective 'are', saying in effect "I found this boring and I expect almost any other reasonable person would too."
- badman_ting 13y agoStrangely enough, opinion works as criticism. We're all just stating opinions here, including you. Get over yourself.
- pjscott 13y agoHas appending the phrase "Get over yourself" to an argument ever accomplished anything useful?