3 ms·
Can you expand on what in particular is wrong with this research? I commend you and upvote for asking the follow-up question. I am familiar with the journal, a
by tokenadult 18y ago
Can you expand on what in particular is wrong with this research?
I commend you and upvote for asking the follow-up question. I am familiar with the journal, and with one of the authors of paper mentioned in the submitted article, and while you were asking, I was reading the abstract of the paper to be as familiar with that as I can before the paper is formally published.
I'll adopt the other reply you received to constitute a large part of my reply. I would further add, mentioning a point that I learned from a geneticist, that there is no mention of genes here. Most purportedly "genetic" studies of IQ and the relationship between IQ and something else use pre-Mendelian correlational methods, and never get to the level of detail of identifying genes. Such studies show a lot less about causation than most members of the general public might guess about such nonexperimental studies. And of course the chief problem here is that the study didn't have an experimental design, but was a correlational observational study done by a researcher who admits, in the submitted article, having a preconceived notion of what the relationship would be.
Thanks for asking.