3 ms·
There is nothing hypocritical about what Apple said. It is absolutely disgraceful for Samsung and Google (Motorola) to use FRAND patents as weapons. It undermi
by threeseed 13y ago
There is nothing hypocritical about what Apple said.
It is absolutely disgraceful for Samsung and Google (Motorola) to use FRAND patents as weapons. It undermines the entire standards process by encouraging companies not to put aside competitive agendas and work together for the benefit of all.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- markdown 13y agoExcept that the ITC ruled that Samsung in fact did NOT fail its FRAND obligations
- josephlord 13y agoFrom what I read they basically said that they didn't care about FRAND commitments.
- belorn 13y agoI guess its perfectly graceful to use obvious patents (which got thrown out from the patent office at reexamination), and minimalistic design patents (which should be a contradiction in terms). Still, since I see it as disgraceful to use any state granted monopoly in efforts to hurt competitors and gain market shares, both Samsung and Apple lacks grace. Arguing who is worse, is like two mass murders arguing over who is more moral and ethical.
- hhw 13y agoNo, it's disgraceful that Apple refuses to abide by FRAND terms i.e. cross-licensing, yet at the same time demands the same or better licensing costs as companies who do abide those terms, and then just uses the patented technology anyway without paying. Nokia was forced to litigate against them for this reason, and rightfully won.