3 ms·
Emailing info@ycombinator.com is the way to get these questions answered.
by sjtgraham 13y ago
Emailing info@ycombinator.com is the way to get these questions answered.
- northwest 13y agoAn open discussion has the benefit of generating valuable feedback for PG.
- sjtgraham 13y agoI may or may not agree with you, but my comment only considers HN rules and that there is a strong precedent for these HN-policy meta-discussions to be killed by mods.
- northwest 13y ago> there is a strong precedent for these HN-policy meta-discussions to be killed by mods. If this is true, it would be a pretty sad state of affairs. If such a discussion comes up, it's because of a lack of transparency.
- ColinWright 13y agoIt is true, and for me it is not a sad state of affairs. I've seen more sites killed by excessive meta-discussion than almost anything else. More, true "transparency" frequently just leads to more meta-discussion about the minutiae, and constant bickering about nuances of interpretation. Personally, I think PG is striking a good balance. If you disagree you are, of course, free to go elsewhere and/or start an alternative community, and solve all the problenms in your own way.
- josephpmay 13y agoTo be perfectly honest, I hadn't reviewed the HN guidelines in awhile, and I forgot about that one. If I have an issue in the future I'll be sure to do that, however, I think this discussion is valuable to the HN community, and it would be unwise for me to delete this post.
- mgunes 13y agoIn the past year, I've emailed info@ycombinator.com about what I thought were perfectly legitimate and thought-provoking, yet not-exactly-in-tune-with-the-HN-hive-mind submissions getting axed off the front page by moderators, on more than one occasion. I haven't received a reply.