5 ms·
When the Snowden documents were released, I got into a heated debate with a friend, who argued that he has nothing to hide. I heard Bruce Schneider being inter
by jseliger 13y ago
When the Snowden documents were released, I got into a heated debate with a friend, who argued that he has nothing to hide.
I heard Bruce Schneider being interviewed, and he said that people frequently challenge him by saying they have nothing to hide. His two-second retort, especially on call-in shows, is simple: "What's your salary?"
No one wants to answer in public.
- kleiba 13y agoIronically, if you pay taxes, that's something the government doesn't even have to spy on you for.
- lifeformed 13y agoI can list sooo many things people would want to hide: - Salary - Medical history - Home address - Phone number - DOB - SS number - Bank account numbers - Passwords - Photos of yourself - Photos of your children - Job search history (when you are already employed) - What time you'll be out of the house - Porn search history
- diminoten 13y agoIt's because you can't give that information out without also granting write access to a person's life. If there were a way I could give you my SSN/bank information/etc without also granting you the ability to impersonate me, I'd gladly do it.
- lifeformed 13y agoYep, but that's only true for some of those things. Others, like salary and photos of your kids, have other reasons for staying hidden (impact on social situations and safety).
- diminoten 13y agoEh, if I didn't think my company would be upset with me telling you what I make, I'd let you know. It's not a big deal to me. You could probably figure it out based on where I live and what I do with my free time anyway. As for pictures of my kids, I don't have any. But it's a pretty terrible argument because it perpetuates the false idea that you must want to hide something for privacy to be necessary. I'd bet large sums of money Bruce Schneier has never used this line of defense against the "nothing to hide" argument.
- sixbrx 13y agoIf you work somewhere that's anything like places I've ever worked, then I think knowing your salary might have a bigger impact on some of your colleagues than you might think, eventually causing some blowback to come your way. Just my observation from past experience.
- lifeformed 13y agoHiding salary information is usually because it can often create awkward tension in your social groups. Like if your poor friends or family know you make a lot more money than you let show. I know it's not the only reason for privacy, but it's a common and significant one.
- coldtea 13y agoAdultery, casual drug use, problems with drinking, what you said about your boss e.g he's a jerk, and a million other stuff.
- sigkill 13y agoNah man, doesn't always work. Whe I tried that, they said "Nothing to hide from the government, not everyone."
- coldtea 13y agoThen tell them: "You're uninteresting then, it's not about you". And add: "Interesting people that shake up the status quo and make this world a better place, from Ghandi to MLK, HAVE had lots of stuff to hide from the government". "Not to mention that in your shallow mind you only imagine an ever benevolent government. Would you have something to hide if Anna Frank's family asked to stay in your apartment?"
- bajsejohannes 13y agoFun fact: In Norway, everyone's salary is public :) (Well, technically, the amount of taxes paid is public, from which you can make a good guess at salary)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]